Igor Oystacher faces prosecution for spoofing in Chicago

Chicago judge rules that spoofing is unconstitutional as the end of the road approaches for Igor Oystacher.

After eight months of legal wrangling, a trader who was accused in October of engaging in the dubious practice of ‘spoofing’ when trading on some of the largest electronic derivatives and futures exchanges in the world, may now find himself the subject of a court order.

Yesterday, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) explained to Illinois federal judge Amy St. Eve who was overseeing its case against Igor Oystacher that the statute’s language describing the crime is constitutionally clear.

Spoofing, which is often conducted via disruptive algorithmic trading entities employed by traders to outpace other market participants and to manipulate exchange-traded derivatives markets.

Spoofers feign interest in trading futures, stocks and other products in financial markets creating an illusion of exchange pessimism in the futures market when many offers are being cancelled or withdrawn, or false optimism or demand when many offers are being placed in bad faith.

This practice has become quite a concern for the CFTC recently, as more individuals with seemingly low levels of resources have begun to employ devices that have successfully manipulated markets in this fashion. Usually, spoofing involves placing a bid or offer with intent to cancel before the orders are filled.

igor oystacher

The flurry of activity around the buy or sell orders is intended to attract other high-frequency traders (HFT) to induce a particular market reaction such as manipulating the market price of a security. Spoofing can be a factor in the rise and fall of the price of shares and can be very profitable to the spoofer who can time buying and selling based on this manipulation. Under the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act spoofing is defined as “the illegal practice of bidding or offering with intent to cancel before execution”, giving rise to the censuring by the CFTC of those suspected of engaging in it.

As is often the case with traders attempting to bend the rules, an alias was used in the case of Mr. Oystacher, who was known as ‘990’ before his real identity was discovered.

Clearly, the old adage that by working for a large company, an employee is ‘just a number’ is indeed very poignant in this instance, as Mr. Oystacher adopted this as his identity, it being the identification code assigned to the company that he worked for in 2004 when the chief dealer at Kingstree Trading LLC in Chicago noticed something very unusual in the Standard & Poor 500 futures market.

The dealer scrutinized the market activity and observed as ‘990’ created an unprecedented display of market manipulation.

At that point, the dealer alerted a senior executive at the company and when the mainstream news agencies discovered this, both men refused to be named for fear of retribution.

By the end of 2004, ‘990’ had become a feared entity within the derivatives exchanges of Chicago. The forums and message boards became awash with references to these three numbers, and many traders and industry professionals petitioned the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (Now CME Group) to put a stop to this trader’s access.

Investigations were made and the true identity of the culprit was revealed to be a young Russian man who had dropped out of Northwestern University to work for Chicago-based proprietary trading firm Gelber Group LLC.

Some rather astonishing 11 years after Mr. Oystacher had begun his spoofing spree, the CFTC filed a complaint against him and his firm, 3Red Trading LLC, accusing him of cheating on some of the largest futures exchanges in the world.

It took 11 years to do this, because at the time of Mr. Oystacher’s activity, the Dodd-Frank Act was non-existent and it was only post-2010 that spoofing became recognized as unlawful post implementation of the Dodd-Frank Act.

Even so, Mr. Oystacher’s original complaint in October last year has resulted in a long, drawn out litigious study as to whether this is constitutionally illegal or not.

Yesterday, it was ruled that there is a case for prosecution and as a result, the judge will likely file a case in which Mr. Oystacher will have to return to court for

In some cases, spoofers can be sent to jail.

Just over a year ago, British trader Navinder Singh Sarao was prosecuted for a spoofing scheme which he operated from a bland, beige suburban semi-detached house in Hounslow, England, next to Heathrow Airport.

It was estimated that Mr. Singh Sarao made $900,000 per day as a result of his activities, equating to a total of $27 million, all of the transactions having been made, according to the prosecution, at Mr. Sarao’s home which is directly opposite his parents’ equally innocuous home, where Nav Sarao Futures was registered.

His activities went unnoticed by U.S. investors and regulators, who spent months investigating the mystery crash and eventually concluded that it was down to market conditions at the time.

Since then, investigations continued and led to Mr. Sarao, who is now alleged by prosecutors to have played a major role in the plunge by using tactics known as ‘layering’ and ‘spoofing’ on the day of the May 2010 crash.

Accused of causing a flash crash to the tune of $800 billion in the US stock market, Mr. Singh Sarao faced extradition as the judgement against him meant that he could be sent to the US to answer 22 counts of wire fraud, commodities fraud and market manipulation carrying a maximum sentence of 380 years’ imprisonment.


Read this next

Digital Assets

US wants Bittrex to settle federal dues before compensating customers

The U.S. government has raised objections to Bittrex’s proposal to compensate its customers, adding to concerns about the resolution of the crypto exchange’s bankruptcy case.

Digital Assets

Binance prepares to suspend US dollar funding after SEC crackdown

Binance.US said it will temporarily suspend US dollar deposits and provided customers with a deadline to withdraw their fiat balances. This decision comes after the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a lawsuit requesting the freezing of Binance’s assets in the country.

Digital Assets

Januar launches real-time payments network to fill gap made by Silvergate and Signature

“To all the entrepreneurs and innovators out there is a clear message: if you are a legitimate European business working with crypto then Januar is here to provide you with the account and payment infrastructure you need to operate successfully and build the financial system of tomorrow.”

Retail FX

Exness’ active clients top 515K as monthly volume hits $3.35 trillion

FX trading volumes are climbing again as economic uncertainty spurred by recent developments over central banks’ policies encouraged speculators to pile back into the market.


Danske Bank plans signficant investment in digital platforms

“We have decided to significantly increase our investments in our digital platforms, expert advisory services and sustainability, focusing on the areas where we see the best opportunities for profitable growth.”

Digital Assets

ERD DeFi Lending Platform and USDE Stablecoin Unveiled at EDCON 2023

ERD, the Ethereum Reserve Dollar, is a decentralized lending platform and stablecoin that aims to provide a capital-efficient, decentralized, and stable solution to the challenges faced by the stablecoin industry, introducing a minimum collateralization ratio of 110% and a robust liquidation mechanism.

Institutional FX

CMC Markets acquires 33% stake in UK blockchain firm StrikeX

“This is a major strategic investment in the growing Web 3.0 technology space of which StrikeX Technologies gives us access to the very best technology and advancements. StrikeX is a brilliant, young dynamic company, with a very talented team that has its finger on the pulse of fast moving technologies.”

Digital Assets

Archax utilizes Hedera Hashgraph DLT to tokenize interest in abrdn’s money market fund

“It is exciting to see a tangible application of Archax’s tokenization engine working with Hedera and it paves the way for us to look at creating other digital, blockchain-based token investment solutions.”

Institutional FX

Citi connects directly to Hong Kong’s central clearing and settlement system

“In 2020, we were the first sub-custodian in Hong Kong to offer our clients real-time notification of the trade matching status. The latest solution is a continuation of our efforts to provide a complete suite of services that are as close to real-time as possible.”