66 funds derided as ‘duds’ by UK research and analytics firm

Q: When is a retail FX broker’s stock a better investment than established funds? A: When the funds are duds.

Government Pension Fund of Norway

At the end of last year, when the vast majority of hard-working, dedicated FX industry professionals, brokerages, technology developers, liquidity providers, bankers and traders took a week or more of vacation time and a well deserved seat at the table to enjoy their festivities, the stock market’s winners and losers for 2018 made themselves clear.

Ordinarily, looking at which blue chip pharmaceutical giant or gray suited management consultancy maintained a steady share price through a year of anodyne board meetings, never ending contract renewals and corporate governance policy would be a perfect antidote to insomnia, however at that point something remarkable occurred.

At that time, Retail FX and CFD brokerage Plus500, itself only propelling itself into public listing on the London Stock Exchange’s Alternative Investment Market (AIM) just five years ago as a lean commercial operation became the envy of the retail FX industry with a very clever proprietary digital marketing system that created a massive advantage in terms of operational and customer acquisition efficiency almost by accident just a few years prior at the firm’s original base in Haifa, Israel.

The company, which in terms of headcount and operational size is a fraction of the size of the 30 year established publicly listed electronic trading giants among which it now nestles in London’s Square Mile, and whilst its success and business model is the bete noire of many long term FX industry professionals, this year’s stock market results are testimony to the success of Plus500’s business model.

Unbelievably, Plus500’s stock was the number 2 best performing stock for all of 2018, in every business sector across all of Britain’s publicly listed companies.

Love them or loathe them, the firm’s illusive executives certainly know when to get in and out of deals, as they have entered and exited at exactly the right time on every transaction since the company was founded.

To play devil’s advocate, it could be argued that any monies lost on the company’s b-book platform could be recovered if you own shares in the publicly listed entity itself, and then some!

By contrast, investing in funds is considered a far more sophisticated means of trading the markets, however research by British analytics company FundExpert, the online initiative of 32-year established financial advisory company Dennehy Weller & Co, has identified some 66 under performing funds which would make downmarket Plus500 stock appear very sensible.

The company identifies what it somewhat amusingly terms as ‘dud’ funds as those that only manage to get into the top 40% of performers in its own sector for 20% of the time.

Its new list of ‘dud’ funds identifies products from major banks such as South African financial giant Investec’s Target Return Bond fund as the worst performer, ahead of HC Kleinwort Hambros Equity Income and Royal Bank of Scotland Extra Income in second and third positions respectively.

The ‘time’ aspect is the 120 overlapping 6-monthly periods in the last 10 years – with a higher weighting being given to more recent periods. For example, a fund with a score of 14.2% has only been in the top 40% of performers 14.2% of the time in the last 10 years. These are not just the bottom 20% of funds but those that are consistently dragging along the bottom of their sector.

Sam Lees, head of research at FundExpert told the Daily mail that investors with a portfolio full of duds should sell them off, and that there’s no point in holding them.

Mr Lees believes that starting from scratch, a successful method for choosing funds must be a straightforward approach to identify top rated funds, that the underlying process must be clear and understandable, the process must be repeatable, long term evidence of extra growth being achieved must be demonstrated and that his firm back tested various methods for selecting funds back to 1994, with Mr Lees saying that the method which stood head and shoulders above alternatives was what is these days known as Dynamic Fund Ratings.

Interesting that public stock of retail FX firms is more valuable than some actual funds, which appears to be contrary to the perception and to the norm.

Q: When is a retail FX broker's stock a more viable option than some established fund portfolios? A: When the portfolios are dud.
Source: Daily Mail

Read this next


The FX Algo Wheel, is it wheels up and ready to take flight?

by David Catterick, Sales Director, BidFX Australia

Retail FX

eToro users now can trade underlying Italian stocks

Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company eToro has expanded its service offering and trading products by incorporating new markets, namely Italian stocks listed at underlying exchanges.

Digital Assets

BlackRock bets on crypto bank Silvergate despite drastic fall

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, has increased its stake in Silvergate Bank, a crypto-friendly lender that counts major crypto exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken as clients.


A viewpoint from Anatoly Crachilov, CEO and Founding Partner at Nickel Digital, on SEC regulation of the digital asset sector

The SEC’s latest episode comes across as more of a PR performance rather than an act of investor protection.

Digital Assets

Tether denies receiving any loans from Celsius, the opposite is true

World’s largest stablecoin issuer, Tether dismissed reports suggesting that it received a $2 billion loan from the bankrupt cryptocurrency lender Celsius.

Institutional FX

Cboe FX volume makes strong rebound in January

Cboe’s institutional spot FX platform today announced its trading volume for the month ending January 2023, which marks a mild rebound after a steep fall in December.


XS.com appoints Exness alumni Mohamad Ibrahim as CEO

XS.com, the multi-regulated financial services provider, has appointed Mohamad Ibrahim as the group’s newest chief executive officer (CEO).


B2Broker Integrates Match-Trader Solution to Expands Its White Label Liquidity Offering

A global provider of technology and liquidity for the FX and cryptocurrency markets, B2Broker recently announced the extension of its white label liquidity offering by merging with Match-Trader.

Digital Assets

UK launches open consultation to regulate crypto exchanges, custody, and lending

The government’s proposed measures have been informed by recent market events – including the failure of FTX – which reinforce the case for effective regulation and sector engagement.