Alleged crypto fraudsters insist My Big Coin is not “commodity”

Maria Nikolova

In the face of a Court ruling that My Big Coin is a virtual currency, and hence, a commodity under the CEA, Randall Crater insists on the opposite.

Less than two months after Judge Rya W. Zobel of the Massachusetts District Court nixed a motion to dismiss a case targeting Randall Crater, his company My Big Coin Pay and a number of other entities associated with this cryptocurrency scheme, the defendants have filed their answers to the complaint by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The opposition can be summarized as: whereas Bitcoin is a commodity, My Big Coin is different from Bitcoin, and, hence, is not a commodity.

The defendants’ arguments run counter Judge Zobel’s findings. The Judge ruled in September this year that virtual currencies are commodities under the CEA.

Commodity is a defined term in the CEA, the Judge noted. It includes a raft of specifically enumerated agricultural products as well as “all other goods and articles … and all services rights and interests … in which contracts for future delivery are presently or in the future dealt in.”

The defendants contend that because “contracts for future delivery” are indisputably not “dealt in” My Big Coin, it cannot be a commodity under the CEA. The CFTC responds that a ‘commodity’ for purposes of the CEA definition is broader than any particular type or brand of that commodity. Pointing to the existence of Bitcoin futures contracts, the regulator argues that contracts for future delivery of virtual currencies are “dealt in” and that My Big Coin, as a virtual currency, is therefore a commodity.

The text of the statute supports the CFTC’s argument, the Judge said back in September.

“Here, the amended complaint alleges that My Big Coin is a virtual currency and it is undisputed that there is futures trading in virtual currencies (specifically involving Bitcoin). That is sufficient, especially at the pleading stage, for plaintiff to allege that My Big Coin is a “commodity” under the Act”, the Judge said.

In the most recent Court filings, the defendants disregard the Court’s arguments. Randall Crater simply reiterates that he denies that the My Big Coin currency is a “commodity”. He claims that “My Big Coin is not sufficiently related to Bitcoin, the only virtual currency on which futures contracts are traded, to conclude that My Big Coin is a good, article, service, right or interest on which contracts for future delivery are dealt in, and, therefore, My Big Coin is not a “commodity” as defined in the Commodity Exchange Act”.

Thus, he argues, the Court should dismiss the CFTC Complaint with prejudice.

Let’s recall that the amended CFTC complaint alleges a fraudulent virtual currency scheme in violation of the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). According to the CFTC allegations, Crater and the other defendants operated a virtual currency scheme in which they fraudulently offered the sale of a fully-functioning virtual currency called “My Big Coin”. In summary, the defendants enticed customers to buy My Big Coin by making various untrue and/or misleading statements and omitting material facts. The falsities included that My Big Coin was “backed by gold,” could be used anywhere Mastercard was accepted, and was being “actively traded” on several currency exchanges.

The defendants also made up and arbitrarily changed the price of My Big Coin to mimic the fluctuations of a legitimate, actively-traded virtual currency. When victims of the fraud purchased My Big Coin, they could view their accounts on a website but “could not trade their MBC or withdraw funds”. The defendants obtained more than $6 million from the scheme.

The case is captioned Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. My Big Coin Pay, Inc. et al (1:18-cv-10077).

Read this next

Digital Assets

BlackRock digs further into crypto with metaverse ETF

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager with almost $10 trillion in AUM, is set to launch a new metaverse ETF to help investors securely monetize on the booming immersive version of the internet.

Digital Assets

Binance wins license in New Zealand as rival Huobi shutters derivatives

Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange by traded volume, has obtained licenses to operate in New Zealand, even after rival Huobi shutdown derivatives trading last month due to concerns about regulations.

Retail FX

Hong Kong busts perpetrators of ‘ramp and dump’ scam

Hong Kong’s financial watchdog, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), has charged thirteen suspects of market manipulation in a joint operation with the local police.

Institutional FX

TradingView integrates market data from German Tradegate exchange

TradingView announced that it ‎has increased data coverage to allow its users to receive information from ‎and get free access to the intra-day and tick data from Tradegate Exchange.

Retail FX

Spotware Systems introduces Custom Push Notifications for cTrader mobile apps

Spotware Systems, a technology provider for the electronic trading industry, is introducing a new push notification feature to alert mobile users of price swings and market fluctuations through their cTrader app.

Market News

The Week Ahead: 30 September from David Madden, Market Analyst at Equiti Group

Sterling dominated the headlines last week, as there were concerns the UK government might struggle to service its debt.

Inside View

How does the quality of signal providers affect your business?

A must-have onboarding process for brokers with investment services like PAMM, MAM, or copy trading


DBS deploys Nasdaq Trade Surveillance

“The confidence that markets and our clients have in DBS as a safe and trusted banking group is anchored on our ability to detect and respond to anomalous activity, which in turn calls for a robust surveillance and prevention infrastructure.”

Industry News

SEC charges Justin Costello and David Ferraro for securities fraud and posing as billionaire veteran

The Securities and Exchange Commission charged Cannabis executive Justin Costello and David Ferraro, an associate of Costello’s, for promoting the stock of several microcap companies on social media without disclosing their own simultaneous stock sales as market prices rose.