Another Win for XRP in SEC v Ripple Case

Rick Steves

Although there is growing optimism among Ripple co-founders and XRP holders, Brad Garlinghouse said the firm is ready to march on without the XRP-based settlement platform if it loses the legal battle against the US regulator.

new york

Ripple Labs and its co-founders are on a roll as Judge Sarah Netburn provided another win in the lawsuit that many experts say may determine the future of crypto regulation.

The lawsuit, which complaint was filed the day before former Chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission left the position, is based on the premise that XRP is a security and thus under the scope of the SEC.

The use of the Howey test is a key factor for the SEC action. The test which is relied upon for more than 70 years is used to determine whether a transaction should be classified as an investment contract and therefore registered as a security.

A recently published research paper by Professors at Rutgers Law School argues that the Howie test is no longer suitable for judging 21st-century innovations.

Ripple co-founder Brad Garlinghouse, however, said he is hopeful that both sides can have a meaningful conversation and settle the matter once the new SEC administration is confirmed by the U.S. Senate.

The incoming chairman, Gary Gensler, is said to be more open-minded towards cryptocurrency and he did make positive comments about Bitcoin in the past.

Judge rejects SEC access to defendants personal information


The latest win for Ripple
was that Judge Sarah Netburn granted the defendants’ motion to reject the SEC’s access to eight years of co-founders Garlinghouse and Larsen’s personal information.

Prior to that, Judge Analisa Torres had granted XRP investors’ request to submit a motion to intervene.

The SEC argued that “if the Court permitted Movants to intervene, all other XRP holders, including a large class of XRP investors who has already sued Defendant Ripple Labs, Inc. (“Ripple”) for unregistered offers and sales of XRP securities, would likely seek to intervene, too. Intervention would thus create an “avalanche” of claims and “near-certainty of undue delay, complexity, and confusion”.

A significant win for the cryptocurrency firm was determined in April 6. U.S. Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn ruled in favor of granting Ripple Labs access to the SEC internal discussions over cryptocurrencies.

Mr. Garlinghouse’s counsel Matthew Solomon believes that it could be “game over” for the whole case if the defense finds information suggesting the SEC thinks or thought XRP was akin to bitcoin or ether, which would be outside the scope of the SEC.

In March, Judge Torres dropped a ‘bombshell: “My understanding about XRP is that not only does it have a currency value but it has a Utility and that utility distinguishes it from Bitcoin and Ether.” The statement admits to XRP’s utility and currency value.

Although there is growing optimism among Ripple co-founders and XRP holders, Brad Garlinghouse said the firm is ready to march on without the XRP-based settlement platform if it loses the legal battle against the US regulator.

“We could do that. We’ve always thought about our product as ‘How do we solve a customer’s problem first and foremost?’”

Mr. Garlinghouse also called the lawsuit “ironic” as it is based on the premise that Ripple illegally sold XRP as an unregistered security, although the regulator says the courts will ultimately determine the status of the crypto asset.

“I find a certain irony that the SEC would bring a lawsuit against us because what they’re saying is not just that we should have known and we’ve acted in bad faith when the SEC themselves haven’t really said, well they know for sure that XRP is a security.

“In their own court filings, they said that the court will determine that, which of course, brings a contradiction that if the court’s going to determine that, how could I personally have known that the SEC would view XRP as a security”, he said.

 

Read this next

Digital Assets

Bybit under pressure from Ontario regulator after being forced out of the UK

Bybit has recently been forced to close its operations in the United Kingdom following the ban on Crypto CFD products earlier this year. 

Digital Assets

‘Rat Poison’: XRP, BTC, ETH, ADA, DOGE rebound despite JP Morgan survey

Interestingly enough, when asked about their personal investments, 40% of them were actively trading cryptocurrencies.

Industry News

FTX and MLB partner together for brand awareness and innovation

FTX, one of the largest crypto exchanges in the world that has been on an expansion spree, has announced that it has tied up with Major League Baseball (MLB) in the US for brand awareness.

Digital Assets

Polygon (MATIC) and Aave grant recipient tie up to incentivise new users with rewards

Polygon (MATIC), a Layer 2 solution on Ethereum, has tied up with Aave grant recipient RabbitHole to incentivise new users for making deposits into Polygon.

Digital Assets

John McAfee, software pioneer and a big crypto supporter, dies in Spanish jail

John McAfee, the founder of the anti-virus software which was a household name a couple of decades back and a huge crypto enthusiast, has died in a Spanish jail on the same day that a court allowed him to be extradited to the US.

Industry News

TraderEvolution Global partners with TradingView: Brokers to enjoy direct access

The multi-asset platform is now connected to TradingView’s network of venues, liquidity pools, and asset classes 

Digital Assets

Visa and Paypal invest heavily into $300 million blockchain fund

Visa and Paypal, behemoths that have been known supporters of the blockchain domain, have invested in Fund V of Blockchain Capital.

Opinion

FX Trading is a business: If you want results, act like a professional. Go Prime of Prime!

Trading the markets is a business. It is no wonder that the ones that see it as gambling are willing to trade against the house, but retail traders that want results, they must act like professionals.

Digital Assets

Celsius acquires MVP workshop as it looks to build more on crypto

Celsius, one of the largest cryptocurrency lending and rewards earning platforms, has announced that it has acquired the development division of MVP Workshop as it looks to expand its development team.