Australia wants to ban PFOF as practice comes under greater scrutiny

Rick Steves

“Payment-for-order-flow arrangements create conflicts of interest that can lead to poor client outcomes. It can also negatively impact market liquidity and pricing. In our view, these harms outweigh the benefits.”

ASIC has proposed amendments to the prohibition on order incentives in the ASIC market integrity rules after having identified that its rules do not deal with certain payment-for-order-flow scenarios such as arrangements between non-market participant intermediaries.

Australia’s financial watchdog wants to close this regulatory gap, although it admits payment for order flow is not prevalent in the Australian equity market.

With the rise of payment for order flow (PFOF) in other markets, especially in the United States, and their controversial impact, regulators across the globe have been taking a closer look at it.

PFOF  is an arrangement whereby one person buys client order flow from another person, in exchange for a payment or other incentive. It is currently prohibited among market participants.

According to Australia’s regulatory framework, a market participant must not, directly or indirectly, make a cash payment to another person for their order flow, if the cash payment leads to the net cost being less than the value of the reported price for the transaction(s).

‘Net cost’ means that a market participant cannot pay more for order flow than the commission received by the market participant for those orders – that is, it prohibits PFOF if it results in a ‘negative commission’”, ASIC explained.

“Payment-for-order-flow arrangements create conflicts of interest that can lead to poor client outcomes. It can also negatively impact market liquidity and pricing. In our view, these harms outweigh the benefits.”

This has led ASIC to consider the application of the existing prohibition on payment for order flow in the context of recent developments in Australia and abroad. A

The regulator’s proposal aims to amend the current prohibition with a proactive measure intended to avoid the emergence of payment for order flow arrangements in Australia. The consultation period will end on 3 November 2021.

PFOF has come under great scrutiny after the short squeeze in the Gamestop share triggered by the army of small traders gathered in the WallStreetBets subreddit. On the other side of the trade were mostly short order from Melvin Capital.

Robinhood was forced to restrict trades, claiming it could not deal with the t+2 settlement cycle under so much market volatility. The neobroker has a PFOF agreement with Citadel Securities, which in turn kept Melvin Capital liquid with a $2 billion injection during the short squeeze.

The Robinhood – Citadel – Melvin Capital triangle triggered the rise of conspiracy theories among small investors on social media platforms.

Read this next

blockdag

Top Crypto Highlights for Q2 2024: BlockDAG’s Astonishing 1120% Growth Compared to Solana’s Surge and Toncoin’s Market Triumph

Explore the latest highlights in cryptocurrency: Solana’s recovery, Toncoin’s record levels, and the rise of BlockDAG’s innovative technology.

Digital Assets

Ripple seeks $10 million penalty citing Terraform fine in SEC case

Ripple Labs wants to reduce the financial penalties proposed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by leveraging recent fines imposed on Terraform Labs.

Digital Assets

Swiss regulator shuts down CoinShares’ partially-owned FlowBank

Switzerland’s financial regulator, FINMA, has closed FlowBank SA and placed it into bankruptcy due to severe breaches of capital requirements and other supervisory laws. This follows a series of enforcement actions against the bank that began in October 2021.

blockdag

Presale Power Players: 5 Crypto Presales Primed for Success in 2024 According to Experts

Unlock the potential of the best presale cryptos available now. See why experts recommend BlockDAG, Bitbot, eTukTuk, 99Bitcoins Token, and ButtChain.

Executive Moves

Paxos axes 65 jobs, cuts headcount to below 300

Stablecoin issuer Paxos has laid off 65 employees, equating to 20% of its staff, despite maintaining a robust financial standing.

Institutional FX

US sanctions trigger major shifts in Russian FX market, says Sergey Romanchuk

The U.S. sanctions imposed on June 12 against the Moscow Exchange and its clearing entity, the National Clearing Center (NCC), are set to cause massive disruptions in the Russian currency market, according to FX industry veteran Sergey Romanchuk.

blockdag

BlockDAG’s X1 Miner App Beta Sparks $49.2M Presale Rise; Uniswap & XRP Whales Getting Involved?

Experience BlockDAG’s meteoric 1120% presale rise, Uniswap’s UNI climbing 18%, and Ripple’s XRP anticipating ETF approval. Explore their latest breakthroughs!

Market News, Tech and Fundamental, Technical Analysis

GBPUSD Technical Analysis Report 13 June, 2024

GBPUSD currency pair can be expected to fall further toward the next support level 1.2700, which has been reversing the price from last month.

Institutional FX

U.S. sanctions halt dollar and euro trading on Moscow Exchange

New U.S. sanctions against Russia have led to the immediate suspension of trading in dollars and euros on the Moscow Exchange (MOEX), the country’s largest exchange group.

<