Bank Policy Institute criticizes US Govt approach in lawsuit against ex-Deutsche Bank traders

Maria Nikolova

BPI seeks to file a letter explaining its position as a part of the case targeting former Deutsche Bank AG metals traders James Vorley and Cedric Chanu.

The approach of the United States government in a case targeting former Deutsche Bank AG metals traders James Vorley and Cedric Chanu has come under fire.

On Wednesday, January 23, 2019, Bank Policy Institute (BPI) filed a motion with the Illinois Northern District Court asking for permission to submit a brief amicus curiae in support of the defendants’ motion to dismiss the indictment. An amicus curiae is someone who is not a party to a case and is not solicited by a party, but who assists a court by offering information that bears on the case.

BPI is a nonpartisan public policy, research, and advocacy group, representing many of the US banks and their customers.

Let’s recall that the Indictment alleges that Vorley and Chanu engaged in “spoofing” in the commodities futures market – entering orders on electronic futures exchanges that the defendants intended to cancel before they were executed.

BPI argues that, given that spoofing is already a crime under the CEA, and requires that the government prove certain elements so as to avoid inadvertently reaching legitimate forms of trading, the government’s attempt to fall back on allegations of generalized violations of the wire fraud statute to charge alleged spoofing is misguided. According to BPI, the government should not be permitted to expand the scope of the generally-applicable wire fraud statute and skirt the specific anti-spoofing provisions in the CEA that reflect the specialized statutes and rules crafted by Congress and the CFTC for the futures market.

BPI argues that the government’s theory of prosecution poses at least two clear risks to the interests of BPI’s members.

First, if the government’s theory is ratified by the Court, any offer to enter into a transaction that makes only accurate factual representations and that would result in a binding contract if accepted, could be a crime. This may happen if the party making the offer hoped it would not be accepted and planned to withdraw it in the future before a transaction occurred. Sophisticated parties, in dealing with one another, regularly have occasion to make representations or take positions that may not reflect their hoped-for or ideal outcome, but which nevertheless would form the basis of a deal if accepted against the unexpressed hopes of the offeror, the organization explains.

Second, according to BPI, the government’s theory would allow the government retroactively to charge violations of yet-to-be-articulated rules of conduct as criminal fraud. Conduct related to negotiations completed a decade ago could be unearthed and subject to the new, broader view of criminal conduct reflected in the indictment.

BPI requests that it be permitted to file its brief no later than February 6, 2019.

Read this next

Fintech

Ouinex taps Netdania to build institutional-grade crypto trading platform

Ouinex intends to always bring the best of TradFi electronic trading infrastructure to Web3 including innovative universal cross-margining capabilities so that users can trade TradeFi instruments by using their crypto holdings as margin.

Retail FX

BDSwiss Elevates Traders’ Experience with Advanced Trading Tools

In the fast-paced world of financial markets, having access to advanced trading tools and educational resources is crucial for traders aiming to stay ahead of the curve.

Market News

Gold & Silver rally, made in China

Gold prices correlate with the US bond market, and the US Dollar influences the Gold/Silver ratio. Chinese market premiums for Gold and Silver suggest continued uptrends. Inflation-adjusted peaks indicate current prices are not overly expensive, implying potential for further gains.

Market News

Japan’s Monetary Policy and FX Intervention: Key Takeaways from the G20 Meeting

At the G20, BoJ President Kanda and Finance Minister Suzuki emphasized stable exchange rates and cautious FX intervention, signaling imminent action. Softer US inflation data and potential BoJ rate hikes are impacting USD/JPY

blockdag

Top 3 Cryptos of 2024: BlockDAG’s $1 Prediction, Immutable’s Remarkable Price Increase, and Solana’s Promising Future

Explore pivotal changes in the cryptocurrency market through our analysis of Solana, Immutable, and BlockDAG. Explore how BlockDAG raised $34.7M in its presale with advanced technologies.

Fintech

UK bank Kroo bans crypto transactions, warns account closure

London-based digital bank Kroo has imposed a ban on cryptocurrency transactions, another blow for crypto traders ‎who recently saw a sizable number of banks deciding not to ‎finance the wobbly asset class.‎

Web3

MoonPay onboards Gucci, Puma, and Mastercard to Web3 Tools

Blockchain payments infrastructure firm MoonPay has unveiled a new platform to simplify the Web3 experience for brands and consumers. The platform, dubbed Web3 Tools, helps brands provide a less complex Web3 journey.

blockdag

BlockDAG’s Keynote Video Drives $34.7M in Presales, Gaining Traction Among Solana (SOL) Investors and Litecoin Enthusiasts

Discover BlockDAG’s leadership in cryptocurrency, attracting Solana (SOL) investors and Litecoin enthusiasts with its strong growth prospects and groundbreaking mining technology. 

Digital Assets

Mt. Gox users alarmed by $10 billion transfer to unknown wallet

Mt. Gox has transferred 42,830 BTC, worth about $2.9 billion, from its cold wallets, according to Arkham Intelligence data. This marks the first major transfer from the defunct bitcoin exchange in five years.

<