IG Group, CMC Markets and Plus500 share prices crash due to FCA CFD ruling

Breaking news IG Group, CMC Markets and Plus500 share prices crash due to FCA ruling on CFD products and leverage cap

Andrew Saks

The ruling today by the Financial Conduct Authority has had a decimating effect on the share prices of IG Group (down 22%), Plus500 (down 38%), and CMC Markets (down 23%) as CFDs – the core business of most British electronic trading firms – are subject to leverage caps and further restrictions. All this effect on top quality firms, yet the British authorities turn a blind eye to binary options fraud whilst other countries take action

This morning, FinanceFeeds reported that the Financial Conduct Authority in Britain has imposed restrictions on the method by which contracts for difference (CFDs) are

the regulator’s view being that Contracts for differences, such as spread bets and rolling spot foreign exchange products, are complex financial instruments offered by electronic trading firms and that following an increase in the number of firms in the CFD market, the FCA has concerns that more retail customers are opening and trading CFD products that they do not adequately understand.

The FCA’s analysis of a representative sample of client accounts for CFD firms found that 82% of clients lost money on these products.

In Britain, CFDs and spread betting are very popular indeed, whereby some of the highest quality electronic trading firms in the world, some of which are publicly listed, provide these products via proprietary platforms to a discerning British audience of loyal customers.

The FCA is therefore proposing a package of measures intended to enhance consumer protection by limiting the risks of CFD products and ensuring that customers are better informed. The new measures include:

  • Introducing standardised risk warnings and mandatory disclosure of profit-loss ratios on client accounts by all providers to better illustrate the risks and historical performance of these products.
  • Setting lower leverage limits for inexperienced retail clients who do not have 12 months or more experience of active trading in CFDs, with a maximum of 25:1.
  • Capping leverage at a maximum level of 50:1 for all retail clients and introducing lower leverage caps across different assets according to their risks. Some levels of leverage currently offered to retail customers exceed 200:1.
  • Preventing providers from using any form of trading or account opening bonuses or benefits to promote CFD products.

This has caused a tremendous reduction in the share prices of three of Britain’s largest and most widely respected electronic trading firms, all of whom’s core business is retail market CFD trading via sophisticated proprietary platforms.

IG Group, Britain’s second largest electronic trading and investments firm after Hargreaves Lansdown, which has a market capitalization of £2.25 billion, has experienced a tremendous 21.9% drop in share prices today down to 614p per share.

Also affected is Plus500, the evergreen example of efficiency with no sales staff, very light operating costs and a digital marketing solution that is the envy of the entire retail business.

Plus500 took an astonishing 38% hit on its share prices this morning, taking its value down to £365 million. Just two years ago, this was a $1 billion company.

CMC Markets whose market capitalization is £406 million and has recently developed its next generation proprietary trading platform at a cost of $100 million, has experienced a 23% decline in share price this morning.

This, therefore is a dark day for the established and highly respected public firms in the world’s largest and most sophisticated financial center – London.

Whilst regulatory prowess and consumer protection is vital in today’s electronic trading industry, not just for the protection of customer interests but also for the longevity and prestige of the companies in top quality jurisdictions, and whilst FinanceFeeds fully supports good quality regulation and will always stand with the top level companies and their leaders in this industry, it is very important to point out that the FCA has taken this step, decimating the values of quality stock, yet continues to turn a blind eye to the fraudulent OTC binary options brands and their associated entities that continue to run amok in Britain whilst other nations across the world ban them outright and arrest the perpetrators.

Britain’s firms are those among the most reputable worldwide, and the longevity of their client bases in their own domestic market is testimony to this, as is their public and commercial profile, therefore the FCA would be better served rounding up the binary options fraudsters before moving in on the upper levels of the retail trading industry.

Whilst the general sentiment among industry leaders in Britain does concur that this is just an adjustment and that prices will rebound, there is a degree of agreement with the FCA’s ruling.

One particular institutional FX industry executive told FinanceFeeds this morning “This is purely an adjustment, and overall it is good for the industry. Find me a futures exchange where you can put 1% down as initial margin – it’s unheard of.”

“If you trade DAX or FTSE on exchange it’s probably more like 4%/5%, which is 20/25:1. The reason for crazy leverage is because of the b-bookers as an STP model can’t run on crazy leverage, therefore I concur that this is a good move” he continued.

As always, there are two ways to look at what constitutes regulatory prowess.

ig
IG Group stock price. Source: Google Finance
cmc
Source: Google Finance
capture
Source: Google Finance

 

 

 

Read this next

Inside View

Stable Scandinavia: Nordic currencies going for absolute gold. We get the inside view

Following a Bloomberg report that singled out Nordic currencies as ones to watch this year, FinanceFeeds took a look within.

Industry News

Bureaucratic FX industry stifler Gary Gensler tipped as Joe Biden’s new SEC chair

During his term, the CFTC created 68 new rules, orders and guidance’s and extended its regulatory reach to encompass not only exchange-traded derivatives but also the far larger OTC markets as well. Will he cosy up to ESMA?

Industry News

DriveWealth buys US floor trading firm

30% of the DriveWealth’s orders in Q4 2020 were placed outside of normal trading hours

Industry News

The Daily Telegraph calls time on Spread Betting and CFDs

Questor acknowledges that it has openly tipped the shares of CMC Markets in the past, but also that the shares have risen by 269% since then and that selling after such a run would be “prudent”

Inside View

SE Asia’s derivatives trading explosion should make all FX brokers look long and hard

SE Asia has been a region of importance for many years. FX brokers went in en masse, some got a bloody nose, some sold to Chinese firms. Meanwhile, exchange traded contracts for retail clients are at unprecedented highs and sustainable. Going on-exchange and multi-asset is the future for firms wanting to approach Asia.

Opinion

How can FX relationship managers and directors maintain relationships in a Corona world? – Op Ed

“The marketplace is cram packed with FX firms vying for business and the only difference is how their personnel approach and handle the clients” says Meir Velenski

Opinion

How to protect your corporate FX exposure from British pound volatility

The corporate foreign exchange impact from the UK’s divorce from the EU can be mitigated.

Industry News

Bank of Russia joins Global FX Code

We take a look at the ethos and origins of the Global FX Code, and how Russia’s FX brokers may well align with those of the West as a result of the Russian Central Bank’s position

Industry News

The UK chancellor plans a second “Big Bang” for London’s markets

Currently, the chancellor’s vision seems to be long on promise and short on substance