Can Ripple win against SEC’s “but for” angle in lawsuit over XRP?

Rick Steves

John Deaton added that if the SEC were to be successful with its novel “but for” test disguised within the Howey test, all of crypto is in danger as the same argument applies to Vitalik Buterin, Joseph Lubin, Satoshi Nakamoto, and so forth. 

John Deaton, the attorney representing 64,000 XRP holders via Amicus Curiae status in the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit, continues to discuss online details pertaining to the case and the SEC’s thought process.

This time, he focused on if XRP itself is a security per se as he has “been troubled as to why the SEC wouldn’t stipulate that XRP itself (including secondary market XRP) are not securities”.

Judge Analisa Torres has recently ordered the public disclosure of exhibits that are expected to be used against Ripple, including a Brad Garlinghouse email to employees and a Chris Larsen email exchange with an XRP holder looking for answers about price dynamics. Both contents were analyzed by attorney Jeremy Hogan.

Why SEC didn’t get rid of amicus counsel

“After reading these emails and anticipating what the 2012 legal memos likely state, I may finally understand why the SEC won’t stipulate the token itself isn’t a security – a stipulation which would rid the SEC of amicus counsel along w/ his 64K XRP Holders”, said John Deaton.

“When I filed the motion to intervene or in the alternative be granted amicus status, Ripple informed the Court that if the SEC agreed XRP wasn’t a security per se, XRP Holders lacked standing to participate. If, however, the SEC intended to argue XRP itself is a security, Ripple argued XRP Holders should be allowed to participate in the case. The SEC not only refused to stipulate XRP itself isn’t a security, but actually argued all XRP are illegal securities.

I’ve always questioned why. The unsealed emails and legal memos are barely relevant. An illegal securities offering analysis focuses on the promises or inducements made by the promoter to investors leading those investors to anticipate profits from the efforts of the promoter”, he continued.

It will be near impossible to prove any real correlation between XRP’s price and public announcements by Ripple (ie partnerships). The SEC must also prove Garlinghouse and Larsen sold XRP in the USA.”

“In reality, the SEC’s case may be so weak and desperate that it believes the only way to win is to prove that XRP itself is a security per se.

Asserting “but for” theory in this case

John Deaton goes further to say the SEC, in essence, is asserting a “but for” theory in SEC v. Ripple. A broad encompassing theory already recognized by Judge Torres.

“For example, the SEC asserts Ripple created a secondary market for XRP – therefore – all XRP, including XRP traded in the secondary market, are investment contracts w/ Ripple. In short, but for Ripple creating a secondary market there would be no secondary market XRP.

If the two emails abovementioned represent the quality of the SEC’s evidence against Ripple, it may be hard for the plaintiff to prove the XRP was sold within the SEC’s jurisdiction. This leaves the SEC with no other choice than to go with the “but for” theory.

“Thus, the SEC must prove Ripple made promises or inducements that led #XRPHolders to form a reasonable expectation of profits based on the efforts of Ripple, its executives or affiliates. If the truth matters, the SEC will fail miserably attempting to meet that standard.”

John Deaton added that if the SEC were to be successful with its novel “but for” test disguised within the Howey test, all of crypto is in danger as the same argument applies to Vitalik Buterin, Joseph Lubin, Satoshi Nakamoto, and so forth.

Read this next


BlockDAG Targets 20,000x ROI, Excels Beyond Litecoin’s Rise, and Enhances Ethereum Layer 2 Activity

Explore BlockDAG’s promising 20,000X ROI as it leads, with significant developments in Ethereum Layer 2 and a surge in Litecoin’s value post-Dencun upgrade.

Digital Assets

Hong Kong regulators approve spot Bitcoin and Ether ETFs

Hong Kong-based asset managers received approval from regulators on Monday to launch spot Bitcoin and Ether ETFs.

Digital Assets

Vitalik Buterin backs Railgun with $350K, RAIL price triples

Privacy cryptocurrency Railgun (RAIL) skyrocketed over 250% following a positive comment from Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin.

Digital Assets

Uniswap hits $2 trillion in trading volume ahead of SEC’s lawsuit

Decentralized finance (DeFi) exchange Uniswap crossed $2 trillion in total trading volume despite escalating competition from other networks and regulatory setback.


BlockDAG’s $17.3M Presale Success Elevates Security Beyond Ethereum Classic Value and Fantom Trends

Explore how BlockDAG’s advanced security with batch 9 entry and $17.3M raised outshines Ethereum Classic value and Fantom’s market moves.

Institutional FX

Finalto secures two prestigious awards at iFX EXPO LATAM 2024

Trading software and liquidity services provider Finalto received two accolades at the iFX EXPO LATAM 2024 held in Mexico City earlier this month.


SEABW Turns the Spotlight on Southeast Asia’s Flourishing Web3 Landscape With Over 40 Side Events and an All-encompassing Agenda

Southeast Asia Blockchain Week (SEABW), a premier blockchain conference exploring the evolving landscape of Web3 in the Southeast Asia region, is proud to announce that there will be over 40 side events, web3 meetups, workshops, and social gatherings.

Digital Assets

Landesbank Baden-Württemberg to offer crypto custody

Germany’s largest federal bank, Landsbanki Baden-Württemberg (LBBW), partnered with Austrian-based Bitpanda to provide “investment-as-a-service” infrastructure for cryptocurrencies. The new service will offer institutional and corporate clients the ability to store and procure digital assets such as bitcoin and ether.

Digital Assets

VALR Secures Regulatory Licenses from FSCA as a Leading Crypto Asset Service Provider in South Africa

VALR, the prominent crypto exchange backed by Pantera Capital and based in Johannesburg, has achieved a significant regulatory milestone by obtaining both a Category I and Category II license from the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) of South Africa.