Citadel quotes SEC report to battle collusion claims in short squeeze lawsuit

abdelaziz Fathi

Citadel Securities has again asked a Florida judge to dismiss the charges accusing the firm of asking Robinhood to restrict trading on GameStop and other “meme stocks,”, a move that resulted in losses for small investors.

This time, the US market maker is citing the conclusions set out in the SEC’s report on the retail trading mania earlier this year. The US top regulator detailed how the events went down and raised red flags on a number of issues related to the structure of stock markets.

However, the report stopped short of laying blame on hedge funds, clearing houses or other market participants.

And as it turned out, Ken Griffin’s electronic trading firm says a lot of conspiracy theories floated on social media at the time was simply untrue.

The firm explains that the SEC’s report refutes plaintiffs’ argument that “Government investigations are indicative of anticompetitive collusion” and that it was specifically “indicative of collusion” that the SEC is “investigating the events concerning the January 28, 2021 trading restrictions.”

For context, the SEC found that the hedge funds that shorted GameStop stock not only were able to hedge their bets, but also booked substantial profits. Overall, hedge funds were not significantly affected by the short squeeze incident, so the allegations against them appear to be false.

In addition, the US securities regulator said it found no evidence of the so-called “gamma squeeze,” which is caused by the “naked short selling,” where investors short sell shares that have not been affirmatively determined to exist.

To support their point of view, the agency officials noted that GME share price maintained its upward trajectory even after the direct effects of covering short positions waned.

In addition, Citadel said the SEC’s conclusion supports its argument that “the enforcement of Plaintiffs’ claims would create conflict between the Exchange Act and the Sherman Act because the SEC is currently investigating the January 2021 short squeeze events.”

“Although the SEC noted “[o]ne narrative” that “attributed the broker-dealer trading restrictions to pressure from hedge funds and their commercial partners,” the SEC instead concluded: “A number of clearing brokers experienced intraday margin calls from a clearinghouse. In reaction, some broker-dealers decided to restrict trading in a limited number of individual stocks in a way that some investors may not have anticipated,” Citadel said in the legal statement.

Over the last few months, quite a few “Internet conspiracies and Twitter mobs” painted Citadel Securities in a bad light. The firm asked the court to dismiss a multidistrict litigation that centered on allegations that Robinhood and other platforms colluded to freeze stock purchases to spare the market maker losses on short bets.

But looking at the results of the SEC’s investigation, this isn’t exactly what happened . Instead, the report describes a process in which massive trading volumes forced retail brokers to temporarily stop or limit offering meme stocks due to capital requirements.

Wall Street’s central clearing hubs demanded these platforms to deposit billions more in collateral to shield them from the volatility during the trading frenzy. The surge in trading forced Robinhood to draw millions from its credit lines, then turned to existing investors and raised $1 billion to meet margin requirements.

Other defendants in the antitrust action including IBKR, E-Trade, Ally Financial and Apex filed separate memos supporting their motion to dismiss claims for negligence and antitrust.

Read this next


These Altcoins Have The Potential To Make You a Millionaire in 2024

The crypto market is witnessing a surge, and certain alternate coins are catching attention for their rapid growth.

Digital Assets

Point72 invests $77.5 million in Bitcoin, Morgan Stanley holds $269.9 million

Point72, the $34 billion hedge fund owned by billionaire and New York Mets owner Steven Cohen, held $77.5 million in the Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC) at the end of the first quarter, according to a recent filing.

Digital Assets

Binance claims Nigerian officials sought $150 million bribe

A Nigerian court has ruled that Tigran Gambaryan, a Binance executive detained on charges of tax evasion and money laundering, can stand trial on behalf of the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange.

Digital Assets

Kraken reviews Tether listing in Europe ahead of MiCA adoption

Cryptocurrency exchange Kraken is “actively reviewing” whether to delist the stablecoin Tether (USDT) from its European platform, according to a report by Bloomberg.


Discover How MoonBag Coin Presale Stacks Up Against Dogecoin & Litecoin

Discover how the MoonBag Coin presale compares to Dogecoin and Litecoin, with unique features, a robust presale structure, and new opportunities in 2024.

Fundamental Analysis, Market News, Tech and Fundamental

Global FX Market Summary: Federal Reserve Policy, USD, May 17 ,2024

Overall, both the Federal Reserve’s policy and the US dollar’s outlook are shrouded in some degree of uncertainty.

Market News, Tech and Fundamental, Technical Analysis

Ethereum Technical Analysis Report 17 May, 2024

Ethereum cryptocurrency can be expected to rise further toward the next resistance level 3200.00, which is the top of the previous impulse wave i.

Digital Assets

Hong Kong adopts digital yuan payments through Chinese banks

Hong Kong has launched a pilot program enabling digital yuan payments through major Chinese banks, marking the first instance of China’s digital currency project being deployed outside the mainland.

Retail FX

Saxo Bank increases client assets five-fold to $116 billion

Copenhagen-based broker Saxo Bank has achieved a major milestone, surpassing $116 billion (DKK 800 billion) in client assets.