Defrauded Chinese investors insist JPMorgan provided substantial assistance to Ponzi scammer

Maria Nikolova

Although JPMorgan had no fiduciary duty to the investors defrauded by Renwick Haddow, the bank is said to have nevertheless provided substantial assistance to the scammer as its nonfeasance amounts to knowing facilitation of a crime.

A case targeting JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE:JPM) and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. over their alleged aiding and abetting “Bar Works” – a Ponzi scheme operated by Renwick Haddow, continues at the New York Southern District Court. After the defendants sought to rebuff the accusations earlier this month by arguing that they did not provide any substantial assistance to Haddow, the plaintiffs have replied to this attempt for defense.

On Wednesday, March 14, 2018, the counsel for the 245 plaintiffs in the action, captioned ZHAO et al v. JPMorgan Chase & Co., et al (1:17-cv-08570), filed a Letter with the Court.

In the Letter, addressed to the Honorable Naomi Reice Buchwald, the plaintiffs argue again that JPMorgan had actual knowledge of the “Bar Works” fraud. The most solid facts which are seen to support the bank’s actual knowledge involve the notoriety and infamy of the Bar Works scheme’s mastermind, Renwick Haddow. He is also known for other fraudulent schemes, including ones involving Bitcoin. The plaintiffs insist that JPMorgan had been aware of Haddow’s true identity and his fraudulent activities while he presented himself under a fake name in communications with “Bar Works” investors.

The plaintiffs expect that discovery of documents will substantiate their allegations, that a known international fraudster, an individual banned from acting as a company director in his home country, attracted the notice of JPMorgan employees following standard banking practices and the bank’s own KYC/AML policies. Plaintiffs expect to find routine alerts triggered by the defendants’ transaction monitoring system, the contents of the defendants’ KYC file on Renwick Haddow, internal communications among the bank’s employees discussing Haddow’s prior schemes, and other internal documents and communications indicating the bank’s actual knowledge.

The plaintiffs also note the transfers to luxury goods purveyors and foreign accounts outside of the scope of Bar Works’ business, including binary options firms. These, the plaintiffs say, cannot be presumed routine or typical banking transactions, and amounted to substantial assistance.

Substantial assistance occurs when a defendant affirmatively assists, helps conceal or fails to act when required to do so, thus enabling the breach to occur. The general rule is that mere inaction of an alleged aider and abettor constitutes substantial assistance only if the defendant owes a fiduciary duty directly to the plaintiff. JPMorgan has argued that it owes no such duty to the plaintiffs in this case. In their latest Letter, the defrauded investors note New York courts have found substantial assistance, even without a fiduciary duty owed to the plaintiff, when such nonfeasance amounts to knowing facilitation of a crime.

Given the fees that JPMorgan received from Haddow’s bank account transactions, the plaintiffs argue that, at the pleading stage, they have managed to state a sufficient claim under New York law for negligence and unjust enrichment against the bank.

Previously filed documents indicate that the plaintiffs claim combined $16,907,626.00 in damages.

Read this next

Institutional FX

PhillipCapital extends trade surveillance partnership with Eventus

“PhillipCapital has seen first-hand how Validus can scale to meet any capacity requirements as clients grow, as well as our team’s expertise in not only our customizable technology but the market and regulatory challenges facing the industry.”

Market News

Why Yellow Metal Prices are Plummeting

Gold prices have been steadily declining after failing to surpass the resistance zone at $1,650. The current price is at its lowest point in seven months. Strong economic data from the US has triggered a meltdown in the gold market.

Industry News

Nuvei enters China following licenses in Australia, Singapore, and Hong Kong

The expansion into China represents more than just a geographic milestone for Nuvei. It also adds an essential component to the company’s comprehensive suite of alternative payment methods (APMs), which currently counts 634 different options. These APMs play a crucial role in catering to local market preferences, thereby enhancing Nuvei’s value proposition for businesses looking to penetrate new markets within the APAC region.

Institutional FX

LiquidityBook launches LBX PMS 2.0 after acquiring Messer

With this rollout, LiquidityBook aims to meet the diverse requirements of its clientele, ranging from startup hedge funds and asset managers to broker-dealers and outsourced trading desks.

Institutional FX

Celoxica enters Australia to offer low latency market data and execution services in APAC

“There is a significant opportunity to deliver fast and efficient market access to APAC financial market participants, including trading firms, brokers, exchanges, and service providers. I am eager to extend our reach in this crucial market.”

Institutional FX

Cboe to launch four new Credit Volatility Indices (Credit VIX)

“The Credit VIX Indices are expected to provide new clear signals on bond market sentiment, and act as a new barometer of corporate credit risk in North America and Europe.”

Executive Moves

TradeZero hires Leo Ciccone as Chief Compliance Officer (CCO) for TradeZero Canada

“Leo brings to TradeZero broad and comprehensive experience coupled with deep business and regulatory relationships that will assist us in ensuring we meet and exceed industry best practices and to further our growth initiatives going forward,”

Institutional FX

Apex launches fractional fixed income trading for retail investors

“The ability for people – and not just high net-worth investors – to easily add fixed-income and diversify their portfolios is a game-changer.”

Institutional FX

MarketAxess launches Open Trading for EM local currency bonds

In an era where diversification and hedging against market risks have become imperative, this new feature could very well serve as a linchpin for international investors looking to diversify their fixed-income portfolios with EM local currency bonds.