Delaware Supreme Court sides with Interactive Brokers in breach of contract dispute

Maria Nikolova

Equity Trust alleges Interactive Brokers’ choice to not renew an agreement triggered closing fees that Interactive Brokers has refused to pay.

The Supreme Court of the State of Delaware has sided with online trading major Interactive Brokers LLC in a lawsuit over alleged breach of contract brought by Equity Trust Company. In an Order, published on October 26, 2018, the Supreme Court supported an earlier ruling in favor of Interactive Brokers.

Under a service agreement between the parties, Equity Trust provided trust and related services to Interactive Brokers’ customers in connection with the customers’ retirement plans. This agreement provided for automatic renewal on the first day of the next year unless either party gave sixty days’ notice that it would terminate the agreement. In October 2016, Interactive Brokers gave notice that it would not renew the agreement for 2017.

Equity Trust alleges Interactive Brokers’ choice to not renew the agreement triggered closing fees that Interactive Brokers has refused to pay. Equity Trust claims the fees are owed under Section 2(k) of the service agreement. Equity Trust brought a claim for breach of contract.

The Superior Court granted Interactive Brokers’ motion to dismiss, holding that the contract provided the parties with a non-renewal option and exercising that option did not trigger any closing fees. Equity Trust then appealed from that decision. The Supreme Court reviews motions to dismiss de novo.

In the Order issued on Friday, the Supreme Court finds that the Superior Court correctly rejected Equity Trust’s argument that declining to renew the agreement prompted the payment of fees. The agreement shows that the obligation to pay closing fees is triggered not when the entire agreement is terminated, but rather when individual accounts are closed. Section 2(k), which is the basis for the alleged breach, requires Interactive Brokers to “pay all Equity Trust fees for Accounts closed during a calendar quarter and all quarterly trustee fees for all open Accounts.”

Thus, according to the Court, closing fees are payable only on the closing of “Accounts.” “Accounts” are in turn defined as “retirement plan accounts established by Customers,” with “Customers” defined as Interactive Brokers’ customers. Therefore,“Account” means an individual retirement plan account; that is, an account that an Interactive Brokers customer has with Interactive Brokers. Customers do not have “Accounts” with Equity Trust, which is only the trustee of the retirement plans. That means that the obligation to pay a closing fee is triggered only when an Interactive Brokers customer’s account is closed.

At no point in the complaint does Equity Trust plead facts supporting a rational inference that all the “Accounts” were closed. In fact, the complaint alleges that Interactive Brokers merely “assumed control of the Accounts,” “removed Equity Trust’s name from the Accounts,” and substituted itself “as trustee for the Accounts.” Those statements imply that Interactive Brokers did not close the Accounts, but instead just replaced Equity Trust as trustee once the agreement expired.

The Supreme Court notes that if Equity Trust wanted the non-renewal of the agreement to result in automatic Bulk Closing Fees, then it should have negotiated for a non-renewal to have that effect by operation of the agreement’s express terms. The easy way to do that would have been to provide that a non-renewal under Section 9 would be deemed to have the same effect as closing all the Accounts under Section 2(k).

Therefore, the Superior Court correctly granted Interactive Brokers’ motion to dismiss, the Supreme Court says.

Read this next

Market News

Stock Market Analysis: Is NVDA Losing Its Leadership?

Since the beginning of the week, the S&P 500 Index (US500) has seen a modest increase of about 0.58%, whereas NVDA’s share price has experienced a decline of approximately 3.8%. This recent divergence raises concerns among Nvidia stock investors — could it signify a loss of NVDA’s market leadership?

Industry News

ESG: Australian regulator wins first greenwashing court case against Vanguard

Vanguard admitted that a notable portion of the securities within both the Index and the Fund did not undergo the promised ESG scrutiny.

Fintech, Uncategorized

BitMEX integrates HALO from Solidus Labs for cross-market surveillance

““The recent approval of the Spot Bitcoin ETF has piqued the market’s interest. As a result of price volatility, the trading volumes for crypto derivatives have gone up substantially. HALO, with its advanced technology and crypto-native detection architecture, will enable BitMEX to smoothly and safely scale trade surveillance across its increased trading volumes and provide the necessary safeguards for new product launches.”

Reviews

IUX Broker Review

IUX, recently rebranded from IUX Markets, stands as a multi-asset Forex broker recognized for its regulatory compliance across various jurisdictions.

Industry News

Horizon Software rebrands to Horizon Trading Solutions

“Horizon Trading Solutions has seen accelerated global growth over the past year to meet the rising demand for our trading solutions and built-for-purpose technology offering. The choice to rebrand represents a key part of this development, while maintaining our heritage and history in the industry.”

Market News

USDJPY has surged to levels last witnessed in 2022. Should we consider opening a short position?

The recent resurgence of the US dollar has propelled USD/JPY to new heights, touching levels not seen since 2022. This surge comes against the backdrop of stable short-term yields and ongoing economic data that fails to signal a significant slowdown, prompting questions about the extent of current monetary easing measures.

Digital Assets

DED Trends on Twitter After Memecoin Snapshot Announcement

Polkadot-backed community coin #DED, made it to the trending charts on X, demonstrating community’s engagement and interest behind the memecoin. 

Digital Assets

BlockDAG Presale Nears $10 Million Amid Toncoin’s Momentum, Green Bitcoin’s Presale, and the Rise of Other Top Cryptos

This article will examine three top trending topics: Toncoin’s potential, Green Bitcoin’s innovative presale, and BlockDAG’s sustainable mining approach. These cryptocurrencies take centre stage for their uniqueness and innovation.

Digital Assets

Coinbase scores minor victory vs SEC, but lawsuit to proceed

A federal judge in Manhattan, U.S. District Judge Katherine Polk Failla, ruled on Wednesday that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) lawsuit against Coinbase can largely proceed.

<