Delaware Supreme Court sides with Interactive Brokers in breach of contract dispute

Maria Nikolova

Equity Trust alleges Interactive Brokers’ choice to not renew an agreement triggered closing fees that Interactive Brokers has refused to pay.

The Supreme Court of the State of Delaware has sided with online trading major Interactive Brokers LLC in a lawsuit over alleged breach of contract brought by Equity Trust Company. In an Order, published on October 26, 2018, the Supreme Court supported an earlier ruling in favor of Interactive Brokers.

Under a service agreement between the parties, Equity Trust provided trust and related services to Interactive Brokers’ customers in connection with the customers’ retirement plans. This agreement provided for automatic renewal on the first day of the next year unless either party gave sixty days’ notice that it would terminate the agreement. In October 2016, Interactive Brokers gave notice that it would not renew the agreement for 2017.

Equity Trust alleges Interactive Brokers’ choice to not renew the agreement triggered closing fees that Interactive Brokers has refused to pay. Equity Trust claims the fees are owed under Section 2(k) of the service agreement. Equity Trust brought a claim for breach of contract.

The Superior Court granted Interactive Brokers’ motion to dismiss, holding that the contract provided the parties with a non-renewal option and exercising that option did not trigger any closing fees. Equity Trust then appealed from that decision. The Supreme Court reviews motions to dismiss de novo.

In the Order issued on Friday, the Supreme Court finds that the Superior Court correctly rejected Equity Trust’s argument that declining to renew the agreement prompted the payment of fees. The agreement shows that the obligation to pay closing fees is triggered not when the entire agreement is terminated, but rather when individual accounts are closed. Section 2(k), which is the basis for the alleged breach, requires Interactive Brokers to “pay all Equity Trust fees for Accounts closed during a calendar quarter and all quarterly trustee fees for all open Accounts.”

Thus, according to the Court, closing fees are payable only on the closing of “Accounts.” “Accounts” are in turn defined as “retirement plan accounts established by Customers,” with “Customers” defined as Interactive Brokers’ customers. Therefore,“Account” means an individual retirement plan account; that is, an account that an Interactive Brokers customer has with Interactive Brokers. Customers do not have “Accounts” with Equity Trust, which is only the trustee of the retirement plans. That means that the obligation to pay a closing fee is triggered only when an Interactive Brokers customer’s account is closed.

At no point in the complaint does Equity Trust plead facts supporting a rational inference that all the “Accounts” were closed. In fact, the complaint alleges that Interactive Brokers merely “assumed control of the Accounts,” “removed Equity Trust’s name from the Accounts,” and substituted itself “as trustee for the Accounts.” Those statements imply that Interactive Brokers did not close the Accounts, but instead just replaced Equity Trust as trustee once the agreement expired.

The Supreme Court notes that if Equity Trust wanted the non-renewal of the agreement to result in automatic Bulk Closing Fees, then it should have negotiated for a non-renewal to have that effect by operation of the agreement’s express terms. The easy way to do that would have been to provide that a non-renewal under Section 9 would be deemed to have the same effect as closing all the Accounts under Section 2(k).

Therefore, the Superior Court correctly granted Interactive Brokers’ motion to dismiss, the Supreme Court says.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Bloomberg, Hashdex expect SEC’s imminent approval of Bitcoin ETFs

Hashdex, an asset manager among the 13 contenders for launching a spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the United States, anticipates the debut of the first spot Bitcoin ETF by the second quarter of 2024, with a spot Ether ETF expected to follow.

Industry News

Witness the intensifying competition as UF AWARDS MEA 2024 nominations persist!

The countdown is on, with less than two weeks remaining to nominate outstanding brands for this prestigious event, culminating in the highly anticipated ceremony during iFX EXPO Dubai 2024 in January.

Retail FX

Saxo Bank’s FX volumes rise despite overall lackluster turnover

As many currency markets saw a relatively active period in November, Copenhagen-based Saxo Bank reported its monthly metrics, which showed a moderate rebound month-over-month.

Market News

S&P 500 Rally Faces Abrupt Halt: Analysts Assess Market Signals

The S&P 500, a benchmark index tracking the stock performance of 500 of the largest US companies, has ignited a flurry of discussions among financial analysts due to its recent performance.


TraderEvolution at FMLS:23: Andrew Saks on how brokers can go multi-asset

In an insightful interview with FinanceFeeds, Andrew Saks of TraderEvolution Global discussed the industry’s evolution towards multi-asset trading. He highlighted challenges in integrating diverse asset classes and the importance of API connectivity. Andrew also touched on emerging trends in options, futures, and fixed income, underscoring the need for adaptable trading technology in today’s dynamic market.

Market News

Powell’s Pivot Navigating the Dynamics of USD, Interest Rates, and Market Expectations

Federal Reserve Chair Powell has signalled a decisive end to the cycle of interest rate hikes for the USD.

Market News

Inflation Concerns, Policy Divergence, and Market Sentiments in the UK

Amidst the recent global revaluation of inflation, Megan Greene, a steadfast MPC member, advocates for a proactive stance. Addressing concerns in Leeds, she calls for an upward adjustment of the Bank of England’s policy rate, cautioning against the potential risks of a too-conservative approach. Greene questions the assumed restrictiveness in the current monetary stance, suggesting it might be less robust than perceived, especially in scenarios of persistent inflation.

Digital Assets

JPMorgan’s stablecoin ventures into interbank transactions

JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s proprietary digital token, JPM Coin, is set to expand its use case by facilitating interbank transactions on Partior, a blockchain ledger developed in collaboration with DBS Bank, Temasek, and Standard Chartered.

Retail FX

Interactive Brokers’ client base surges past 2.5 million

Interactive Brokers LLC (NASDAQ:IBKR) saw 1.89 million daily average revenue trades, or DARTS, in November 2023 compared to 1.93 million transactions in the prior month. The figure is three percent lower on a yearly basis, and also dropped slightly from a month earlier.