DOJ’s attempt to stay CFTC action encounters traders’ opposition

Maria Nikolova

The requested stay, if granted, would prejudice the defendants, says Michael Nowak, who stands accused of spoofing.

Less than a month after the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) requested to intervene and stay a civil action brought by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) against Michael Thomas Nowak and Gregg Francis Smith, the defendants have made it clear that they oppose the DOJ’s request.

In a set of documents submitted at the Illinois Northern District Court on November 27, 2019, Nowak and Smith who stand accused of spoofing object to the DOJ’s plans.

Let’s recall that, the DOJ (i) seeks leave to intervene in the civil action; and (ii) moves for a stay of the CFTC action through the conclusion of the parallel criminal prosecution – United States v. Smith, et al., Case No. 19 CR 669 (N.D. Ill.).

In its Motion, the DOJ notes that the criminal case includes both defendants to this civil case – Michael Nowak and Gregg Smith – and substantially the same conduct, events, and time period. The government argues that the requested stay would benefit the Court and all parties by minimizing redundant litigation, narrowing the scope of discovery and issues to be adjudicated in this case, and relieving Nowak and Smith of the choice of having to choose between potentially invoking their rights against self-incrimination in this civil case (which invocation could be used against them in this case) or testifying in this case (which testimony could be used against them in the criminal case).

Further, according to the DOJ, a stay is needed to preclude Nowak and Smith from impermissibly taking advantage of the civil discovery process to circumvent the limitations on criminal discovery that protect the integrity of criminal prosecutions, and to allow the defendants the ability to focus their resources on defending the pending criminal case.

In his opposition to the DOJ’s request, Nowak notes that Courts have uniformly held that a stay is appropriate only in unique circumstances, and where necessary to avoid significant prejudice. The defendants’ use of civil discovery rules to obtain the discovery to which they are entitled does not pose a risk of cognizable prejudice or harm to the government, and does not justify the extensive stay the DOJ seeks, Nowak argues.

According to him, the requested stay, if granted, would prejudice the defendants by substantially delaying the time-consuming process of discovery in the CFTC Case, which in turn will further prolong and delay a resolution of this action.

A more limited stay, permitting document discovery to proceed but otherwise pausing the action, would better balance the competing interests of the parties and the public, according to the defendants. Such a stay would protect the criminal process as well as the defendants’ rights, but also vindicate the defendants’ interests in proceeding as expeditiously as possible to resolve the CFTC Case.

Read this next

Retail FX

Financial Commission adds FX broker Bold Prime to membership roster

The Financial Commission today announced that it has added Bold Prime to its member roster, which is made up of online brokerages operating in FX, derivatives and cryptocurrency markets.

Digital Assets

Despite crypto winter, Cake DeFi paid out $58 million in Q2 rewards

According to its latest ‘Transparency Report,’ Cake DeFi continued its growth trajectory in the three months through June 2022, even as the entire crypto industry experienced macro challenges this quarter.

Retail FX

SimpleFX Review: Cryptos, Spreads, Pros & Cons

SimpleFX combines years of Forex and cryptocurrency experience with a focus on offering resources to retail traders. 

Retail FX

Ironbeam becomes CME clearing member and launches MT5

“The direct clearing aspect along with our low-latency proprietary trading tools and technology solutions make Ironbeam the ideal trading destination.”

Institutional FX

Top 0.07%: oneZero makes it to Inc. 5000 of fastest growing companies in America

oneZero started out by serving the foreign exchange trading community, developing and executing technology that could scale with the growth of the FX market.

Industry News

CFTC wins case against broker for secretly taking other side of client orders in block trades

“As we said at the outset of this case, the illegal use of inside or confidential information undermines confidence in markets and will not be tolerated.”


BankiFi raises $4.8m to bring embedded banking platform to North America

“Our mission is to make all aspects of cash management and payments easier for SMBs everywhere, and this investment is another huge step to making that a reality.”

Executive Moves

Shieldpay hires ex-Payoneer Chris Andrews as Head of Sales

“We’ll be expanding our position in existing markets and accelerating growth into new verticals, whilst building on our direct and indirect channels.”

Digital Assets secures preliminary approval to operate in Canada, one of the longest-established crypto platforms, has become the first digital asset platform to sign a Pre-‘Registration Undertaking’ with the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) in Canada.