Ex-Deutsche Bank traders convicted of LIBOR rigging secure NYCDL support

Maria Nikolova

The New York Council of Defense Lawyers backs Gavin Campbell Black and Matthew Connolly, urging reversal of their conviction.

Shortly after Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black filed their briefs with the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, asking for overturning of their conviction of LIBOR rigging, the former Deutsche Bank traders have secured backing from the New York Council of Defense Lawyers (NYCDL).

Earlier this week, NYCDL filed the so-called “amicus brief” (a letter by a friend to the Court). The document is in support of Gavin Campbell Black and Matthew Connolly, urging reversal of their convictions.

NYCDL explains that it has a particular interest in this case because it directly implicates NYCDL’s core concerns with combatting the unwarranted extension of criminal statutes and promoting clear standards for the imposition of criminal liability.

NYCDL argues that the alleged fraudulent representations in this case are estimates of the interest rates at which the defendants’ former employer, Deutsche Bank AG, could borrow funds in the interbank market. According to NYCDL, these estimates were a matter of opinion, the rates submitted were all reasonable estimates of Deutsche Bank’s anticipated borrowing costs; and the defendants never caused or intended to cause Deutsche Bank to submit a rate that was false.

The Council criticizes the Government’s theory of prosecution, which is that the defendants committed fraud by causing Deutsche Bank to submit estimates that were modified to take account of the bank’s trading positions. The District Court endorsed this theory.

This is not, and has never been, the law, according to NYCDL. Fundamental to a charge of criminal fraud is the defendant’s making of a false statement while knowing or believing it was false. Where the statement is one of opinion, this means that the Government must establish that the defendant knew the opinion was false or, at the very least, lacked a reasonable basis, NYCDL says.

In this case, the Council argues, the Government did not even attempt to prove that Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR estimates were false or unreasonable or that the defendants believed them to be so. It therefore follows that the Government failed to prove that the defendants participated in a scheme to issue fraudulent LIBOR estimates.

Furthermore, according to NYCDL, the Government asserts a novel theory of wire fraud which would upend the law of liability for opinions and has potentially far-reaching implications, such as exposing business executives and employees to prosecution and imprisonment for issuing opinions and making estimates that are reasonable, accurate and honestly believed, simply because the opinion or estimate was influenced by their employer’s financial interest.

In October 2018, a jury convicted Connolly and Black for their participation in a scheme to manipulate the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR).

The decision, made by a jury at the New York Southern District Court, followed a month long jury trial. The jury convicted former Deutsche Bank supervisor Matthew Connolly, 53, of Basking Ridge, New Jersey, of one count of conspiracy and two counts of wire fraud and former derivatives trader Gavin Campbell Black, 48, of London, of one count of conspiracy and one count of wire fraud.

Connolly was Deutsche Bank’s director of the Pool Trading Desk in New York, where he supervised traders who traded USD LIBOR-based derivative products. Black was a director on Deutsche Bank’s Money Market and Derivatives Desk in London, who also traded USD LIBOR-based derivative products.

Read this next


Bitcoin payments app Strike launches in Europe

Bitcoin blockchain-based payments app Strike launched in Europe on Wednesday, allowing users in the region to buy, sell, and withdraw bitcoin (BTC).


Bandit Network’s Points SDK and Brave Ads Power Astar zkEVM’s Quest Platform “Yoki Origins”

“Yoki Origins,” supported by Bandit Network and Brave Ads, introduces a gamified and rewarding experience for Astar zkEVM users, marking a significant milestone in Web3 adoption.

Digital Assets

Crypto ETFs to debut in Hong Kong next week

Hong Kong has authorized six cryptocurrency-based spot ETFs set to launch on April 30, according to Bloomberg.


BlockDAG Among The Best New Crypto To Invest In Post 8 Billion Coins Sales; More On Bitcoin Cash Futures’ Launch & Solana Positive Predictions

Explore Solana’s ATH predictions to see whether it can rise after a $17B dip? BlockDAG sells 8 billion coins in presale as Bitcoin Cash Futures launch.

Fundamental Analysis, Market News, Tech and Fundamental

Global FX Market Summary:USD, FED, German IFO ,Gold April 24 ,2024

Mixed US economic data and Fed rate hike uncertainty are causing volatility in the EUR/USD pair, while the Eurozone and gold prices add another layer of complexity.

Market News, Tech and Fundamental, Technical Analysis

EURCHF Technical Analysis Report 24 April, 2024

EURCHF currency pair can be expected to rise further toward the next major resistance level 0.9840, which stopped the pervious waves C and B, as can be seen below.

Digital Assets

Binance’s CZ could stay in prison until 2027, wife begs for mercy

Changpeng “CZ” Zhao, the founder and former CEO of Binance, has apologized for his decisions and accepted “full responsibility” in a letter to U.S. District Judge Richard A. Jones.

Digital Assets

Monex Group expands crypto business with 3iQ takeover

Monex Group has completed the acquisition of a majority stake in 3iQ Digital Holdings, Inc., a Canadian digital asset investment fund manager, as part of its strategy to expand its crypto business.

Education, Fintech, Inside View

How to Get Into Fintech: Best Tips to Succeed

The Fintech sector is experiencing significant growth, with fresh opportunities emerging rapidly.  Innovations such as machine learning and cryptocurrency are revolutionising finance, leading to a need for trained experts.