Former precious metals trader loses fight with US Govt over investigation interview

Maria Nikolova

Court has denied James Vorley’s motion to suppress the statements he made during the last interview with his former employer Deutsche Bank.

James Vorley, a former Deutsche Bank precious metals trader accused of spoofing, will not be allowed to suppress statements he made during an interview with his former employer. This becomes clear from a Memorandum Opinion signed by the Honorable John J. Tharp of the Illinois Northern District Court on March 11, 2020.

As FinanceFeeds has reported, James Vorley has moved to suppress statements he made during an interview conducted by two Deutsche Bank employees on March 17, 2015. He maintains that his statements during this interview were compelled by the government in violation of the Fifth Amendment.

Vorley makes two main claims regarding the disciplinary investigation interview that took place on March 17, 2015:

  •  that his statements were coerced under the threat he would not receive compensation;
  • that the interview was a part of the bank’s co-operation with the Government.

On March 9, 2015, just two days before his last day of work, he received a letter stating that he was “required” to attend a disciplinary investigation interview. The letter “strongly encouraged” Vorley to answer questions, while threatening that an adverse finding by the disciplinary panel could result in forfeiture of his deferred compensation.

Vorley stressed that Deutsche Bank showed no interest whatsoever in disciplining him for months after it questioned him in May 2014 about the “spoofing it up” chat. It then terminated him as redundant and offered him a severance package. However, once it began cooperating with the government’s precious metals investigation, including with respect to interviews of employees, it referred Vorley for a disciplinary investigation interview.

According to the trader, there is no evidence that the bank had any reason for reopening its investigation of him in the final days of his employment other than its desire to earn cooperation credit from the government. The most reasonable conclusion to be drawn in these circumstances is that the March 17, 2015 disciplinary investigation interview was conducted as part of the bank’s cooperation, Vorley says.

In the opinion issued today, the Judge sided with the United States Government and concluded that Vorley’s statements were not “compelled” within the meaning of the Fifth Amendment. Hence, his motion to suppress was denied.

The Fifth Amendment, in relevant part, provides that no person “shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.” This prohibition is in play in this case because the government seeks to introduce statements made by Vorley in its case-in-chief at the trial of this matter.

The threshold issue presented by Vorley’s motion is whether his statements to the Deutsche Bank investigators during the March 17, 2015 interview were “compelled” within the meaning of the Fifth Amendment.

The Judge finds it is indisputable that Vorley was not “compelled” to answer the Bank’s questions during the March 17, 2015 interview, as he refused to answer any questions about his trading activity other than those concerning a single trading sequence in which he engaged. Vorley answered the questions he was willing to answer and refused to answer those that he did not.

The Judge notes that Vorley does not explain (and the Court cannot fathom) why Vorley believed that refusing to answer the Bank’s questions about trading on March 16, 2011 would mean the loss of his deferred compensation while refusing to answer questions about the other “similar trading conduct” in 2011 the Bank wanted to explore would not.

The lawsuit continues at the Illinois Northern District Court.

Read this next

Crypto Insider

Octa’s insights: the approval of spot Ethereum ETFs is not going as planned.

The approval of spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETF) by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in January 2024 triggered a substantial rise in the bitcoin price. Also, interest in the proposed spot Ethereum ETF has increased

Industry News

Bursa Malaysia introduces Trading Reminders

The Trading Reminder flag aims to alert investors to exercise caution when encountering a stock displaying persistent unusual price and/or volume movements after the listed company’s UMA response.

Industry News

21 Republican representatives want to “End the Fed”

“Americans are suffering under crippling inflation, and the Federal Reserve is to blame.”

Retail FX

Scope Markets launches unleveraged trading

“Whilst our traditional contract for difference (CFD) products continue to prove incredibly popular, the Invest account is unleveraged and only allows ‘long’ positions to be taken, a combination that significantly reduces the risk of capital losses.”


Unlocking Profit Potential: Earn Returns with DecodeEX Experience Bonus!

DecodeEX, the innovative brokerage subsidiary of Decode Global, announced its experience bonus campaign, offering every user the opportunity to maximize their strategic trading potential with up to $10,000 in experience bonus. 

Market News

Pretiorates’ Thoughts 28 – Precious metals and base metals out of control

Ten days ago we mentioned in Pretiorates’ Thoughts 26: Chapter 2 should start with Precious Metals.

Retail FX

Webull launches discount brokerage in Malaysia

“Making investing more inclusive and accessible to all, Webull Malaysia brings best-in-class tools and information to empower investors of all levels with knowledge and skills to help them make better investment decisions and achieve their investment goals.”

Digital Assets

Hidden Road adds OKX’s Nitro Spreads into prime brokerage

“Hidden Road continually seeks to increase market access and capital efficiency through expanded prime brokerage offerings. Integrating OKX’s Nitro Spreads product builds upon this philosophy by extending our counterparties’ ability to execute risk-managed arbitrage strategies.”


Dev Release 31: BlockDAG’s SHA-3 Upgrades Propel Crypto Mining Innovation as Miner Sales Approach 5800 Units

Learn about BlockDAG’s 31st Development Release, which includes advanced SHA-3 updates and a significant increase in miner sales, driving advancements.