FX Cartel demands that US govt provides details about coordinated trades by Dec 1st

Maria Nikolova

According to the former traders, there is no reason, other than gamesmanship, for the government to withhold the requested information about allegedly coordinated trades from the defense for months.

As FinanceFeeds has earlier reported, the US government and former FX traders – Richard Usher, Rohan Ramchandani, and Christopher Ashton, known also as the FX “Cartel” or “Mafia”, have locked horns over evidence to be used in a Forex manipulation case.

Usher, former Head of G11 FX Trading-UK at an affiliate of Royal Bank of Scotland plc, as well as former Managing Director at an affiliate of JPMorgan Chase & Co., Ramchandani, former Managing Director and head of G10 FX spot trading at an affiliate of Citicorp, and Ashton, former Head of Spot FX at an affiliate of Barclays PLC, are alleged to have conspired to manipulate the FX market by “coordinating their bidding, offering, and trading” at “certain times.”

The parties in the case conferred on Wednesday, September 6, 2017, where it was specified that “the conduct that we are talking about, the agreement, is to essentially move the price of the Euro dollar currency pair on occasions when they can make money or avoid losses in doing so and coordinating their trading.”

The conference held on September 6, 2017, aimed to settle a dispute between the parties over the so-called “bill of particulars”, a list of written questions from one party to another asking for details (particulars) about a claim or defense. The US government had earlier refused to provide the defendants with such a “bill of particulars”, saying that instead it would offer an early trial exhibit list, which will specify the particular instances of alleged collusive trading and means of communication. The government has said it was ready to provide this 60 to 90 days prior to trial.

The former traders have argued that the timing is unacceptable, as it would not allow them to properly study all data related to the case and prepare their defense accordingly. Moreover, the parties disagree on the nature of evidence to be included in the document to be delivered by the government.

The government had initially offered to provide a list of episodes, identified by time-stamps in chats, in which the alleged trading coordination occurred, but had refused to provide the corresponding trades. At Wednesday’s conference, the government finally agreed to provide information of certain corresponding trades, but only for a limited subset of the episodes it will use at trial.

The defendants argue that they need the trades underlying each alleged episode to defend against the allegations of coordinated trading.

The government counters that their identification of time stamps in chats should enable the defendants to locate the corresponding trades, but the former traders argue that the chats and audio calls, by themselves, are too vague.

Another point of confusion for the defendants is that the government claimed on Wednesday that it might even introduce at trial allegedly coordinated trades for which the defendants did not even communicate in their coordination,

“and there may be trading that all of these defendants have done that that they don’t speak to one another about but is supporting their collusion and is adding to the efforts of their collusion”.

Adding to the disagreement, the government said on Wednesday that it had not and could not identify all of the trades relevant to its allegations.

“We can’t give the defendants what we don’t have and will never have which is a list of illegal trades or a list of inclusive trades, it just doesn’t exist in a Sherman Act case.”

This position, the defendants note, directly contradicts earlier statements by the government when announcing that several banks had agreed to plead guilty to violating the Sherman Act for FX manipulation.

The defendants’ proposal would require the government to provide a final list of episodes and the accompanying trading data by December 1, 2017, which is approximately six months before the trial is set to start on June 5, 2018. This time request is explained via the complexity of the trading data and the vagueness of the indictment.

In particular, the defendants require:

  • a list of the 198 episodes of allegedly coordinated trading by September 18, 2017;
  • rolling and winnowed down lists each month, with a final list of episodes (of up to 75) by December 1, 2017;
  • for every such episode identified by the government, the corresponding bids, offers, and trades that were allegedly coordinated.

In their letter to the judge assigned to the case, the defendants note that there is no reason, other than gamesmanship, for the government to withhold the information from the defense for months, by which time the defendants would have lost the opportunity to meaningfully test and analyze it with the assistance of experts.

The case, captioned USA v. Usher et al (1:17-cr-00019), continues at the New York Southern District Court.

Read this next

Industry News

ASIC cancels/suspends AFS license of AFSL Group and Quantum Funds Management

ASIC canceled the AFS license of AFSL Group because it failed to lodge statements and audit reports and it did not maintain AFCA membership. The Australian regulator suspended Quantum because it does not have the required professional indemnity insurance coverage.

Executive Moves

BidX Markets hires Shaun French as Research Analyst – Multi Asset

“We believe with his background in the Financial Markets and being based in Dubai, he will be able to provide our clients with access to outstanding research, while also being in a great location to help support our international clients base which is growing at a rapid pace’’.

Institutional FX

Nasdaq migrates US options exchange to AWS with +10% performance in round-trip latency

Nasdaq has announced the successful migration of the core trading system of Nasdaq MRX – one of its six U.S. options exchanges – to Amazon Web Services (AWS).

Institutional FX

TraditionData launches oil swaps pricing data at a critical time in OTC oil traded markets

TraditionDATA has announced the release of a new proprietary Oil Swap Model (OSM) which brings further visibility into illiquid and opaque oil markets.


TNS connects to Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (TASE) as market data vendor

“This latest exchange connection allows TNS to provide access to approved recipients, including exchange members and market data vendors. This project includes market data for TASE’s equities and increases the number of market data feeds we now offer globally.”

Executive Moves

Cowen Digital taps ex-Blockchain.com Taylor S. Cable to lead Europe and Asia operation

“Cowen Digital is a pioneer in delivering institutional grade access to the digital asset ecosystem and I am very excited to join the team at this pivotal time to grow our presence in Europe and Asia.”

Industry News

ASIC sues American Express Australia for lack of TMD on credit cards

“ASIC has now taken multiple actions under the design and distribution regime, including issuing over 20 interim stop orders. This regime turned a new page in the regulation of financial products in Australia and is intended to deliver better outcomes for consumers. It is a priority for ASIC to maximize these increased protections and see the long-term benefits of the DDO regime realized.”

Institutional FX

Eurex reports mixed volumes for November 2022

Deutsche Börse’s derivatives-focused exchange, Eurex today said its total traded derivatives contracts grew by 10 percent in November, from 68.6 million to 75.3 million compared to the same month last year.

Digital Assets

AAX’s Nigerian customers storm local office amid withdrawal halt

According to the Nigerian media, angry consumers of the troubled crypto exchange AAX had stormed its local office hoping they can get their money back after the firm halted operations earlier in November.