GAIN Capital responds to TIBCO Software’s $22m claim for alleged software over-deployment

Maria Nikolova

GAIN rejects allegations by TIBCO about unauthorized use of its software and files counterclaims about fraud in the inducement and negligent misrepresentation.

Less than a month after TIBCO Software reiterated its allegations about software over-deployment against GAIN Capital, the online trading major has sought to reply to the accusations and has filed a set of counterclaims against the software firm.

On Thursday, June 14, 2018, GAIN Capital filed an answer to TIBCO’s complaint with the California Northern District Court. The document (a heavily redacted version of it was seen by FinanceFeeds) states that GAIN rejects the accusations against it. In addition, GAIN asserts a number of counterclaims against TIBCO.

GAIN states that TIBCO was simply not content with its legitimate license fee revenue stream. In 2016 (if not earlier), GAIN says, TIBCO began setting up its customers for expensive and extortionate games of “gotcha.” GAIN was allegedly one of TIBCO’s victims. TIBCO tricked GAIN into signing an “Order Form” (“2016 Order Form”) for TIBCO products and services that GAIN had not used and did not need.

The broker insists that the KMPG audit that purportedly indicated the software over-deployment by GAIN was flawed. After receiving the End of Deployment Report from GAIN in April 2016, TIBCO demanded an audit by KPMG regarding the deployment of TIBCO’s software. That audit purported to find “over-deployment” of TIBCO’s software by GAIN beyond what TIBCO claims GAIN had paid for. The over-deployment numbers are dubbed absurd by GAIN.

According to the broker, TIBCO deliberately rigged the audit to achieve the result it wanted by instructing KPMG to include in its count of the number of units deployed by GAIN, processors that were no longer in use by GAIN, and versions of TIBCO software that TIBCO had updated from time to time. Including non-operative processors and outdated versions of its software is said to have drastically inflated the purported deployment of TIBCO software. This intentional ruse resulted in TIBCO’s whopping so-called “Bill of Materials,” sent by email on or about October 20, 2016.

This step had a very important effect – GAIN explains – it moved the goal posts so far out, that even a wildly inaccurate and over-inflated “settlement” might seem palatable—especially to GAIN IT personnel who TIBCO made to feel were responsible for the purported over-deployment. This was deliberate. But GAIN’s accounts payable personnel did not respond to TIBCO’s payment requests. Negotiations between TIBCO and GAIN broke down, and TIBCO initiated its lawsuit in June 2017.

TIBCO says it is owed more than $22 million for unauthorized use of its software by the online trading major. TIBCO’s complaint asserts a number of claims against GAIN, including breach of contract; breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing; and copyright infringement.

GAIN’s counterclaims include: Fraud in the inducement; Negligent misrepresentation; Unfair competition; and Rescission based on unilateral mistake.

GAIN asks the Court to award GAIN damages, including but not limited to compensatory and punitive damages, together with pre-judgment and post-judgment interest, in an amount to be determined at trial. The broker also asks the Court to enter an order enjoining TIBCO from seeking any payments from GAIN for license fees, or claiming that it is owed any payments for license fees by GAIN, under the 2016 Bill of Materials.

The case is captioned TIBCO Software Inc., v. Gain Capital Group, LLC (5:17-cv-03313).

Read this next

Retail FX, Technology

MetaTrader’s iOS issue opens brokers’ eyes to other trading platforms

In a surprising (or-not-so-surprising) move, Apple has removed MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 from its App Store in a huge blow for the leading FX trading platform provider.

Retail FX

Pepperstone adds analytics and automated trading tools free of charge

“We look forward to bringing significant value to Pepperstone traders and making a real, positive impact in their daily trading habits. We are excited to welcome them on board.”

Retail FX

FP Markets wins Best Global Value Broker for 4th consecutive year at the 2022 Global Forex Awards

“We greatly appreciate the continued international recognition as at FP Markets we pride ourselves on these attributes and these prestigious awards are testament to the hard work from our global team to always provide our clients with the ultimate trading experience.”

Inside View

How to Engage Your Customer at Every Stage of Their Journey

As many as 89% of successful businesses say that providing assistive customer experiences is critical to their growth. That’s because a mere 5% increase in customer retention can boost profits by 25% to 95%.

Industry News

CFTC fines Chinese firms Chinatex and COFCO $720,000 for wash trading

Chinatex traders engaged in wash trading in order to liquidate a long position in the account of an affiliated company and re-establish the position in its own account, to the ultimate benefit of its parent company, COFCO.

Industry News

US-based operation of Brazilian broker XP fined $500,000 for recordkeeping failures

“Proper recordkeeping is vital to protecting our markets and market participants from fraud and manipulation. This case serves as another example of the Commission’s intent to vigorously enforce the recordkeeping obligations of its registrants.”

Digital Assets

Bitfinex announces integration of USDt on Polkadot

Polkadot is the brainchild of British computer programmer and Ethereum co-founder and former CTO Gavin Wood.

Executive Moves

FPG hires ex-Fireblocks Chris Hazelton to head marketing at crypto prime broker

“Chris’s experience as a marketing leader at several exceptional businesses will help us refine our message to an institutional audience that’s overwhelmed with new information and show tangible examples of how we’ve helped customers like them scale successfully in crypto.”


FinanceFeeds Podcast Ep. #6: Gold-i’s Tom Higgins talks efficiency in FX and inner workings of Crypto Switch

On its sixth episode, the FinanceFeeds Podcast welcomed Tom Higgins, the founder and chief executive of trading systems integration provider, Gold-i.