Gemini fires back at SEC’s allegations of offering unregistered securities

abdelaziz Fathi

Gemini, the cryptocurrency exchange owned by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, has taken steps to challenge the allegations brought by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). This move comes in response to the SEC’s accusations that Gemini’s service, Gemini Earn, violated securities regulations by offering unregistered securities.


Gemini has filed a reply brief in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, where it argues that the SEC has not submitted a clear claim in its lawsuit. The exchange said that the court should simplify the matter by posing direct questions to determine whether Gemini Earn qualifies as a security. These questions include identifying the alleged security’s sale date, buyer, seller, and price.

Furthermore, Gemini claims that the SEC should first identify the unregistered security and then establish the sale or offer to sell that security. The exchange further states that the SEC has not met this requirement in its complaint.

“Even assuming for the sake of argument that SEC has somehow described a security (under either of its inconsistent theories), it has not plausibly alleged that such security was ever sold or offered for sale,” reads the 15-page motion,” the legal notice reads.

The legal dispute began when the SEC accused Gemini of offering unregistered securities through Gemini Earn. The exchange’s reply brief seeks to challenge the SEC’s arguments and highlight the lack of clarity and proof in the regulatory body’s claims.

Regardless of the lawsuit’s outcome, it seems Gemini won’t be returning to the United States any time soon. The exchange confirmed its exit from the country in April, alongside several other industry players.

Gemini is being sued by investors over the sale of its interest-bearing crypto products. In a class-action complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, some investors accused Gemini and its founders of fraud and violations of the Exchange Act.

The complaint alleges that Gemini’s Earn program didn’t register its high-yield products as securities in accordance with U.S. securities law. The filing highlights that the exchange promoted annual interest rates of up to 7.4% on crypto deposits, which was higher than rates for short-term, investment-grade, fixed-income securities or bank savings accounts.

Gemini customers said that the exchange failed to distinguish the FDIC status of its own bank deposits and customers’ high-yield program. In other words, those statements implied that FDIC insurance was available for Gemini Dollar (GUSD) holdings, while the agency does not insure brokerage accounts.

The Earn accounts were frozen after its main lending partner, Genesis Global Capital, enacted a similar freeze before going bankrupt.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Binance tames up with Japan’s biggest lender to launch stablecoins

Binance Japan is planning to launch stablecoins denominated in the dollar, euro, and yen in Japan in 2024. The crypto exchange aims to introduce these tokens, and possibly more, through its partnership with Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group’s trust banking arm.

Institutional FX

Spot FX volumes drop +10% at CLS in August 2023

Total daily traded volume submitted to CLS for settlement took a step back in August as the summer typical lull hit market activity. The metrics showed a weak performance in the group’s FX business as the Q3 got off to a calm end while no fresh events were able to whip up a market frenzy.

Digital Assets

Veteran iGaming Team Launch Crypto Casino Portal

CryptoCasinos.Casino launches as a premier destination for crypto gambling aficionados, offering in-depth reviews, comparisons, and resources to navigate the burgeoning world of cryptocurrency-based casinos seamlessly.

Digital Assets

Xsolla Announces Acquisition of AcceleratXR, A Multi-Player Platform For Games

Xsolla enhances its gaming tech suite with the acquisition of AcceleratXR, bolstering cross-platform game development and pioneering advancements in cross-play experiences for players worldwide.

Digital Assets

OKX’s PoR report shows no solvency concerns, assets worth $11.2 billion

Cryptocurrency exchange OKX has released its 11th consecutive proof-of-reserves report amid increasing demand of crypto investors asking for transparency from exchanges they trade with.

Digital Assets

Horizen Launches Decentralized Governance with Introduction of Horizen DAO

Horizen inaugurates a novel decentralized autonomous organization, inviting broader community participation and heralding a new chapter in blockchain governance.

Digital Assets

Binance France induces users to convert their fiat into crypto

Following the expiration of its partnership with Paysafe, Binance France urged its customers to convert their fiat currency holdings on the platform into cryptocurrencies.

Industry News

Exness Crowned as Best Global Multi-asset Broker at Forex Expo Dubai 2023

Cyprus-based Exness garners top honors at the Forex Expo Dubai, solidifying its esteemed position in the global financial arena.

Retail FX

CySEC cancels license of 101investing parent following €200,000 fine

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) confirmed on Tuesday that it has wholly withdrawn the Cyprus Investment Firm (CIF) License of FX retail brokerage firm FXBFI Broker Financial Invest Ltd, trading as 101investing.