Going offshore will kill your business

For brokers looking to ditch their licenses and go after clients in undeveloped nations, look up. Those nations are now looking to arrest owners of unlicensed FX brokers. Without regulation, there will be nowhere to go for new business.

INTL FCStone takes its FX and commodities business into Africa

For quite some time, FinanceFeeds has been an unequivocal advocate of evolution via reinvestment, especially when new challenges face the retail FX brokerage sector and there are some capital reserves that could be utilized to make the necessary changes that are often needed to keep up with the demands of increasing regulatory requirements and market dynamics.

Ever since the rise to prominence of brokerages which entered the FX trading sector via affiliate marketing and off-the-shelf infrastructure methodology, a dichotomy has existed in that some brokers have tended to remain unlicensed and onboard clients offshore (that includes firms with a cursory CySec licensed entity and then onboard most of their clients via an offshore Caribbean location), and then there are the others which have steadily grown their business and entered into developed markets, gaining good quality licenses on the way.

The latter is the most sustainable route to a long term business, however in the aftermath of recent regulatory rulings such as that by ASIC which has prevented FX firms from onboarding non-Australian clients, having a potentially decimating effect on those which have relied heavily on Chinese IB networks, brokerages have been faced with a choice.

The choice is quite simple: Either to take the good and solid revenues earned from having garnered a very well organized Asia Pacific-based partner network, and reinvest it into developing trading systems and product ranges that would take a retail broker into new and popular audiences, and join the realms of the new, app-based retail trading platforms which allow bank accounts, mortgages and trading on one app, or to rival the challenger banks such as Revolut.

The amount of high ticket venture capital that is being invested in these new entities is enough of a measure of the confidence that the financial world has in them as the future structure of banking, retail finance and technology and their own system and customer base means that their intellectual property is their own when it comes to valuation time for public listing.

With MiFID II in Europe stipulating that all trade reporting must be correct and all infrastructure must fit best execution practices for regulated marketplaces, ETFs or market makers, leverage restrictions in place, and with Australia about to follow suit with the added aspect of the US-style ruling on no cross border client bases, firms can either invest in their future and aim toward a domestic, good quality audience which requires multi-asset trading and a modern experience, or throw in the towel and go offshore.

Going offshore means keeping the Asia-Pacific IB network churnable, but it means no credibility and no chance of ever operating in developed markets which is where the majority of the good sustainable new business is.

Once the Chinese government has developed an algorithm which successfully blocks the IP addresses of every new broker that attempts to attract clients from outside, unregulated firms will be left with parts of South East Asia, and the undeveloped nations in Africa and the Middle East.

Enough to sustain a business? No. Not by a long way, because the governments and central banks of many African nations are now looking to ban all unlicensed FX brokers – and by that they mean ones with registered offices on islands.

The ability of unlicensed b-book FX brokers in the Middle East, Russia and Asia to onboard clients from Nigeria, Kenya and Ghana, along with some other East and Central African nations has been a byproduct of the overall distrust that residents of those countries hold in their own government and monetary system.

For example, Nigeria has been a target market for some brokers largely due to the chaotic nature of its own financial system and massively varying Naira rates, leading to an IB network that holds physical seminars and refers clients to offshore brokers, some of which do not mean well at all.

Today, Kenya’s central bank issued a warning against dealing with unlicensed and unregulated online forex traders which differed from previous anodyne soundbites in that this time, the authorities are looking to arrest brokerage executives who seek to onboard Kenyan clients via offshore platforms.

In a public notice published in local media yesterday, the banking regulator said those platforms are downloadable on Google Play and Apple App Store, and aggressively market themselves through social media, promising huge and instant returns.

Many of these are mobile versions of MetaTrader, operated by offshore white label partners of other b-book brokers.

“The purpose of this notice is to warn members of the public against dealing with unlicenced and unregulated online forex dealers. They should only deal with genuine and licenced financial institutions and entities’’ the Central Bank of Kenya statement read.

It asked members of the public to report complaints regarding these illegal dealers to the Banking Fraud Investigations Unit.

A spot check by a local investigator in Kenya on Google’s Android Play application download system found a dozen of forex trading apps that had been prioritized to appear when a local IP address was searching for them, including Go Forex designed by GoForex 24, FXPesa by EGM Capital, Iron Trading, Forex Game, Trading Signal, the amusingly named Bimono Trade Olymp Trade among others.

The Kenyan central bank did not state that a firm would have to be regulated in Kenya, instead inferring that a license from a reputable financial markets regulator is the differentiating factor, and for clients not to use totally unregulated firms.

Kenya’s capital markets regulator the Capital Markets Authority (CMA) estimates that about 50,000 people, including brokers, dealers and money managers, are in the business and are mainly using offshore platforms that are not overseen by Kenyan regulators to offer the service.

In April, CMA raised red flag on increasing number of illegal forex traders, with CEO Paul Muthaura warning them of dire consequences.

“The Authority will also take appropriate enforcement action against any persons or entities illegally conducting online foreign exchange trade or collecting client funds in contravention of the above regulatory provisions,” Mr Muthaura said.

By canceling a good quality license and going offshore – an example being IC Markets, a company that makes over $500 million per month in revenues and is one of MetaQuotes largest customers with a substantial number of server licenses which recently headed to the Seychelles following Australia’s ruling on overseas client bases, otherwise reputable FX brokers are putting themselves in the same category as these oddly named non-entity white labels and will be unable to do business in the vast majority of regions worldwide.

It is not prudent to hold nations with third tier regulatory structures and undeveloped economies as a sustainable audience and an ‘easy target’ because they have been targeted for several years by entities that have not meant well, therefore are vigilant and are beginning to outlaw the activities of such firms.

Therefore, by going offshore, brokerages would never be able to approach clients in Europe, North America, Australia, Singapore, Hong Kong, China or Russia, and similarly, the nations that they would seek to rely on will follow Kenya’s lead and begin to arrest owners of unlicensed firms doing business with retail customers on their territories.

Thus, the regulated, genuine method of doing business is the most sustainable. It requires a bit of investment to ensure that regulations are met and that products are appealing to a dynamic, modern and astute investing public in first tier jurisdictions, but it is well worth it.



Read this next

Retail FX

Interactive Brokers adds 680k accounts, daily trades hit two-year high

Interactive Brokers LLC (NASDAQ: IBKR) recorded 2.44 million daily average revenue trades (DARTs) in February 2024, marking a notable increase from the 2.2 million transactions observed in the previous month. This figure represents the highest DARTs reported in two years, indicating an 11 percent monthly surge and a 15 percent year-on-year rise.

Retail FX

Financial Commission adds Ultima Markets to membership roster

Multi-asset brokerage firm Ultima Markets, operating under the trading name Ultima Markets Ltd, has been granted membership of the Financial Commission, marking the most recent inclusion into the ranks of the self-regulatory organization.

Digital Assets

Bitcoin hits fresh record high amid massive short squeeze

Bitcoin has surged to record highs against both the euro and the pound, hitting €60,447 and £51,736 respectively on Coinbase. The primary cryptocurrency has seen an almost 7% increase in the past 24 hours.

Digital Assets

US court rules crypto trades as securities in Coinbase case

A US court ruled that trading crypto assets on platforms like Coinbase constitutes securities transactions.

Market News

Weekly Data: Oil and Gold: Brief Review before the NFP

This preview of weekly data looks at USOIL and XAUUSD where economic data coming up later this week are the main market drivers for the near short-term outlook.

Institutional FX

FXSpotStream reports lower volumes for February 2024

FXSpotStream’s trading venue, the aggregator service of LiquidityMatch LLC, reported its operational metrics for February 2024, which moved lower on a monthly basis.

Fundamental Analysis

Global FX Market Summary: EUR, USD, Gold March 4th,2024

US Dollar Weakness: The US Dollar (USD) is currently struggling to gain strength due to a combination of factors.

Technical Analysis

Bitcoin Technical Analysis Report 4 March, 2024

Bitcoin cryptocurrency can be expected to rise further toward the next resistance level 69000.00 (former multiyear high from January)


Finding Opportunity in Challenge: Why New Regulations Offer a Chance For Business to Get on Top of Data Management

The combination of CESOP, PSD3 and the PSR, has put businesses under new pressures. In this engaging article, André Casterman, Senior Advisor at Intix provides invaluable guidance on how companies can stay ahead of the curve.