Hong Kong’s SFC fines Sincere Securities over internal control failings

Maria Nikolova

The disciplinary action followed an investigation into an investor’s complaint concerning the conduct of a former account executive of Sincere Securities Limited.

The Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) today announces that it has reprimanded and imposed a fine of $5 million on Sincere Securities Limited over a series of internal control failings and regulatory breaches.

The disciplinary action followed an SFC investigation into an investor’s complaint concerning the conduct of a former account executive of the company. The SFC found that Sincere Securities did not require its account executives to obtain clients’ written consent before transferring their funds maintained at the company to their gold trading accounts opened with its associated company Allied Victory Gold and Silver Investment Limited.

Sincere Securities engaged an independent reviewer to conduct a review of its internal control systems and procedures. The independent review and a separate review by the SFC identified deficiencies across 14 areas of the company’s business operations and internal controls for the period between October 2015 and December 2016.

The 14 areas of deficiencies include: (i) procedures and manuals; (ii) compliance surveillance program; (iii) escalation policy; (iv) staff dealing activities; (v) discretionary trading; (vi) third-party authorization; (vii) handling of client funds; (viii) handling of client securities; (ix) client orders and dealing; (x) handling of returned mail; (xi) preparation and delivery of trading documents; (xii) customer due diligence; (xiii) credit and margin control procedures; and (xiv) books and records.

For instance, the company did not have specific procedures to filter, analyse and monitor staff dealing activities. It also failed to segregate the sales, dealing and settlement functions effectively with the result that its account executives handling client orders also handled clients’ fund deposits and withdrawals; and had no written procedures to prohibit its staff from receiving client order instructions through mobile phone when they are on the trading floor.

Moreover, some client order instructions were received through mobile phone applications, such as WhatsApp messenger, while they were in the company’s office but no contemporaneous record of the order details was maintained. Let’s note that SFC has been very stringent regarding proper record-keeping of client order instructions. The regulator has acted against entities and individuals that use mobile apps for receiving client instructions. For example, in May this year, the SFC prohibited Mr Wong Ka Hang, a licensed representative of Haitong International Futures Limited (Haitong), from re-entering the industry for 9 months pursuant to section 194 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance over accepting client orders via WeChat messages.

In the case of Sincere Securities, the SFC considers that the company’s systems and controls were inadequate and failed to ensure compliance with the applicable regulatory rules and requirements.

In deciding the disciplinary sanctions, the SFC took into account various factors, such as the company’s agreement to engage an independent reviewer to review its internal control systems and procedures, as well as the fact that Sincere Securities has taken remedial actions to address the deficiencies identified and had compensated the affected client in the complaint case.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Montenegro approves Do Kwon’s extradition to US

Do Kwon, the former CEO of cryptocurrency startup Terraform Labs, is reportedly facing extradition to the United States to face fraud charges. Kwon has been imprisoned in Montenegro since March, and Montenegro’s Justice Minister Andrej Milovic is expected to make a formal decision on the extradition on December 20.

Institutional FX

Marex seeks US listing following failed UK IPO, eyes $2.8B valuation

London-headquartered commodities broker Marex has kicked off plans for a US listing, opting against a London public float after a failed attempt two years ago.

Retail FX

ThinkMarkets IPO scrapped as SPAC merger falls through

Canada-listed blank check company, FG Acquisition Corp., and Melbourne-based broker ThinkMarkets have jointly decided to call off their previously announced merger plan.

Retail FX

Exness trading volumes slow down in November, dip below $4B mark

FX brokerage powerhouse Exness reported a double-digit decrease in its trading volumes for the month of November 2023 as the market environment stabilised following a period of high volatility.

Executive Moves

iGaming veteran Breon Corcoran replaces June Felix as IG CEO

Spread betting and CFDs broker IG Group plc today announced the appointment of Breon Corcoran, the former chief executive of Paddy Power Betfair, as its new CEO, effective from January 29, 2024.

Retail FX, Reviews

A Guide to Forex Trading and Quotex App Download for PC

Trading in financial markets presents a great opportunity for profit. One of the popular choices nowadays is foreign exchange trading, also called Forex or FXm which involves buying and selling national currencies to make a profit. 

Digital Assets

Tokensoft and Chainwire Form Partnership to Boost Crypto PR Outreach

Through this partnership, Tokensoft leverages Chainwire’s expansive PR platform, enhancing its global reach within the cryptocurrency community and ensuring coverage for its token distribution, claims, and fundraising campaigns.

Digital Assets

No escape for Binance’s CZ: Court blocks travel before sentencing

A federal judge in Seattle has ruled that Chanpeng Zhao, the former CEO of Binance, is not permitted to return to his home in the United Arab Emirates before his sentencing in the United States, set for February.

Digital Assets

FINMA-regulated digital asset provider Taurus expands into Germany

This expansion follows recent moves by BaFin to accelerate the licensing of crypto custody services, aiming to boost market confidence. Following this, several new licenses were issued, notably to Commerzbank, making it the first full-service financial institution in Germany to receive a crypto custody license.