Illinois Court nixes attempt by MtGox CEO Mark Karpeles to dismiss action against him

Maria Nikolova

The Illinois Northern District Court has denied a motion to dismiss by Karpeles in a case brought by ex-customers of MtGox.

In line with earlier reports, the Illinois Northern District Court has denied a motion to dismiss brought by Mark Karpeles in a case related to the collapse of Bitcoin exchange MtGox. The relevant Memorandum Opinion & Order was issued on March 12, 2019.

The plaintiffs in the case – Gregory Greene and Anthony Motto, seek on behalf of a putative class to hold Mark Karpeles, Mt. Gox’s principal liable for financial losses allegedly arising from the exchange’s collapse. The plaintiffs are bringing state law claims that sound in conversion/trespass to chattels, negligence, and consumer fraud. Their complaint alleges that Karpeles intentionally misrepresented the security and stability of the Mt. Gox exchange and that his negligent or intentional failures in designing and operating the exchange allowed the loss of the plaintiffs’ assets. On behalf of a putative class, the plaintiffs seek actual, statutory, and punitive damages, along with prejudgment interest and attorney fees.

Karpeles has moved to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction.

In denying Karpeles’ motion to dismiss, Judge Gary Feinerman noted that Greene and Motto’s contacts with the exchange were not random, isolated, or fortuitous, but rather the product of Mt. Gox’s virtual presence in Illinois, as some 7,056, or about 1.5%, of the addresses associated with Mt. Gox accounts came from Illinois.

The Court has found that, even if the Illinois market was “simply one among many”, a place of no particular interest to him, Karpeles purposefully availed himself of that market by operating an exchange that generated thousands of Illinois accounts and by purporting to safeguard the assets of Greene, Motto, and the other Illinois users.

Although Karpeles did not himself make the alleged misrepresentations to Greene and Motto, it is enough that he allegedly directed his agents to do so given that the agents had notice that the communications concerned Mt. Gox’s business with individuals in Illinois. Similarly, that Karpeles did not expect Mt. Gox to have thousands of Illinois accounts and did not care to ascertain the origin of each deposit or communication does not deprive the contacts with Greene and Motto in Illinois of their jurisdictional significance.

In sum, because he purposefully availed himself of the Illinois market through his deliberate and continuous exploitation of that market, which in turn gave rise to Mt. Gox’s business with and communications to Greene and Motto in Illinois, Karpeles has a constitutionally sufficient connection with Illinois to justify the exercise of specific jurisdiction.

The case continues at the Illinois Northern District Court.

Read this next

Institutional FX

Marex profit soars 70pct in H1 2022 on commodity boom

London-headquartered commodities broker Marex posted record revenues in the first half of 2022 as strategic investment across its global franchise has positioned the business to outperform in favourable market conditions.

Executive Moves

YourBourse hires 3 executives to transform development procedures

“Valter, Maria, and Sergey bring decades of experience in the FX industry to our company and I’m very excited how they will enable our ambitious growth plans.”

Technology

Baton adds OCC to collateral management network

“For the FCM community, this translates into ensuring money isn’t being left on the table. Our FCM clients are already using the Baton platform to move tens of billions of dollars of collateral every week.”

Retail FX

eToro buys US rival Gatsby to expand zero-fee trading offering

Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company eToro has secured the regulatory nod to acquire no-fee trading app Gatsby as it aims to expand its business in the US.

Executive Moves

Genesis Global snatches CMO Jason Jhonson from metaverse company

The hire of Jhonson follows the announcement that Genesis raised $20 million in fresh funding from US banking giants, Bank of America, BNY Mellon and Citi.

Digital Assets

Celsius subsidiary GK8 integrates with Polygon while looking for new owner

“This integration affords our customers more agility in managing their crypto assets, which is key to creating new revenue streams.”

Digital Assets

BDO Italia audits Tether reserves to release monthly attestation

World’s largest stablecoin issuer, Tether has switched the accounting firm that audits the massive reserves that back its USDT token to BDO Italia, the 5th largest accounting firm in the world.

Retail FX

Libertex bags multi-year sponsorship deal with FC Bayern

Indication Investments Ltd, the operator of FX retail brand Libertex, has secured a lucrative sponsorship deal with German soccer giant FC Bayern.

Institutional FX

PrimeXM reports lower volumes for July as summer lull bites

PrimeXM has reported weaker trading volumes for July 2022, in line with other institutional and retail platforms that saw the activity of their clients dropped compared to a month earlier.

<