Industry executive with 59 years of institutional experience appalled by FXCM situation details all to FinanceFeeds

“I was told many moons ago that Mr Niv had an ‘in house’ price provider, but I discounted the ‘rumor’ telling those who told me, that no person could be that stupid to believe they could do such a thing without being caught out.”

Almost a week has elapsed since the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) took action against FXCM, one of the world’s largest and most highly respected OTC FX brokerages, after generating a comprehensive report that revealed its findings that FXCM’s US division had been trading against its customers for several years.

The milestone ruling which shocked the entire OTC derivatives industry detailed that FXCM had enlisted the services of an external market maker, of which FXCM had an undisclosed interest, to take the opposite positions of FXCM’s retail customers via an algorithmic system developed by FXCM, whilst all the while purporting publicly to be executing trades on an agency basis.

Senior directors Drew Niv and William Ahdout, along with FXCM are now banned from operating in the US, with 150 staff having been let go, and the company’s reputation in absolute tatters, share prices on the ground and litigation commencing.

Many executives across the FX industry have spoken to FinanceFeeds during the course of the last week to provide perspective, as this is a poignant event that may well change the entire global perspective on OTC execution and how to monitor it, as well as shatter any argument that the OTC industry has against the pressure mounting from the exchange fraternity to place retail trading on exchanges by default.

Today, FinanceFeeds spoke to a veteran of the FX industry, who has over 59 years worth of experience in institutional venues across the world from London to Hong Kong to Sydney, at senior level.

A highly well recognized executive, FinanceFeeds has granted anonymity on the basis that this particular executive is privy to a vast amount of detailed insde information.

The conversation began with an exclamation “FXCM is a disgrace!” he said.

“My ‘value judgements’ about doing business with them was based on their ‘no dealing desk’/no conflict of interests structure” he continued.

“I was told many moons ago that Mr Niv had an ‘in house’ price provider, but I discounted the ‘rumour’ telling those who told me, that no person could be that stupid to believe they could do such a thing without being caught out.”

“To me the arrogance of people doing such things clearly demonstrates that they do not have a competent view of the real world!” stated the industry executive.

“To me the demise of FXCM has been brought about by the worst kind of ‘spiv’ behaviour by telling/assuring clients of one business ‘morality’ position, and then conducting business with them by doing the opposite” he continued.

“Irrespective of the FXCM debacle I ask you the following question about whether you feel that there should be a league table available to all participants in the market to see the real positions [financially and operationally] of all FX brokers” he asked. FinanceFeeds cuncurs that this is a good idea and potentially beneficial to all industry participants in the quest for complete impartiality and transparency which would protect our industry from any doubt or defend against any regulatory ruling that could force OTC business onto exchanges.

This particular executive then detailed the background that he uses as an example for how the FXCM debacle can be held up as completely unacceptable.

“Many years ago I was a director of Australian Ratings Pty Ltd, which later became Standard and Poors of Australia” he said.

“I cannot stop reflecting and analysing in my mind the tragedy inflicted on the markets by the FXCM debacle. For all past major unexpected happenings I have experienced since I joined the London Stock Exchange trading floor in 1959, I have always considered immediately after the event, the opportunities for reforms to strengthen the framework of the structures fundamental to the operation of fair and just markets” he said.

“In London, I was a trainee dealer with Durlacher Co which had 90 individuals on the Floor of the London Stock Exchange, and we were ‘market makers’, known as stockjobbers” he explained.

“At that time our firm made prices in more than half of all stocks quoted on the Exchange. We ran a ‘book’ in all those stocks. Our customers were exclusively Stockbrokers.”

“We had zero access to any other institutions and Stockbrokers only bought and sold stocks via Stockjobbers. This system was well considered and designed by those who had the power to institute a system which prevented ‘conflicts of interest’ between dealers [principals] and brokers [agents]” he further explained.

“I was brought up in this system and I have championed it all of my life. At every opportunity, particularly when I was a financial journalist with Australia’s major daily newspaper, I hammered the difference between ‘principal’ and ‘agent’” he said. (FinanceFeeds has read all of this material, dating back to 1982 – Ed.)

In conclusion, he said “I used every opportunity offered to me to say that so called ‘Chinese Walls’ were only the invention of Institutions, such as the major US Wall Investment Banks, so that they could ‘legally’ take a principal position, and at the same time act as ‘so called’ agents.”

Bearing in mind the gravity of this situation, it is interesting that Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has not yet followed suit. Where there is smoke, there is usually fire.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Scope Markets promotes James Hughes to head of marketing

Belize-based FX and CFDs brokerage Scope Markets has promoted James Hughes, who until recently was its head of brand, to take on an expanded role as the company’s global head of marketing.

Retail FX

Fraudsters clone Financial Commission’s website, two ex-members under suspicion

The Financial Commission, an industry-specific dispute resolution service that caters to the financial services industry, today announced that it believes a clone website has been impersonating its membership roster.

Retail FX

CMC Markets warns of operational challenges in Q1

CMC Markets PLC (LSE:CMCX) said in a trading update for the fiscal year 2023 that February and March posed a more challenging environment with lower equity volumes and a higher proportion of lower margin institutional trading activity.


Why Is Digital PR So Important for Financial Service Providers? Buzz Dealer’s CEO Uri Samet with the Answers

Digital PR is all about spreading your message faster, wider, and stronger in the online world, through proper SEO, link-building, and organic and paid social media work.

Inside View

Why And How Are Virtual Cards Disrupting The Finance Industry

Virtual cards have the potential to revolutionize the finance industry by providing faster and more secure payments, wider acceptance, and eco-friendliness.


Sweat Economy’s Oleg Fomenko on upcoming launch of Move-to-Earn app in the US

With the crypto winter’s biggest hurdles seemingly behind us as the prices of Bitcoin et al. climb the charts again, the Web3 economy is preparing for the next phase.

Industry News

OptionMetrics acquires Woodseer to add dividend forecast data for equities

“The addition of Woodseer’s product suite will enhance our ability to serve financial market stakeholders and academic institutions in their analysis of equity market performance and risk.”

Digital Assets

Metacade raises over $14.7M as presale set to close in 72 hours

Metacade, one of the most exciting GameFi ventures of 2023, has now raised over $14.7m as the presale goes into its final hours. With over 90% sold, the project expects to sell out ahead of their scheduled closing time, set for Friday 31st March at 23:59 Pacific Time. 

Digital Assets

Coinme launches Circle’s USDC on Stellar network

“By enabling USDC on Stellar in the Coinme wallet, anyone with cash can now utilize the Stellar blockchain to access a fully-backed dollar digital currency. People can now swap their cash for USDC on Stellar and send it in seconds for the cost of a penny.”