Is the P&L model dead and buried? Not by a VERY long way

The rapid shift away from remunerating sales staff, partners, affiliates and introducers on net deposit a couple of years ago took effect in order that the retail FX industry could emulate the institutional sector and provide retail clients with an ethical trading system, whilst providing a more steady stream of income for the broker, and […]

The rapid shift away from remunerating sales staff, partners, affiliates and introducers on net deposit a couple of years ago took effect in order that the retail FX industry could emulate the institutional sector and provide retail clients with an ethical trading system, whilst providing a more steady stream of income for the broker, and encouraging longer term relationships for all parties.

So much emphasis has been placed on this, that it has become widely understood across the entire industry that the ‘profit and loss’ model is a think of the past.

This is very much not the case at all, and in order to investigate, FinanceFeeds conducted extensive research in Shanghai, China, the center of attention for all industry participants worldwide.

Whilst most affiliates and introducers in the region are insistent on ensuring that their clients remain with them long term, and contrary to popular belief, are very cautious when entering into a deal with a broker to ensure that their clients will be catered for with their best interests in mind, this giant, fabulous and advanced financial powerhouse is home to some very large companies which operate their business purely on net client loss.

Whilst it most certainly could be argued that a profit and loss deal between broker and introducing agent is potentially against client interest, it is also most certainly worthy of consideration that it is not in the best interest of a broker from not only a risk management point of view but also a cash flow perspective.

If an introducing agent is remunerated on spread mark up, or commission as a revenue share, this ensures a steady income stream for the introducing agent, however, if remuneration is conducted on a profit and loss model, and there is a month in which many clients make a profit, then no commission would be due at all, and the introducing agent would be saddled with operating costs and staff salaries, but have no income.

Let’s put some figures on it. FinanceFeeds research has concluded that in Shanghai alone, there are approximately 10 introducers which would like to operate on a profit and loss model, however western brokerages which have a large share of the Chinese IB market do not operate with this method therefore they (and their customers) are targets for those which do.

Three companies in downtown Shanghai which prefer the profit and loss model have a net deposit amount of around $30 million per year, with clients purely trading using EAs.

IB commission is roughly $20 million per annum per firm, and there are approximately $100 million in assets under management within each company. The business model takes into consideration that clients will lose a combined total of approximately $70 million per year, hence the net deposit figure.

Remarkable indeed, and perhaps not as unsustainable as was once thought as word travels very quickly in China if things go awry for customers.

 

 

Read this next

Institutional FX

Verto launches EM FX marketplace: NGN, ZAR, XAF, XOF, KES, GHS, UGX

“We’ve seen significant pent-up demand looking for counterparties, which is one of the reasons we’re launching this product. We built Verto Marketplace to directly address these systemic issues, offering a platform that provides the control, transparency, and cost-efficiency that traders, brokers, and corporate treasurers need.”

Payments

BVNK launches Swift payments to move between fiat and stablecoins

“Adding USD and EUR via Swift means that our customers can really take full advantage of stablecoins to speed up their money movement, wherever they are based – and they can easily get back into fiat currencies if and where they need to.”

Market News

Base metals could soon take off from the base again

Dive into our full analysis to understand the potential resurgence of base metals and what it could mean for your investment strategy.

Digital Assets

Global clamp down on crypto tax evasion to go live in 2027

“As jurisdictions that play host to active crypto markets, we therefore intend to work towards swiftly transposing the CARF into domestic law and activating exchange agreements in time for exchanges to commence by 2027.”

Digital Assets

Ripple and Archax team up for tokenization with XRPL

“There is clear real-world utility in use cases like RWA tokenization for the operational efficiency, access to liquid markets and transparency inherent to crypto, and Archax has already tokenized assets such as equities, debt instruments and money market funds. Financial institutions are now understanding this and we are excited to play our part in helping them to embrace the technology by bringing their assets onto the XRPL.”

Interviews

Acuity Trading at iFX EXPO LATAM: Andrew Lane on the rise of AI and prop trading

At iFX EXPO LATAM 2024, Acuity Trading’s Andrew Lane discussed the successful rollout of their Research Terminal, the impact of AI on the trading industry, competition from AI-powered solutions, emerging market trends in Latin America, and the rise of prop trading, while addressing regulatory challenges and innovations.

blockdag

Top Crypto Highlights for Q2 2024: BlockDAG’s Astonishing 1120% Growth Compared to Solana’s Surge and Toncoin’s Market Triumph

Explore the latest highlights in cryptocurrency: Solana’s recovery, Toncoin’s record levels, and the rise of BlockDAG’s innovative technology.

Digital Assets

Ripple seeks $10 million penalty citing Terraform fine in SEC case

Ripple Labs wants to reduce the financial penalties proposed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by leveraging recent fines imposed on Terraform Labs.

Digital Assets

Swiss regulator shuts down CoinShares’ partially-owned FlowBank

Switzerland’s financial regulator, FINMA, has closed FlowBank SA and placed it into bankruptcy due to severe breaches of capital requirements and other supervisory laws. This follows a series of enforcement actions against the bank that began in October 2021.

<