Judge dropped “bombshells” on SEC vs Ripple, top lawyer argues

Rick Steves

The lawsuit against Ripple alleges co-founders aided and abetted Ripple’s unregistered sales of securities, dating as far back as 2013 and 2015 respectively.

Attorney Jeremy Hogan, a partner at Hogan & Hogan, has commented on the most recent court session of the SEC vs Ripple lawsuit and referred to a “bombshell” dropped by the Judge, in where she interrupted Brad Garlinghouse’s lawyer Matthew Solomon to say:

“My understanding about XRP is that not only does it have a currency value but it has a Utility and that utility distinguishes it from Bitcoin and Ether.”

Attorney Solomon disagreed and said XRP is similar to Ethereum, but the Judge’s statement admits to XRP’s utility and currency value.

With currencies and securities being two different things, the SEC argument that Ripple is a security may be losing its credibility with the Judge. In regard to utility, that’s the point Ripple has been making the whole time.

The Judge also questioned the SEC attorney that, based on his theory, “everyone who sold XRP – including you and me – are selling illegal securities”. The SEC lawyer said, “no, under Section 4, only Ripple and affiliates of Ripple can have sold XRP illegally”.

This statement from the SEC lawyer clears the way for the cryptocurrency exchanges in the United States to re-list XRP again with no fear of reprisal.

The lawsuit against Ripple alleges co-founders aided and abetted Ripple’s unregistered sales of securities, dating as far back as 2013 and 2015 respectively.

In its answer, Ripple stated it had “never offered or sold XRP as an investment” and that “XRP holders do not acquire any claim to the assets of Ripple, hold any ownership interest in Ripple, or have any entitlement to share in Ripple’s future profits.”

In addition, the cryptocurrency firm argued that “utility depends on XRP’s near-instantaneous and seamless settlement in low-cost transactions. Treating XRP as a security, by contrast, would subject thousands of exchanges, market-makers, and other actors in the gigantic virtual currency market to lengthy, complex, and costly regulatory requirements.”

Of the 23 major financial market jurisdictions, nine of them haven’t taken any form of enforcement action against crypto-related companies, and the remaining jurisdictions have a more lenient approach compared to the SEC in a deliberate strategy to appeal to fintech startups.

Acknowledging that the size of the U.S. cryptocurrency market is a contributing factor to the SEC’s high rate of intervention, a research paper by Rutgers School of Law Professor Yuliya Guseva argues the Howey test is a key factor for the SEC action and it is no longer suitable for judging 21st-century innovations.

Read this next

Institutional FX

Deutsche Bank goes live with its FX pricing and trade engine in Singapore

Deutsche Bank has gone live with its electronic foreign exchange pricing and trading engine in Singapore, where demand for currency trading among institutional players is on the rise.

Retail FX

CySEC extends the suspension of Depaho license until November 19

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) has decided to extend further the suspension of the license of the Cyprus investment company Depaho Ltd, which operates the retail FX brands GTCM, FXGM and TRADEAPP.

Retail FX

CAPEX.com introduces QuantX, a tool to build automated portfolio

Multi-licensed broker CAPEX.com has rolled out a new portfolio platform, QuantX, which uses a client’s risk tolerance assessment and other criteria to create fully customized investment portfolios.

Digital Assets

Ripple scores major win: Judge orders SEC to explain…a lot

The SEC is ordered to explain, among other things, how the Howie test applies to XRP, what is the status of Ether and Bitcoin, and the sale of XRP as investment contracts.

Retail FX

Trade CFDs on 900+ of the Biggest Companies this Earnings Season with HotForex

Traders with the internationally acclaimed multi-asset broker HotForex can trade CFDs on the stocks of over 900 companies during Earnings Season with tight spreads, flexible leverage, negative balance protection and the many other advantages that have made it an honest, open and transparent broker of choice to over 2.5 million traders around the world.  

Digital Assets

Polygon (MATIC) double spend bug yields $2 million bounty for developer

Polygon, the Layer 2 solution on top of Ethereum, has recently paid out the highest ever bug bounty in history to a whitehat developer Gerhard Wagner for pointing out a double-spend bug in the network which could have resulted in huge losses if it had been exploited.

Digital Assets

KuCoin aims to become largest social trading platform in crypto

KuCoin was founded in September 2017 and it currently provides Spot trading, Margin trading, P2P fiat trading, Futures trading, Staking, and Lending to its 8 million users in 207 countries.

Digital Assets

Apifiny’s crypto trading network adds Instant Transfers for best bid and offer

Instant transfers significantly enhance Apifiny Connect, allowing traders to more efficiently buy and sell on 25 connected markets across six continents.

Retail FX

iFOREX clients can follow two experts trading in real time

Trading Rooms’ access will be free of charge for active traders who open an account with the broker.

<