KPMG wants clarity on GAIN Capital – TIBCO dispute

Maria Nikolova

KPMG remains in the dark as to whether it should comply with GAIN’s request to provide information about all audits it has conducted for TIBCO Software over the past five years.

Evidence to be provided by KPMG is now at the center of a legal dispute between TIBCO Software and online trading major GAIN Capital. Whereas TIBCO alleges that GAIN has overdeployed its software, the broker has filed counterclaims against TIBCO accusing it of fraud in the inducement and negligent misrepresentation.

The underlying dispute concerns software deployment. Beginning in 2008, GAIN licensed TIBCO software on a worldwide “enterprise basis,” meaning GAIN was entitled to deploy an unlimited number of software units during a designated “enterprise term,” the latest of which ended in 2012. According to TIBCO, GAIN did not have a license to deploy any units outside of that enterprise term- e.g. past 2012. In August 2016, KPMG audited GAIN and determined GAIN had deployed hundreds of software units outside of the enterprise term, that is, without a valid license.

This audit is now at the heart of the dispute. Both parties have served KPMG with subpoenas asking for information related to this audit. But GAIN wants to know more.

GAIN has filed the so-called “Non-Mutual Requests”, which call for KPMG to produce information related to every other audit that KPMG has conducted for TIBCO during the last five years. Specifically, GAIN seeks discovery related to (a) the number of audits KPMG has conducted on behalf of TIBCO, (b) fees associated with those audits, and (c) confidential third-party customer information such as the identification of TIBCO customers audited and the results of those audits.

According to GAIN, in reality, KPMG’s audit was fundamentally flawed and TIBCO has a pattern and practice of engaging KPMG to conduct audits of customers and deliberately giving KPMG incorrect instructions so that KPMG will inevitably find “overdeployment” of TIBCO software on its customers systems.

GAIN stresses that TIBCO has been involved in disputes with other companies involving strikingly similar fact patterns. GAIN contends that TIBCO’s deliberate conduct and use of KPMG to set up its clients for extortionate claims of overdeployment amounts to fraud.

TIBCO wants GAIN to withdraw these non-mutual requests. GAIN refuses to do so.

On Tuesday, August 14th, KPMG filed a letter with the California Northern District Court, noting that it has had some discussions with GAIN over its information requests but that these discussions have been put on hold as TIBCO seeks a protective order regarding the information GAIN wants to obtain.

It is apparent that KPMG has no clarity on how to proceed and that it will have to wait for the Court to decide on whether it should provide the details GAIN wants.

The case is captioned TIBCO Software Inc., v. Gain Capital Group, LLC (5:17-cv-03313).

Read this next

Executive Moves

Christine Kiener joins Saxo Markets UK as Head of Institutional Sales

“I have been very impressed by the strong track record, clear strategic pathway and ambition of the Saxo business. I am excited to start working with the team to further grow the institutional footprint which has been established in the UK.”

Industry News

CFTC charges Rathnakishore Giri with $12m Bitcoin ponzi scheme

“Identifying and policing fraud in these emerging markets may be difficult or delayed in light of the agency’s limited visibility in these markets”, said CFTC Commissioner Kristin Johnson.

Institutional FX

AbbeyCross raises $2.47m to develop FX market infrastructure for EM currencies

Many EM currencies are currently traded without full-price discovery, creating an unlimited compliance and regulatory risk.

Digital Assets

YouHodler enhances Multi HODL: faster rates and execution, lower fees

“We know some traders mentioned freezing issues when opening or closing a Multi HODL deal. Now, those problems are completely gone”.

Industry News

ASIC bans Funds United Pty director for six years

The six-year ban will prevent Ms. Hutchinson from controlling an entity that carries on a financial services business, and performing any function within the industry.

Inside View

Brave new world: Recruitment of fintech talent in the new UK immigration environment

In this article, solicitor Denise Osterwald outlines what UK businesses should do to attract top talent from abroad.

Digital Assets, Interviews

FX goes Crypto: Exclusive interview with BVNK’s Jonathan Cumberlidge

BVNK is the new name in the City of London. Co-founded by ex-TradFi Chris Harmse, Balfour Group founder Jesse Hamson-Struthers, and ex-TrueLayer George Davis, the firm provides a single platform to bridge fiat and crypto together. 

Digital Assets

AAX ranked world’s second largest spot exchange, only behind Binance

Crypto trading volumes experienced their first surge in activity since March as the majority of digital assets began their recovery from the recent grim price action, according to a new report by Cryptocompare.

Digital Assets

Bitpay teams up with Cardlytics to provide 15% cashback rewards

Crypto payment service provider Bitpay announced a partnership with Cardlytics Inc (NASDAQ:CDLX), which it says will offer more rewards for BitPay cardholders on its platform.

<