Mark Karpeles insists case brought by US clients of MtGox should be dismissed

Maria Nikolova

The defense counsel argues that the Illinois Northern District Court lacks personal jurisdiction over Karpeles, and the case against him must be dismissed.

Mark Karpeles, the former head of ill-fated Bitcoin exchange MtGox, on Tuesday submitted his response to the allegations by the plaintiffs in a US case targeting Karpeles and Mizuho Bank.

Karpeles’ counsel insisted that, under binding Seventh Circuit law and the evidence submitted to the Court, the Illinois Northern District Court lacks personal jurisdiction over Karpeles, and the case against him must be dismissed.

According to the defense counsel, the plaintiffs (that is, several former US clients of MtGox) never mention, and therefore abandon, the claim that “Karpeles conducted business throughout this District, the State of Illinois, and the United States.” The alleged wrongful conduct took place in Japan, not in Illinois, the defense notes.

Karpeles is said to have not “purposefully directed his activities at the forum state or purposefully availed himself of the privilege of conducting business in that state”.

Next, the defense proceeds to explain the difference in what Mizuho Bank knew about MtGox’s customers who wired money to the bank and what Karpeles knew. What Mizuho Bank knew and what Karpeles knew about these plaintiffs is very different and compels a different result in this case for Karpeles, his counsel says. Mizuho Bank had knowledge of the plaintiffs’ location. Furthermore, there is no reason to believe that Mt. Gox or Karpeles were given any information on where wire transfers to Mizuho Bank originated.

Procedural difficulties are also mentioned, as the Japanese Government has forbidden Karpeles to leave Japan. Additionally, discovery would be extremely difficult, even impossible.

Finally, the defense counsel addresses the so-called “fiduciary shield” doctrine issues. MtGox was not the alter ego of Karpeles, the defense says. The fiduciary shield doctrine applies here and is yet another basis that precludes the exercise of personal jurisdiction over Karpeles in Illinois, the defense states.

Let’s recall that the fiduciary shield doctrine prevents courts from asserting jurisdiction over a person on the basis of acts taken by that person not on his own behalf, but on behalf of his employer.

“The fiduciary shield doctrine does not protect a defendant who has decision-making authority and a financial stake in the company that directed him or her to a jurisdiction,” the plaintiffs had argued.

Mark Karpeles, however, insists that this doctrine protects him. He requests the Court to dismiss the allegations against him.

Mark Karpeles is being sued in Illinois by US clients of MtGox who accuse him of:

  • intentionally, with gross recklessness, or negligently stealing plaintiffs’ bitcoins and fiat currency;
  • negligence, alleging that Karpeles owed the plaintiffs a duty of reasonable care to prevent improper access and misuse of the plaintiffs’ bitcoins and fiat currency and to allow authorized users complete access to the same and breached those duties;
  • consumer fraud – Karpeles represented that he would protect MtGox clients’ bitcoins and fiat currency and allow them to buy, sell, trade, and withdraw those funds, while siphoning, or allowing others to siphon, funds from Mt. Gox customers’ accounts.

The plaintiffs also allege that Karpeles concealed that Mizuho Bank was no longer providing international withdrawal services, that thousands of bitcoins had been lost or stolen, and that he was shutting down the exchange and filing for bankruptcy.

The case is captioned Greene v. MtGox Inc. et al (1:14-cv-01437).

Read this next

Institutional FX

State Street launches FIX API for Fund Connect ETF platform

“Expanding from proprietary APIs to the FIX industry standard will bring us closer to our goal of 100% digital interactions. This is another example of innovations we’ve brought to our operating model as we celebrate 30 years of servicing ETFs since the launch of SPY.”

Industry News

HollyWally opens office in Portugal to bring B2B2C wallet-as-a-service platform to Europe

“We looked at a number of centers for startups throughout Europe and were attracted straight away to Lisbon. There is great Government support and enthusiasm for startups, it’s well positioned between our Asian and US offices, it’s a cost-effective city in which to base a fintech and it’s a beautiful place.”

Retail FX

Eightcap integrates Acuity’s economic calendar for trade ideas on MT4 or MT5

“By incorporating Acuity’s cutting-edge AI technology into our platform, we are able to offer our clients a powerful new tool that will help them stay ahead of the markets. We are committed to providing an extensive range of tools and educational resources that will enhance our clients’ trading experience and allow them to trade smarter.”

Inside View

Private Equity Renaissance

Recent years have seen a resurgence in the concept of trading physical equities, with a slew of new arrivals joining the market for what is arguably one of the oldest forms of investing. But what has been the driving force behind this change in momentum?

Digital Assets

Dubai introduces new crypto regulations with fines of up to $135,000

Against the backdrop of a crashing market and burned investors, Dubai has sealed a landmark rulebook that governs how the Emirate will regulate cryptocurrency activities.

Institutional FX

FX volume drops 16pct at Russia’s largest exchange in January

The Moscow Exchange, Russia’s largest exchange group, released its monthly batch of trading volumes and metrics for January 2023 – the latest readings showed a pullback across the board for multiple segments, namely in the FX, given lower volatility and a reduced trading schedule.

Institutional FX

Standard Chartered sets up wholly-owned brokerage arm in China

UK-headquartered bank Standard Chartered said its Hong Kong arm has been granted an in-principle approval for a brokerage license from the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC).

Digital Assets

Revolut offers staking for Ether, Cardano, Polkadot, and Tezo

British fintech and banking firm Revolut has introduced crypto staking — a practice of earning rewards for serving as a transaction validator in the Ethereum blockchain – to its UK and European Economic Area (EEA) customers.

Inside View

Saxo releases Q1 2023 Quarterly Outlook: “The Models Are Broken”

“2023 is likely to prove a rough ride for currencies if the USD bear market fails to continue in a straight line, but EUR and JPY may outperform.”

<