Missing reports and discrepancies with Europe’s policy – UK approach to LIBOR gets under fire

Maria Nikolova

Lord James of Blackheath criticizes SFO over LIBOR trials and asks the new government to decide “how we are going to sort out the mess we are in”.

london

The manipulation of LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate) has continued to make headlines this year, especially after a recording implicated the Bank of England in the rate rigging scandal. More pressure has been piled on the way the UK has handled the issues amid reports of critical evidence “disappearing”.

On Monday, the House of Lords heard the statement of Lord James of Blackheath who starkly criticized the way UK regulators and authoritative bodies have handled LIBOR-related issues.

Lord James noted the sequence of four LIBOR cases which have passed through the High Court in the last 18 months. There have been 15 prosecutions, five convictions, two cases where the juries have failed to agree and eight acquittals. As a result, he said, there are “so many confusions and unresolved issues from this process and our parallel LIBOR market in Europe, called Euribor, is complaining so much that it may seek to shut us out and take the entire market, to our significant financial detriment.”

One of the key issues is that the UK is apparently at variance with the remainder of Europe, which has stated that it will have no LIBOR prosecutions for any incident that occurred prior to April 15, 2013, as the new regulations came into force on that date. All the prosecutions that the UK has seen go back as far as August 2006, so they would not have been relevant.

Tom Hayes, a former derivatives trader at UBS and Citigroup in Tokyo, was arrested in Surrey on December 11, 2012 by officers from the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) and City of London Police in connection with an SFO investigation into the manipulation of in Japanese Yen LIBOR. Lord James reminded the fellow Lords that back in the days the Financial Conduct Authority convened an expert committee, which examined the situation and said that the senior executive to whom Mr Hayes had had to report his fixings on a daily basis had behaved correctly. It said that there was no question of his disqualification and all accusations were discarded.

The FCA then sent a copy of its report of the proceedings to the SFO, asking that it be placed in the hands of the defence counsel for the trial against Mr Hayes. Three weeks into the trial, it was found that the SFO had never released the report, and it was never seen again. The judge refused to allow it to be submitted as late evidence and the jury accordingly convicted. Mr Hayes got a prison sentence and a fine.

Lord James also slams the SFO over the “experts” it provided with regards to LIBOR-related trials. He notes that the expert witness provided by the SFO had broken down in the fourth trial, and had confessed that “he did not know the first thing about LIBOR, had never worked a day in the LIBOR market and had been given coaching by the SFO as to what to say to convince the jury”.

Lord James calls on to the new government to address three LIBOR issues:

  • First, as a matter of common justice they need to decide how we are going to sort out the mess we are in with this one.
  • Secondly, we have to work out how we are going to amend the statute book and codes of practice to ensure that we are clean for the future.
  • Thirdly, we have to get ourselves back into LIBOR permanently and stay there.”

Read this next

Institutional FX

Verto launches EM FX marketplace: NGN, ZAR, XAF, XOF, KES, GHS, UGX

“We’ve seen significant pent-up demand looking for counterparties, which is one of the reasons we’re launching this product. We built Verto Marketplace to directly address these systemic issues, offering a platform that provides the control, transparency, and cost-efficiency that traders, brokers, and corporate treasurers need.”

Payments

BVNK launches Swift payments to move between fiat and stablecoins

“Adding USD and EUR via Swift means that our customers can really take full advantage of stablecoins to speed up their money movement, wherever they are based – and they can easily get back into fiat currencies if and where they need to.”

Market News

Base metals could soon take off from the base again

Dive into our full analysis to understand the potential resurgence of base metals and what it could mean for your investment strategy.

Digital Assets

Global clamp down on crypto tax evasion to go live in 2027

“As jurisdictions that play host to active crypto markets, we therefore intend to work towards swiftly transposing the CARF into domestic law and activating exchange agreements in time for exchanges to commence by 2027.”

Digital Assets

Ripple and Archax team up for tokenization with XRPL

“There is clear real-world utility in use cases like RWA tokenization for the operational efficiency, access to liquid markets and transparency inherent to crypto, and Archax has already tokenized assets such as equities, debt instruments and money market funds. Financial institutions are now understanding this and we are excited to play our part in helping them to embrace the technology by bringing their assets onto the XRPL.”

Interviews

Acuity Trading at iFX EXPO LATAM: Andrew Lane on the rise of AI and prop trading

At iFX EXPO LATAM 2024, Acuity Trading’s Andrew Lane discussed the successful rollout of their Research Terminal, the impact of AI on the trading industry, competition from AI-powered solutions, emerging market trends in Latin America, and the rise of prop trading, while addressing regulatory challenges and innovations.

blockdag

Top Crypto Highlights for Q2 2024: BlockDAG’s Astonishing 1120% Growth Compared to Solana’s Surge and Toncoin’s Market Triumph

Explore the latest highlights in cryptocurrency: Solana’s recovery, Toncoin’s record levels, and the rise of BlockDAG’s innovative technology.

Digital Assets

Ripple seeks $10 million penalty citing Terraform fine in SEC case

Ripple Labs wants to reduce the financial penalties proposed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by leveraging recent fines imposed on Terraform Labs.

Digital Assets

Swiss regulator shuts down CoinShares’ partially-owned FlowBank

Switzerland’s financial regulator, FINMA, has closed FlowBank SA and placed it into bankruptcy due to severe breaches of capital requirements and other supervisory laws. This follows a series of enforcement actions against the bank that began in October 2021.

<