No more trading against your clients! European regulator cites conflict of interest, FinanceFeeds investigates

It took several years for the regulatory authorities in many jurisdictions that are populous with retail FX brokerages to address one of the longest standing taboos since the dawn of electronic trading companies that position their services toward the private individual. Seventeen years have elapsed since the establishment of Matchbook FX, which paved the way […]

trading

It took several years for the regulatory authorities in many jurisdictions that are populous with retail FX brokerages to address one of the longest standing taboos since the dawn of electronic trading companies that position their services toward the private individual.

Seventeen years have elapsed since the establishment of Matchbook FX, which paved the way for retail brokerages, however it wasn’t until the mid-2000s that the influx of B-book brokerages headed onto the market, most of which used the MetaTrader 4 platform and offered fixed spreads, whilst executing orders via a dealing room which warehoused trades – effectively giving rise to what became colloquially referred to as the ‘profit and loss model.’

Whilst the entire retail FX industry has evolved significantly over the last seven or eight years and trading platforms are now designed to be connected to liquidity providers which in turn have relationships with Tier 1 banks in order to provide aggregated liquidity and give retail traders a finely honed system which provides direct access to the world’s currency markets with pricing that reflects the live market , only now have many regulators began to take a close look at the method by which brokerages execute trades on behalf of clients.

Many brokerages which traditionally operated a ‘profit and loss’ model were unregulated, therefore creating a situation in which there was no jurisdiction, whilst those in regulated markets operated according to best execution practices.

This subject has now become a priority for the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) which has issued a very direct statement which reads “Where a firm is adopting a dealing model under which the profit made by the firm is dependent upon the clients of the firm making losses, such that the execution of relevant transactions is inseparable from a material conflict of interest between the firm and its clients, NCAs should consider whether the conflicts of interest arising from such a model can be managed, and, as a consequence, whether such a business model can comply with firm’s obligation to act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of its clients (Article 19(1) of MiFID), and to take all reasonable steps to avoid conflicts of interest.”

mushegh
Mushegh Tovmasyan

“For example, a firm offering CFDs or other speculative products acting as the counterparty to a retail client’s trade without any hedging arrangements in place has no incentive to execute orders in the best interest of the client, because if the client “wins”, the firm “loses.” Such a conflict of interest in all likelihood cannot be managed and should therefore be avoided, by not adopting such a business model” states ESMA.

This may well signal the end of the profit and loss model among all brokerages in Europe, and therefore it is important to gain perspective from liquidity providers and prime brokerage firms as to how this impacts the industry. Many brokers that were asked for their opinion on this matter declined to comment, however the perspective from those who did is very interesting indeed.

Mushegh Tovmasyan, CEO of Divisa Capital explained to FinanceFeeds today: “ESMA is targeting three potential offenders, as follows:

(1) STP firms that use their offshore group company as a counterparty to effectively skirt regulatory oversight and capital requirements;

(2) Companies who STP flow to a B book Liquidity Provider and benefit from a profit share; and

(3) Companies who do not have any hedging relationships at all.

Mr. Tovmasyan explains further that “I disagree that ESMA are putting a blanket ban on B booking. Instead, there is a growing effort to make sure that B booking is done within the providers’ financial means and that firms seeking to engage in risk management do so in a transparent manner that does not cause conflict with clients or regulators.”

“Brokers fall foul with the regulators when they claim to be STP but all volume goes to a non-regulated B book shop, and conflicts of interest with clients occur when they advertise STP, interbank, ECN execution when in fact all trades are going to another B book shop, usually an unregulated one” said Mr. Tovmasyan.

Mr Tovmasyan added that “this should not come as a surprise to the more risk prone B book shops out there, who have known for a while that they need to diversify their risk by securing access to real liquidity in the interbank market to cope with changing market conditions.”

Yiannis Gerousis, Head of Dealing at FXPRIMUS explained to FinanceFeeds “Market making firms who deal on account should make all efforts to act as a systematic internalizers by matching clients positions with each other, and thus profit from spread with no hedging cost. Trying to be on the other side of the trade and waiting for clients to lose so they can profit from losses might lead to conflict of interest which should be Indeed, whilst the b-book model is likely to continue to be the execution model of choice across many retail brokerages, it is clear that the regulators are accepting to this – of course it has certain risk management and execution speed benefits, however maintaining a facility to provide true market pricing is becoming an increasing focus of the regulatory authorities, as is ensuring that brokers do not view client deposits as their profit.

Image courtesy of Banco Carregosa

Read this next

Inside View

Crypto Liquidity Providers: No Transaction, No Party!

One of the most integral parts of trading cryptocurrencies is ensuring seamless transactions; however, this is not always easy when you first start using cryptocurrency exchanges.

Digital Assets

Niftables launches white label NFT platform for content creators and brands

Niftables is the go-to platform for brands and creators looking to realize their NFT vision — whether they’re an individual or the biggest entertainment company in the world.

Retail FX

ACY Securities sponsors Table Tennis NSW as CFD broker bets in Australia’s youngest

ACY Securities has partnered with Table Tennis New South Wales (TTNSW) for a two-year sponsorship agreement intended to highlight the Chatswood-based multi-asset CFD broker’s brand in Australia, with a focus on the southeastern state.

Executive Moves

Peter Hetherington appointed CEO of Capital.com, Currency.com, and Shares.com

With his extensive experience driving strategy and growth for leading wealth and brokerage firms in highly regulated markets, Peter is the ideal CEO to lead the Group on its next chapter of growth and success.”

Digital Assets

Crypto platform Elwood raises $70m from Goldman Sachs, Dawn, Barclays, BlockFi, Flow, Galaxy, more

Elwood Technologies has closed a $70 million Series A funding round co-led by Europe’s largest B2B investor Dawn Capital and global investment bank, Goldman Sachs.

Industry News

Wilshire to launch Climate Change 1.5℃ Target Index with Nikkei and Hang Seng

Wilshire has announced a collective launch with Nikkei and Hang Seng to bring to market the first in a series of indexes empowering investors to transition their investments towards a low-carbon and climate resilient economy.

Industry News

Anne Boden’s Starling Bank bets big on UEFA Women’s EURO 2022 tournament

Starling Bank has launched a campaign ahead of the UEFA Women’s EURO 2022 tournament as part of its national sponsorship, the biggest ever for the bank.

Industry News

Older adults flock to financial apps as Revolut reports 215% more UK users aged 55-74 since pandemic

Data has also shown that older adults are back to travelling as the 55-64 UK age group has seen a tenfold increase in the amount spent in foreign countries over the past two years, and the 64-75 age group isn’t far behind with an 840% increase.

Industry News

Ripple replies to SEC’s last attempt and “shoves it down their throats pretty hard”

“The SEC really messed that up. How can Hinman receive legal advice from SEC lawyers for a personal opinion?”, attorney Hogan commented.

<