NY Court denies ex-Deutsche Bank traders’ motions for acquittal or new trial

Maria Nikolova

Black’s and Connolly’s communications confirmed that they understood the impact that moving LIBOR would have on counterparties.

Judge Colleen McMahon of the New York Southern District Court has dashed the hopes of former Deutsche Bank traders Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black for acquittal or a new trial in a case alleging their participation in a scheme to manipulate the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR). 

On Thursday, May 2, 2019, the Judge signed Decision and Order denying the defendants’ motion for judgment of acquittal or a new trial.

Connolly and Black were convicted by a jury of conspiring to commit wire fraud and bank fraud, as well as actual substantive wire fraud in connection with a scheme to cause their employer – Deutsche Bank, to submit false and fraudulent USD LIBOR submissions to the BBA. Connolly and Black then each moved for a judgment of acquittal or, in the alternative, for a new trial. On May 2, 2019, Judge Colleen McMahon nixed the motions.

In her Decision and Order, the Judge noted the heavy volume of evidence showing that Connolly and Black participated in the scheme to manipulate LIBOR. For example, in an email, Connolly requested: “If possible, we need in NY 1mo libor as low as possible next few days…tons of pays coming up overall… thanks!”. Or, for instance, a chat where Black asked: “can we have a high 6mth libor today pls gezzer?”

The Judge also stressed that the Jury heard evidence that the defendants asked Deutsche Bank submitters to change the bank’s submissions in line with their trading positions, from which jurors could easily infer that the Bank’s Libor submissions were not a true estimate of borrowing costs, but rather numbers manipulated for its financial gain. The evidence thus showed that Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR submissions were false and fraudulent statements because they did not actually reflect the conspirators’ estimates of the bank’s borrowing costs.

According to the Judge, the jury heard sufficient evidence to find that Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR submissions were fraudulent because each submission carried with it the implicit certification that it was determined according to the BBA’s rules – which is not what happened.

Further, contrary to the defendants’ assertion, the evidence at trial did not establish that LIBOR submitters were free to set their submissions within a “reasonable range” that took account of their banks’ trading positions. Importantly, the evidence showed that Deutsche Bank had a method for determining one particular rate – not a range of rates – at which it could ask and accept interbank offers for each currency and tenor, per the BBA’s definition.

The scheme to defraud was material to the BBA, as well as to Deutsche Bank’s counterparties. Black’s and Connolly’s communications confirmed that they understood the impact that moving LIBOR would have on counterparties. Black acknowledged the “sort of linkage that fixing to trillions of derivative contracts all around the world”. The Judge says that a reasonable juror could easily find from this evidence that the defendants acted consciously to benefit Deutsche Bank at the detriment of its counterparties, and thus, acted with intent to defraud. Similarly, the jury could reasonably find that neither of the defendants acted in good faith.

The Judge also discarded the defendants’ attempt to shift the blame to Deutsche Bank’s training.

“That defendants were not specifically trained not to manipulate LIBOR does not negate their fraudulent intent, any more that does the fact that others were also doing it”. 

Read this next

Digital Assets

Societe Generale launches its own cryptocurrency, EURCV

French banking giant Societe Generale has launched its own euro-pegged stablecoin, EUR CoinVertible (EURCV). This move by France’s third-largest bank reflects the increasing trend of mainstream financial institutions embracing cryptocurrencies on a global scale.

Executive Moves

Stelios Eleftheriou leaves NAGA Group to join BVNK

BVNK, the crypto-powered payments and banking platform for businesses, has appointed FX industry veteran Stelios Eleftheriou, who has a colorful career across the gaming industry, as Business Development Director (CFD & iGaming).

Retail FX

CAPEX.com introduce ETFs on UAE, Saudi stocks

Abu Dhabi-based broker CAPEX.com has expanded its asset class offerings to include a new suite of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) tailored for the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) markets.

Institutional FX

Tradeweb Markets surges past $1.80 ADV in November

Tradeweb Markets Inc. (Nasdaq: TW) has reported a total trading volume of $38.2 trillion and a record average daily volume (ADV) of $1.80 trillion for November 2023. These figures mark a 59.2% year-over-year increase.

Inside View

A Mission in Accounting

Ismael Haber, an auditor and accountant, has made it his mission to help businesses improve the quality of their financial information by eliminating fraud and error. In the next five years, the demand for these specific financial services, being external financial audits, forensic accounting, and other fraud preventive and detective services is envisaged to increase.

Institutional FX

CME Group to launch new spot FX marketplace ‘CME FX Spot+’ in 2024

US derivatives exchange, CME Group today announced plans to introduce ‘CME FX Spot+’, a novel spot foreign exchange (FX) marketplace.

Interviews

FMLS:2023: Andrew Mreana provides an exclusive sneak peek into cTrader’s 2024 innovations

cTrader’s focus for the next year would be on developing new tools for Introducing Brokers (IBs) and partners, particularly those related to algorithmic (algo) trading, the company’s head of growth told FinanceFeed in an exclusive interview at the Finance Magnates London Summit 2023.

Digital Assets

Grayscale’s Ethereum ETF stalls: SEC extends review to January 2024

The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has extended the evaluation period for Grayscale’s proposed Ethereum spot ETF.

Institutional FX

BMLL completes China equity data offering: Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Hong Kong

“Demand for China data has never been higher. This is set against a general industry trend of increased market participant sophistication, and an increasing demand for quality historic market data to understand market microstructure and venue behaviour. Market participants need to get the full picture of market quality, liquidity and order book dynamics to ultimately make better informed decisions on the markets they trade and the venues they run.”

<