NY Judge dashes attempt by seven US stock exchanges to dismiss HFT case

Maria Nikolova

The Exchanges are accused of selling certain services to high-frequency trading firms, which then used those services to engage in allegedly manipulative trading schemes at the plaintiffs’ expense.

A market manipulation case targeting some of the biggest US stock exchanges, including BATS Global Markets, Inc., Chicago Stock Exchange, Inc., Direct Edge ECN, LLC, New York Stock Exchange, LLC, NYSE Arca, Inc., Nasdaq OMX BX, Inc., and the Nasdaq Stock Market LLC, continues at the New York Southern District Court.

On Tuesday, July 16, 2019, Judge Jesse M. Furman dashed an attempt by the Exchanges to dismiss the case against them.

The plaintiffs – several investment funds – bring claims against seven stock exchanges under Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. § 78j(b). In brief, the plaintiffs allege that the Exchanges sold certain services to high-frequency trading (HFT) firms, which then used those services to engage in allegedly manipulative trading schemes at the plaintiffs’ expense. The Court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims in 2015, holding that the Exchanges were protected by absolute immunity and that, in any event, the plaintiffs had failed to plead any manipulative acts or “primary” violations of Section 10(b) by the Exchanges.

The Court of Appeals, however, disagreed on both counts and remanded the plaintiffs’ Section 10(b) claims for further proceedings.

The Exchanges then renewed their motion to dismiss, pressing arguments that the Court of Appeals had left open. In an Opinion and Order entered May 28, 2019, the Court denied that motion. The Exchanges have then moved, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b), for certification of an interlocutory appeal.

In its Memorandum Opinion and Order, issued on July 16, 2019, the New York Southern District Court denied the defendants’ motion. The Court concluded that certification is not warranted.

The Court noted that the plaintiffs’ allegations, taken as true, establish that they were “sufficiently frequent purchasers” to have been “systematically victimized by distorted prices,” thus satisfying the necessary standards.

The Exchanges argue that the plaintiffs’ failure to allege “that they purchased or sold any particular security” gives rise to a “substantial ground for difference of opinion” as to whether they adequately allege statutory “standing” and loss causation.

But the Court noted that under binding Second Circuit precedent, because an omission claim “can involve facts solely within the defendant’s knowledge, at the early stages of litigation, the plaintiff need not plead manipulation to the same degree of specificity as a plain misrepresentation claim.” The Court therefore held that Plaintiffs had pleaded their claims with sufficient particularity. The Exchanges offer no reason, the Judge said, to conclude there is substantial ground for difference of opinion on that issue.

In short, according to the Judge, the Exchanges do not satisfy their burden to show a substantial ground for difference of opinion on the issues they raise – at least not one substantial enough to warrant the “strictly limited” Section 1292(b) certification procedure. Accordingly, their motion to certify an interlocutory appeal was denied.

Read this next

Fintech, Uncategorized

BitMEX integrates HALO from Solidus Labs for cross-market surveillance

““The recent approval of the Spot Bitcoin ETF has piqued the market’s interest. As a result of price volatility, the trading volumes for crypto derivatives have gone up substantially. HALO, with its advanced technology and crypto-native detection architecture, will enable BitMEX to smoothly and safely scale trade surveillance across its increased trading volumes and provide the necessary safeguards for new product launches.”

Industry News

Horizon Software rebrands to Horizon Trading Solutions

“Horizon Trading Solutions has seen accelerated global growth over the past year to meet the rising demand for our trading solutions and built-for-purpose technology offering. The choice to rebrand represents a key part of this development, while maintaining our heritage and history in the industry.”

Market News

USDJPY has surged to levels last witnessed in 2022. Should we consider opening a short position?

The recent resurgence of the US dollar has propelled USD/JPY to new heights, touching levels not seen since 2022. This surge comes against the backdrop of stable short-term yields and ongoing economic data that fails to signal a significant slowdown, prompting questions about the extent of current monetary easing measures.

Digital Assets

DED Trends on Twitter After Memecoin Snapshot Announcement

Polkadot-backed community coin #DED, made it to the trending charts on X, demonstrating community’s engagement and interest behind the memecoin. 

Digital Assets

BlockDAG Presale Nears $10 Million Amid Toncoin’s Momentum, Green Bitcoin’s Presale, and the Rise of Other Top Cryptos

This article will examine three top trending topics: Toncoin’s potential, Green Bitcoin’s innovative presale, and BlockDAG’s sustainable mining approach. These cryptocurrencies take centre stage for their uniqueness and innovation.

Digital Assets

Coinbase scores minor victory vs SEC, but lawsuit to proceed

A federal judge in Manhattan, U.S. District Judge Katherine Polk Failla, ruled on Wednesday that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) lawsuit against Coinbase can largely proceed.

Web3

COTI Teams Up with Civic for Enhanced Digital Identity Control

СOTI and Civic are teaming up to enhance digital identity security in Web3, aiming to provide users with more control over their digital selves through innovative technology.

Digital Assets

BlockDAG Takes on Chainlink (LINK) Crypto, and RON With DeFi Card and 5000x Profit Potential

Explore BlockDAG’s innovative DeFi card, which transforms cryptocurrency into spendable cash, alongside Chainlink (LINK) crypto and Ronin’s advancements.

Digital Assets

Court finally decides on Sam Bankman-Fried sentence, experts predict 20 years

Sam Bankman-Fried, the former CEO of the now-defunct cryptocurrency exchange FTX, is set to face sentencing on Thursday in a pivotal moment that could see the entrepreneur beginning a lengthy period in federal prison.

<