Plaintiffs in FX benchmark rate fixing case oppose DOJ’s request for discovery stay extension

Maria Nikolova

The plaintiffs in the case targeting banks like JPMorgan and Citi are unaware how the depositions would interfere in the DOJ’s criminal proceedings.

Plaintiffs in a Forex benchmark rate fixing case targeting banks like JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE:JPM), Citigroup Inc (NYSE:C), Bank of America Corp (NYSE:BAC), and HSBC, are opposing the latest request by the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) for a three-month extension of the limited discovery stay in the lawsuit.

On Friday, March 16, 2018, the plaintiffs filed a Letter with the New York Southern District Court, arguing that the depositions they ask for are crucial to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs state they have no reason, and are unaware of any reason, how the depositions would interfere, in any way, in the proceedings by the Department of Justice, and that delays of depositions always carry with them the prospects of witnesses either changing positions, memory loss, and/or availability.

The plaintiffs say they have advised the defendants of the specific persons to be deposed on numerous occasions, including the Case Management and Scheduling Plan, Status Reports, and the Notices of Deposition.

In conclusion, the Court has ordered that the case would be governed by a protective order. Therefore, to the extent that the attorneys and witnesses are prohibited from revealing to others the scope and nature of the depositions, it cannot be said by the Government that such a situation would interfere with any ongoing investigations, the plaintiffs state.

Let’s recall that the plaintiffs had previously indicated their intentions to take depositions from:

  • Stuart Alderoty, Esq., former Senior Executive Vice President and General Counsel, HSBC Bank USA, N.A.;
  • Marc Moses, Executive Director and Group Chief Risk Officer, HSBC Holdings plc;
  • James Fuqua, Esq., General Counsel, UBS Securities LLC, Investment Bank Americas;
  • Axel Weber, Chairman of the Board of Directors, UBS Group AG;
  • Matthew Fitzwater, Esq., Global Head of Litigation, Investigations, and Enforcement, Barclays PLC;
  • Rohan Weerasinghe, Esq., General Counsel and Corporate Secretary, Citigroup, Inc.;
  • Stephen Cutler, Esq., former General Counsel and current Vice Chairman, JPMorgan Chase & Co.;
  • James Esposito, Esq., Global General Counsel, NatWest Markets and General Counsel (Americas), Royal Bank of Scotland.

In December, the Court sided with the Department of Justice and granted its application for a discovery stay. Now, the DOJ is seeking to prolong the stay again.

The plaintiffs in this case, however, managed to secure an important win earlier this week, as Judge Schofield issued an Order which denied the Motion to Dismiss launched by the defendant banks in this case.

The Judge found that the plaintiffs’ third amended complaint sufficiently pleads antitrust injury because it alleges facts supporting a reasonable inference that the foreign currency consumer retail market in which the plaintiffs participated was directly restrained by the banks’ alleged manipulation of FX benchmark rates.

The action, captioned Nypl v. JP Morgan Chase & Co. et al (1:15-cv-09300), is brought on behalf of a putative class of consumers and end-user businesses alleging that they paid inflated foreign currency exchange rates caused by an alleged conspiracy among the defendant banks to fix prices of FX benchmark rates in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, 15 U.S.C. sec. 1 et seq.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Binance upgrades Bahrain license to offer full-suite of crypto services

The Central Bank of Bahrain (CBB) has granted Binance its Category 4 license as a fully-fledged crypto-asset service provider (CASP).

Digital Assets

BitMEX spot exchange hits $24 million in daily volume

The newly-launched spot market of crypto exchange BitMEX reported a record of $24 million in 24-hour trade activity on May 25.

Retail FX

Financial Commission certifies offering of trade copier 4X Solutions

The Financial Commission, an independent self-regulatory compliance specialist for the financial services industry, has certified the trading technology offered by trade copier 4X Solutions.

Industry News, Inside View

LIVE from Devexperts webinar for brokers on Fractional Trading

Finance Feeds is providing live coverage of the event that aims to help brokers discover fractional shares as a key tool for a successful brokerage business in today’s trading industry.

Industry News, Retail FX

ASIC celebrates retail ban on binary options as 68% of wholesale clients lose money

In the 13 months before the ban, between 74% and 77% of active retail clients lost money trading binary options. The product intervention order does not apply to wholesale clients.

Crypto Insider

Investing in crypto: how to stay away from weak players

The main reason behind the hacks of crypto exchanges is weak key management. For example, all 4 hacks that took place in 2021 were caused by the ability of hackers to obtain access to hot wallets. 

Retail FX

Vantage launches swap-free gold XAUUSD trades for all clients until end of July

“As the greenback continues to strengthen, we want to support traders who remain bullish on gold or seek short term trading opportunities amid the volatility”

Industry News

Broadridge launches ESG reporting solution ahead of European regulation SFDR

The Broadridge managed solution for EET adds to existing Broadridge services, including European PRIIPs Template, European MiFID Template, Solvency II Tripartite Template and many more across the European jurisdictions.

Industry News

iCapital to acquire embedded structured investment platform SIMON

SIMON’s platform, SPECTRUM, is a multi-dimensional allocation analysis and portfolio construction tool designed to evaluate how structured investments and/or annuities may fit into a portfolio.