The price of silence: Mizuho’s inaction comes into focus of MtGox case

Maria Nikolova

The bank insists its silence and inaction cannot render it culpable for any damage caused to US customers of MtGox who could not get their money back after the Exchange got into trouble.

Mizuho Bank, which has been accused of creating transaction difficulties for MtGox’s customers, is stepping up its defense in the United States by using a rather unconventional argument which centers around its inaction and silence.

Let’s recall what the case is about. When MtGox’s head Mark Karpeles refused to close Mt. Gox’s account at Mizuho, the bank instituted a series of policies it kept secret from the public that were designed to frustrate Mizuho’s relationship with Mt. Gox. Thus, Mizuho limited and ultimately stopped processing international wire withdrawals from Mt.Gox’s Mizuho account. Mizuho, however, continued to accept international cash deposits into the Mt. Gox account.

In January 2014, plaintiff Joseph Lack, a resident of California, joined Mt. Gox. Upon joining, Lack wired $40,000 to Mt.Gox’s Mizuho account. Mizuho accepted the transfer and collected the transaction fee. On February 24, 2014, the website of the exchange went dark. Lack waited in vain for his deposit to appear in his Mt Gox account. He did not succeed in getting his money back.

Accordingly, Lack brought an action against Karpeles and Mizuho. Lack alleges that Mizuho had a duty to disclose material information to him and the other depositors. Also, the plaintiff accuses Mizuho of intentionally defrauding him by concealing that the bank was no longer accepting withdrawal requests. Furthermore, the plaintiff alleges that Mizuho caused him damage.

Mizuho has earlier tried to rebut the claims but the California Central District Court sided with the plaintiff  and denied the bank’s motion to dismiss.

Now, Mizuho aims to appeal from that Court’s decision. It filed the respective motion on Monday, July 23rd.

The official question that Mizuho raises is the following:

May a foreign bank defendant’s passive acceptance of wire transfers, coupled with an allegedly wrongful silence or inaction pursuant to the bank’s generally applicable worldwide policy, subject a bank to personal jurisdiction in each forum state in which a wire transfer originates, consistent with the requirements of the Due Process Clause of the United States Constitution?

The issue at hand is of wide applicability: whether a foreign bank’s alleged silence or inaction pursuant to the bank’s generally applicable worldwide policy creates a substantial connection with the forum state (in this case, California) so as to support personal jurisdiction. Foreign banks indeed accept wire transfers from their customers’ customers all the time.

Mizuho then goes on to explain how wires are something pretty much unrelated to it. Here is the precise wording:

“To accept a wire transfer is passive conduct, especially because, by its nature, a wire transfer is not a communication between people, but just a transmission of information electronically from a machine at one bank to a machine at another. Indeed, Lack is not alleged to have had any direct contact with Mizuho”.

Mizuho is alleged to have simply remained silent – which is to say, it said (and did) nothing. In substance, according to the bank, the transaction was between Lack and Mt. Gox, whereas Mizuho played no substantive role.

Mizuho does not dispute that Mt. Gox customers reside in 175 countries, and at least 30,000 of them live in the United States. The bank also concedes that if a court in California may exercise personal jurisdiction over Mizuho based solely on Mizuho’s receipt of wire transfers without disclosing to the sender the alleged change in Mizuho’s relationship with its customer, then so can courts in all other jurisdictions in the United States where Mt. Gox customers reside.

The defendant bank insists that its “inaction” was not targeted at California-based clients of MtGox. The damage caused to Lack is dubbed by the bank to be incidental.

The case, captioned Joseph Lack v. Mizuho Bank, Ltd., et al (2:18-cv-00617), continues at the California Central District Court.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Binance US weighs plans to go public, CEO CZ says

Binance.US, the American outpost of the world’s biggest crypto exchange, has seemingly plans to follow Coinbase’s path and go public one day.

Retail FX

FX volumes, number of active clients boom at Exness in June 2021

The latest group of retail FX platforms to report their monthly volumes indicate that June was a busier month all round, with Exness setting its second-highest monthly volumes on record.

Industry News

Individuals impersonating CySEC representatives draw warning from Cyprus watchdog

The Cyprus financial watchdog said on Friday there was evidence of fraudulent impersonation of its officials who are engaged with firms under CySEC’s supervision.

Digital Assets, Inside View

SEC v. Ripple angers XRP holders as rival Stellar (XLM) mixed in “love triangle” over MoneyGram

“Although the SEC claims that all XRP are unregistered securities and Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen unjustly enriched themselves, it allows Ripple Co-founder JedMcCaleb to sell his XRP for hundreds of millions of dollars to possibly buy MoneyGram. Makes perfect sense”, said XRP Holders’ attorney John Denton ironically.

Industry News

Monex loses second appeal in CFTC anti-fraud enforcement action

Since Dodd-Frank that such trading must be conducted on a regulated exchange, and that the offeror must be registered with the CFTC.

Technology

Profile Software announces automated custody platform and mobile tech

The upgraded version of Axia Custody offers advanced functionality for multi-custodian operations across borders for a competitive multi-channel international-level client experience.

Industry News, Institutional FX

IHS Markit to pay CME Group $113m amid EU approval of post-trade JV

IHS Markik, at the same time, is being acquired by S&P Global Inc for $44 billion in stock, subject to approval as well.

Digital Assets

India’s Central Bank working towards implemention of digital currency

The Deputy Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, T Rabi Sankar, has said that the central bank was working towards a phased implementation of a central bank digital currency and is in the process of introducing it for wholesale and retail segments shortly.

Industry News

Visa acquires Currencycloud to facilitate global funds movement

Visa has announced the acquisition of Currencycloud, which provides APIs which help institutions with remittance and currency exchange capabilities in a deal that is valued at $963 million.