Ripple execs state list of demands to end XRP lawsuit

Rick Steves

Despite the demands, Ripple execs admitted the SEC wants a trial by jury.

The much-awaited Individual Defendants’ Answers have been filed, thus fixing the deadline for the SEC’s position on additional discovery to April 15, 2022, and the deadline for the Joint Proposed Scheduling Order to April 22, 2022.

Both the Brad Garlinghouse response and the Chris Larsen answers mostly deny the SEC’s allegations or state the defendants lack sufficient knowledge to either admit or deny the allegations.

The documents also expresses what the individual defendants want from the court as to put an end to the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit.

Pressure on the SEC has mounted tenfold since yesterday’s revelations that the agency was aware of Bill Hinman’s “full financial conflict of interest” with his old firm and that he disregarded internal advice in order to meet people at Simpson Thacher or clients several times.

“SEC not entitled to relief”

Garlinghouse’s list of 440 answers and Larsen’s thread of 442 answers end with a similar statement:

“Plaintiff’s prayer for relief and judgment (including Sections I through V) does not require a response, but to the extent any response is necessary, Mr. Larsen [Garlinghouse] denies that Plaintiff is entitled to the requested relief and judgment or to any relief whatsoever, and therefore requests that the Court:

1. Dismiss the action with prejudice;
2. Enter judgment in favor of the Defendants against Plaintiff with respect to all causes of action in the Complaint;
3. Award Mr. Larsen [Mr  Garlinghouse] his attorneys’ fees and all other costs reasonably incurred in defense of this action; and
4. Award Mr. Larsen [Mr  Garlinghouse] any other relief as the Court may deem just and proper.

Additionally, the individual defendants said admitted that the SEC “demands a trial by jury”. Such a trial would lead to further delays in a case that was filed a year and a half ago and is holding back one of the most prominent blockchain companies in the world as well as one of the leading digital assets by market capitalization.

XRP is not a security for regulators in the UK, Japan, Singapore

The overall answers seem to be consistent with Ripple’s and the individual defendants’ claims since the beginning, that transactions in XRP do not constitute securities, as they are not “investment contracts” under the Supreme Court’s decision in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946).

The defendants reiterated the utility argument, that XRP (and the XRP Ledger) has utility separate and apart from any value it may hold as an investment.

They also reaffirmed that Ripple has never offered or sold XRP as an investment in Ripple; that Ripple never sold XRP in an Initial Coin Offering; and that XRP holders do not acquire any claim to the assets of Ripple, hold any ownership interest in Ripple, or have any entitlement to share in Ripple’s future profits.

In the answers, they took the opportunity to remind the SEC and the court that seven years ago, the DoJ and FinCEN determined that XRP is lawfully used and traded in the marketplace as a virtual currency due to its functions as a store of value, a medium of exchange and a unit of account—not a share in Ripple’s profits.

The SEC and the court were also reminded that securities regulators in the United Kingdom, Japan, and Singapore have likewise concluded that XRP is a virtual currency not subject to securities regulation. As the U.K. Treasury stated recently, “widely known cryptoassets such as Bitcoin, Ether and XRP” are not securities, but “[e]xchange tokens” that “are primarily used as a means of exchange”.

In the meantime, the court is expected to rule on the SEC’s Motion for Partial Reconsideration, the Defendants’ Motion to Strike the Supplemental Expert Report, the Defendants’ Motion to Compel Turnover of the Estabrook notes, and the decision on the SEC’s proposed redactions.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Japan advances digital yen trial as PoC concluded

The Bank of Japan (BOJ) today published the findings of the second phase of its digital yen’s proof-of-concept (PoC) experiment, joining a growing number of countries seeking to catch up to front-runner China.

Digital Assets

Russia scraps proposal for government-backed crypto exchange

Russia has decided to abandon its previous plans of creating a national cryptocurrency exchange and will instead focus on developing regulations that would enable private companies to establish such exchanges.


CFI Financial onboards Elena Kupriyanova as head of marketing

CFI Financial Group has named Elena Kupriyanova as its new global head of marketing in a bid to bolster its marketing efforts and enhance its market presence.

Retail FX

Trading 212 revenue tops 2021, but bottom line disappoints

Per its filing with the UK companies house, Trading 212 UK said revenue from online trading rose to £98.7 million in the fiscal year ending December 31, 2022, up five percent compared to £94 million a year earlier.

Digital Assets

Binance to cease services for Japanese users after local launch

Binance is poised to reenter the Japanese market through the launch of a fully compliant subsidiary in the country. This development comes a few months after Binance made a fresh bid to return to the lucrative market in November 2022 with the acquisition of Japanese-registered crypto exchange service provider Sakura Exchange BitCoin (SEBC).

Digital Assets

Huobi Hong Kong offers crypto trading for retail clients

Huobi HK, a subsidiary of digital asset exchange Huobi Global, has made an announcement stating that it is now providing crypto spot trading services to both retail and institutional clients in Hong Kong.

Digital Assets

Bybit’s Strategic Leap: Navigating the Cryptocurrency Landscape in Kazakhstan

In a significant leap forward, Bybit, the globally recognized cryptocurrency exchange, has received preliminary approval from the Astana Financial Services Authority (AFSA), marking an important milestone in its strategic expansion into Kazakhstan and the wider Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) region.


Bitcoin 2023: Unlimit’s Jack Jia discusses fiat on/off ramps for crypto business

Unlimit’s expansion into the crypto space aims to bridge the gap between traditional banking networks and the rapidly evolving crypto world, facilitating seamless conversions into various digital wallets and enhancing scalability through off-chain solutions.

Digital Assets

European Systemic Risk Board warns of crypto conglomerates, leverage, DeFi, staking, lending

The report considers policy options to address risks arising from crypto conglomerates, crypto-based leverage, novel operational challenges, DeFi and crypto staking and lending.