Ripple forced to deliver XRP evidence that supports SEC case

Rick Steves

“Ripple is ORDERED to conduct a reasonable search of the relevant video and audio-taped recordings and produce responsive documents.”

After a week of silence, Judge Netburn has ordered Ripple to search for and turn over video and audio recordings of the firm’s internal meetings.

The SEC’s motion to compel was granted as expected after an extensive back and forth between both parties.

Ripple argued that the plaintiff’s “boil-the-ocean demand” was “flatly incompatible with the federal rules” as well as the SEC’s claim that the recordings will prove XRP was sold as securities is “sheer conjecture”.

The SEC said that Ripple’s conduct necessitated this motion: “Ripple failed to search its library of recordings—or even inform the SEC that it was withholding responsive recordings—until its former Chief Compliance Officer testified in the last month of fact discovery that Ripple maintained such recordings.

Attorney Jeremy Hogan, who has been commenting on the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit right from the start, said last month that the recordings dispute was “not looking good for Ripple” and that they will form the backbone of the SEC case and that is why that whether it is able to gain access to more recordings is very important to the lawsuit.

He also predicted that the Judge would rule in favor of the SEC’s motion with limitations and he was right. The order is transcribed below:

“Ripple’s search of its recorded meetings has been inadequate under the circumstances. While the Court recognizes that a human review of the recordings may be unreasonable, a reasonable search could include automated transcriptions of recordings (similar to the common technology used to transcribe voicemail messages) and the use of search terms.

“Accordingly, Ripple is ORDERED to conduct a reasonable search of the relevant video and audio-taped recordings and produce responsive documents. Because Ripple represents that it has more than 4,000 recordings, the parties are ORDERED to meet and confer to determine whether there are particular time periods when recordings are most likely to be responsive to the SEC’s discovery demands.

“For example, meetings in the weeks preceding dates of significance may generate more probative material than meetings held at other times. Similarly, cross-references with the calendars for the Individual Defendants or other key employees may identify meetings of significance.

“In light of the close of discovery, Ripple is order[ed] to undertake such efforts without delay.”

This can be considered a major win for the SEC as the evidence found in Ripple’s recordings is likely to beef up the agency’s case that the defendants sold and marketed XRP as an investment contract. This is the plaintiff’s main argument against Ripple.

On the other side, Ripple’s main argument in its favor is that the SEC failed to provide fair notice that the sale of XRP could be construed as an investment contract.

The lack of fair notice is something the whole crypto ecosystem has been complaining about for years as the regulatory framework for digital assets remains unclear and the SEC has been only regulating by enforcement or via “personal opinions” from its officials.

Attorney Jeremy Hogan commented on the ruling: “Remember, an Order like this might give the SEC some bullets for its gun (and vice versa when Ripple wins), but the next BIG Order is on the SEC’s motion to strike the Fair Notice Defense. THAT is the bazooka!”


Read this next

Digital Assets

Crypto miner BitFuFu to go public on Nasdaq through $1.5 billion SPAC merger

Cloud-mining service provider BitFuFu, backed by industry giant Bitmain, will go public through a merger with a blank-check firm in a deal that values the combined entity at $1.5 billion. This valuation is 4.6x 2022 projected revenue and 3.3x projected December 2022 annualized recurring revenue.

Digital Assets

Bithumb will no longer allow withdrawals to unverified crypto wallets

Bithumb, one of South Korea’s big four exchanges — alongside Coinone, Korbit, and Upbit — exchange is moving to block the use of anonymous wallets.

Retail FX

Cyprus compensation fund (ICF) to protect customers of Sonafx and BelightFX

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) today published a new list of financial services providers that were disbarred from its lifeboat scheme.


Exclusive interview with Stacey Van Niekerk of Finalto Group

With qualifications in A+ IT certification; in programming and wealth management as well as currently studying Investment Management at CISI Stacey Van Niekerk is an incredible asset to the Finalto Group. Having 10 years combined extensive experience in the Financial Industry working and helping Brokerage Firms and Fintech companies assist clients around the world in regions such as Australia; Africa; Europe; Asia; Uk and Mena Stacey is now responsible for driving Finalto’s B2B technology offering.

Institutional FX

MOEX lifts restrictions on repo transactions, including short positions

Russia’s largest institutional trading venue has lifted restrictions it applied last month to repo transactions with a central counterparty (CCP) in US shares.

Retail FX

USGFX has a heavy shortfall in client money, nearly $350M missing

BRI Ferrier, the liquidators of Union Standard International Group, known as USG or USGFX, today said creditor claims have hit $357 million, and this amount may increase further.

Industry News

Ripple fails to stop discovery extension amid SEC’s 180º on Hinman’s speech

The plaintiff has made a 180º turn by suggesting that the speech wasn’t merely peripheral to actual policy formulation”, but was in fact an “essential link” in the SEC’s deliberative process with respect to Ether” and other digital assets. 

Digital Assets

Gemini hires Pravjit Tiwana as CTO with eyes on Web3 and Metaverse

“I want to help build Web3 and the decentralized Metaverse. The promise is as big as the Internet itself and Gemini is well-positioned to help build and catalyze that future.”

Institutional FX

Broadridge automates Santander’s Shareholder General Meeting services in Spain

Broadridge has recently expanded coverage for proxy processing and extended voting windows for 20 sub-custody markets in 2021, with more markets to follow in 2022 and 2023.