Ripple gives four more reasons to get SEC’s internal docs in XRP lawsuit

Rick Steves

The Ripple counsel reminded the court that the SEC’s internal documents are also relevant to the Howey analysis, scienter and fair notice, as well as the objective review of defendants’ understanding in thinking about the aiding and abetting charge.

Ripple has responded to the SEC’s claim that a prior ruling by Judge Torres has made the Hinman 2018 speech and related notes and the Estabrook notes irrelevant to the XRP lawsuit.

The SEC argued that the court considered the abovementioned emails and notes only relevant to the dispute over the individual denfendants’ recklessness.

Judge Torres denied their motion to strike the case against them and that ruling made the privileged material irrelevant and undiscoverable, according to the SEC.

Howie, scienter, fair notice, and “aiding and abetting”

“The January 13 Opinion compelling the SEC to produce communications regarding the Hinman speech was expressly not premised on a finding that the Individual Defendants’ articulation of the standard of recklessness was correct and the SEC’s was erroneous. Judge Torres’s recent decision therefore does not merit reconsideration of the Court’s January 13 Opinion. ”

Ripple argued the court order does not undermine the relevance of the Hinman speech communications or the court’s holding that those materials are not privileged. The same applies to the Estabrook notes.

The defendants then explained that the Hinman speech communications are directly relevant to the fair notice defense, which Judge Torres specifically allowed to proceed over the SEC’s motion to strike.

“Contrary to the SEC’s suggestion, Defendants have never suggested that communications related to the Hinman speech were relevant only to the recklessness standard”, the Ripple counsel stated, adding that the SEC’s internal documents are relevant to the Howey analysis, scienter and fair notice, as well as the objective review of defendants’ understanding in thinking about the aiding and abetting charge.

Summary judgment schedule by mid-May?

The SEC v. Ripple lawsuit is showing signs of an end in sight. In the SEC’s latest request for an extension, the plaintiff noted that Ripple proposed a summary judgment schedule with opening briefs and related fillings due in mid-May.

Ripple executives and individual defendants, Chris Larsen and Brad Garlinghouse, also plan to proceed with briefing despite the pending discovery-related motions. The SEC disagreed, stating it is premature.

“The SEC believes that such a briefing schedule is premature, given that the Individual Defendants have yet to answer the complaint and plead affirmative defenses, and respectfully requests that the court direct the parties to meet and confer regarding a summary judgment schedule once the SEC has advised the court of its position on the need for additional discovery.”

Read this next

Digital Assets

Mercado Libre launches crypto trading in Chile

Argentine e-commerce giant Mercado Libre (MELI) is continuing with expansion plans for its crypto business with a fresh launch in Chile, a comparatively wealthy South American nation.

Digital Assets

Gemini to launch overseas derivative exchange amid US crackdown

Gemini, the cryptocurrency exchange founded by the Winklevoss twins, is reportedly developing an international derivative trading platform in response to a US domestic crackdown on crypto assets.

Digital Assets

Thailand’s SEC to scrap $8,800 limit for retail investment in ICOs

Thailand’s Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) plans to lift the limit for retail investors who want to participate in initial coin offerings (ICOs) to boost asset-backed digital investments in the country.

Digital Assets

Kraken signs commitment to launch regulated business in Canada

San Francisco-based cryptocurrency exchange Kraken has filed a pre-registration undertaking with a Canadian provincial regulator as it works towards becoming a regulated provider in the country.


TT’s Keith Todd brings fixed income and cybersecurity to FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Keith Todd about Trading Technologies’ move to fixed income after nearly 30 years of existence. TT is also proposing cooperation and transparency among competitors to tackle cyber risks.

Digital Assets

Binance joins FIDO Alliance to enhance user security with introduction of passkeys

“With passkeys, a user can quickly and safely sign in across multiple sites, apps, and devices with local biometric authorization. Binance will offer users a more secure and streamlined experience using passkeys on our platform without compromising on security”.

Digital Assets

ipaymy taps TripleA in Singapore for rent, invoices, taxes, salaries in Crypto

“Our white label crypto payment solution enables our partners to reap the benefits of accepting crypto payments, without managing crypto on their balance sheets. This makes it an ideal solution for businesses looking to offer cryptocurrency payments volatility-free.”

Industry News

London and New York rank joint first as top financial centers, according to…London

“The UK remains one of the most open and global financial centres with better access to international markets than the US, France, or Japan. But our competitive advantage is at risk.”


Sterling Trading Tech (STT) discusses their Risk & Margin System at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Chief Customer Officer Keith Cacciola and Managing Director of Business Development Andrew Actman about STT’s competitive advantages, the challenges their clients face today, the firm’s product roadmap and new leadership at STT.