Ripple lawsuit: SEC finds way to kill DPP issue leveraging Judge’s statements

Rick Steves

“In light of Judge Torres’ Order, it is clear that the SEC’s internal documents reflecting its staff’s thinking about XRP, Bitcoin, Ether, or any other digital asset – have no relevance to the Individual Defendants’ scienter”, the SEC argued.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has filed a letter claiming that the court’s recent decision to deny Ripple executives’ motion to dismiss has made the DPP documents under dispute irrelevant to the case.

The letter supplements the SEC’s motion for partial reconsideration and clarification of the DPP ruling, which ordered the production of drafts of former Director Hinman’s speech and related internal communications.

SEC argues Court made DPP documents irrelevant

“For the reasons set forth below, the Order answers any question as to whether the SEC’s internal documents are relevant to the Individual Defendants’ scienter. They are not. Accordingly, the Order merits resolution of the two pending motions in the SEC’s favor, regardless of whether the DPP applies to the documents (as it does, for the reasons described in the SEC’s briefs on these motions).”

The SEC then argued that, in Judge Torres’ ruling on the motion to dismiss, the court was clear that the SEC’s internal documents have no relevance.

“In denying Individual Defendants’ motion to dismiss the aiding and abetting claims, Judge Torres expressly rejected Individual Defendants’ proposed scienter standard and resolved this dispute in the SEC’s favor. First, Judge Torres held that the SEC does not need to prove that Individual Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded that Ripple’s offers and sales of XRP violated Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933.

“Second, Judge Torres rejected the argument that “the SEC must show that they knew or recklessly disregarded that Ripple’s actions were somehow otherwise ‘improper.’

“Instead, Judge Torres ruled that, to prove the necessary mental state for aiding-and-abetting liability, the SEC must simply show that Individual Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded the facts that constitute a Section 5 violation.

“In light of Judge Torres’ Order, it is clear that the SEC’s internal documents reflecting its staff’s thinking about XRP, Bitcoin, Ether, or any other digital asset – have no relevance to the Individual Defendants’ scienter”, the SEC argued.

While the SEC is leveraging Judge Analisa Torres’ ruling on the motion to dismiss, the SEC’s motion for partial reconsideration and clarification of the DPP ruling will be decided by Magistrate Sarah Netburn.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Coinbase CEO says Chase UK’s ban on crypto “totally inappropriate”

Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong criticized Chase UK’s decision to restrict cryptocurrency-related transactions in the UK. He called the move “totally inappropriate” and expressed his disagreement with the bank’s decision to ban its UK customers from conducting debit card or wire transfers related to cryptocurrencies.

Digital Assets

Binance CZ refutes any connection with CommEX

Changpeng “CZ” Zhao, the founder and CEO of Binance, has denied being the owner of CommEX, the company that reportedly acquired Binance’s business in Russia.

Institutional FX

Refinitiv’s spot FX volumes hit 8-month low

Refinitiv, the former Financial and Risk business of Thomson Reuters, today reported that the average daily volumes (ADV) of currency trading were $424 billion last month on the company’s main FX trading services.

Executive Moves

Integral hires industry veteran Paul Arnold as liquidity manager

Integral, a technology provider to the financial markets’ buy-side, has appointed Paul Arnold, a highly experienced FX industry professional, as its liquidity manager, according to information made public on his Linkedin profile.

Digital Assets

Terraform’s Do Kwon challenges US extradition request

Do Kwon, the crypto entrepreneur and former CEO of Terraform Labs, is opposing the U.S. Securities Exchange Commission’s request to question him about the crash of his company’s stablecoins Terra and Luna.

Digital Assets

Coinbase gets nod to offer futures for retail customers

Coinbase International Exchange has received regulatory approval from Bermuda’s financial regulator, the Bermuda Monetary Authority (BMA), to allow eligible non-US retail customers to trade perpetual futures contracts.

Inside View

How brokers can win the trading tech wars: Insights from iFX EXPO 2023

Last week’s iFX EXPO International 2023, held at the City of Dreams Mediterranean Integrated Resort in Limassol, Cyprus, welcomed a series of insightful discussions. A panel that particularly stood out focused on the role and evolution of trading technology.

Crypto Insider

Web3 Transformation: Radix’s Babylon Update Redefines User and Developer Engagement

Radix Publishing leaps forward in the decentralized world with the release of the Babylon mainnet upgrade, bridging the gap between innovative tech and user-friendly DeFi experiences.

Digital Assets

Crypto.com Joins Forces with PayPal and Paxos for Enhanced PYUSD Exchange Experience

Crypto.com collaborates with PayPal and Paxos to fortify its position as the premier exchange for PYUSD, marking a significant milestone in the global crypto landscape.

<