Ripple scores important win against SEC as firm plans IPO

Rick Steves

The attorney-client privilege clearly stood in the way and provided Ripple with a much-needed win.

The court has denied the SEC’s motion to compel Ripple to produce memos discussing XRP sales with the firm’s lawyers – a motion that Ripple Labs argued went against the rules of attorney-client privilege.

That was precisely Judge Netburn’s rationale for her ruling as attorney-client privilege is designed to “encourage full and frank communication between attorneys and their clients and thereby promote broader public interests in the observance of law and administration of justice.”

The Judge, however, allowed the regulator to renew the same motion in case Ripple “raises its beliefs or relies upon its privileged communications in support of its fair notice defense.”

The battle over legal advice, which was heating up the courtroom this month, is now over. The SEC’s principal argument was the “fairness doctrine”. At an hearing, the SEC attorney Jorge G. Tenreiro said Ripple’s lawyers knew what the law required and that it could be a security.

“Their lawyers knew from the very beginning, and to now come and say to the court, “nobody knew”, and leave us unable to rebut that by showing all of the advice that they got, not just what they selectively disclosed to third parties, is fundamentally unfair and fundamentally against the fairness principle as recognized in this circuit”, said Mr. Tenreiro.

The attorney-client privilege clearly stood in the way and provided Ripple with a much-needed win. An important one as the defendant rests its affirmative defense on the basis that the SEC did not provide fair notice that XRP could be deemed a security, especially after a string of events that would suggest otherwise.

“In support, it cites to the SEC’s eight-year delay in pursuing enforcement action against Ripple for its alleged securities violations — even after XRP was listed on over 200 cryptocurrency exchanges, billions of dollars of XRP sales transactions had taken place, and Ripple had entered a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice and FinCEN that described XRP as a ‘convertible virtual currency”, the Judge wrote in the ruling.

A Ripple win on the Fair Notice defense “could save the industry from the SEC”, attorney Jeremy Hogan has recently stated. “It becomes persuasive authority for any crypto company the SEC sues from this point forward. If the Fair Notice defense survives and Ripple wins, the SEC is going to have an uphill battle winning any other lawsuit they bring.”

“But it’s even bigger than that. . . Even if Ripple loses the Fair Notice defense, they can appeal the ruling. And if an appellate court determines that Judge Torres was wrong and Ripple did not have Fair Notice, then the SEC is now really in trouble because that ruling is binding on every crypto lawsuit that comes along.”

It is no secret that Ripple intends to go public once the lawsuit with the SEC is over, but CEO Brad Garlinghouse renewed his plans in an interview at the Consensus 2021 event.

“I think that the likelihood that Ripple is a public company is very high at some point. I think in the middle of an SEC lawsuit, you know we need to get that closed out and the SEC approves an S1, it’s easier to do that after you have closure and clarity and that regulatory certainty we have been seeking for so long.”

SBI Group chief Yoshitaka Kitao, who has a seat in Ripple’s board of directors, has recently expressed the same views on an earnings presentation call, where he added that the IPO would pay off their investment.

 

Read this next

Industry News

Finalto shakes up Non-Deliverable Forward trading with game-changing offer 

Finalto takes the complexity out of Non-Deliverable Forwards with a revolutionary NDF offer that does away with the product’s associated issues, providing a streamlined forex solution that can slot smoothly into any existing infrastructure.

Digital Assets

Is Ripple looking to build a market-making platform for XRP?

Ripple, the global payments platform that owns the digital asset XRP, is reportedly looking to launch a market-making platform for XRP through a spokesperson of the company who has denied any such plans for now.

Industry News

Capital.com integrates with Paypal for deposits and withdrawals

Capital.com, one of the fastest-growing trading and investing platforms in Europe, has announced that it has integrated with Paypal which means that its users would be able to make deposits and withdrawals via Paypal.

Digital Assets

Solana publishes review on its network outage, thanks community

On September 14, the Solana network went down due to a sudden increase in the network load to over 400,000 transactions per second and this was fixed after around 17 hours of downtime and due to the efforts of all the validators within the network.

Industry News

Robinhood working on crypto wallet and transfer features

Robinhood, the trading platform that is loved by the latest generation of traders and investors, has been trying out the use of crypto wallets and also transfers through them.

Retail FX

Canada’s chief watchdog hits Celox.live with a regulatory warning

Canada’s mega regulator, the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization (IIROC), today warned Canadian investors not to be fooled by Celox.live.

Retail FX

CySEC Delists OptionRally and Four Brokers from Investor Compensation Fund

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) today published a new list of financial services providers that were disbarred from its lifeboat scheme.

Retail FX

Advanced Markets UK Reports Stronger Revenue and Mitigated Loss ‎for 2020‎

Advanced Markets (UK) Limited, the UK trading arm of a multi-asset liquidity and prime-of-prime service provider, has released its annual report and year-end financial statements for the 12-month period ending December 31, 2020. The latest results on UK Companies House showed a healthy uptick in turnover in conjunction with a mitigated financial loss for the reported fiscal period.

Industry News

HYCM to Conclude Participation in Dubai Forex Expo with ‘Year-End Trading’ Seminar

As the year draws to a close, there might be a slew of tasks on your to-do list. Following the success of previous events, multi-regulated FX brokerage firm HYCM is hosting an intensive trading seminar titled ‘Trading into Year-End: All You Need to Know.’ 

<