SEC and CFTC dispute crypto oversight: Which will rule over Ripple’s XRP?

Rick Steves

It seems, however, that the CFTC is now pushing back as some US lawmakers and government officials hint that the SEC could get to rule over the asset class.

For years the digital asset ecosystem has complained about the lack of clarity in regard to the regulatory framework for the industry and the United States Congress is finally introducing bill proposals that could clear the path for the technology and asset class.

In late July, a piece of legislation has been announced by Representative Don Beyer (D-VA). The bill has already been reviewed by attorney Thien-Vu Hogan, who concluded that XRP would not be subject to the SEC supervision if the legislation were to pass.

Instead, XRP would be regarded as a Digital Asset (not a Digital Asset Security), which would fall under the scope of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, according to Ms. Hogan.

The proposed legislation was announced the same day SEC Chair Gary Gensler replied to Senator Elizabeth Warren’s letter requesting information about the regulator’s “authority to properly regulate cryptocurrency exchanges and to determine if Congress needs to act to ensure that the SEC has the proper authority to close existing gaps in regulation”.

At the time, attorney James K. Filan said the move was an orchestrated powerplay to outflank the CFTC for control of the crypto space.

Earlier this week, SEC Chair Gensler gave a speech on the role of the agency towards crypto. Noting that “my views are my own, and I’m not speaking on behalf of the SEC staff”, the top official said “there’s actually a lot of clarity” as to many of these tokens being offered and sold as securities.

He then quoted former SEC Chairman Jay Clayton in 2018: “To the extent that digital assets like [initial coin offerings, or ICOs] are securities — and I believe every ICO I have seen is a security — we have jurisdiction, and our federal securities laws apply.”

“You see, generally, folks buying these tokens are anticipating profits, and there’s a small group of entrepreneurs and technologists standing up and nurturing the projects. I believe we have a crypto market now where many tokens may be unregistered securities, without required disclosures or market oversight”, he added.

It seems, however, that the CFTC is now pushing back as some US lawmakers and government officials hint that the SEC could get to rule over the asset class.

“Only one US regulatory agency has experience regulating markets for Bitcoin & Crypto and it is not the SEC. It is the CFTC. If the Biden Administration is serious about sensible Cryptocurrency regulation, it needs to nominate a CFTC chairman”, said Chris Giancarlo, former CFTC Chair.

CFTC Commissioner also commented on the growing influence of the SEC over the emergent asset class: “Just so we’re all clear here, the SEC has no authority over pure commodities or their trading venues, whether those commodities are wheat, gold, oil….or crypto assets”.

SEC v. Ripple: XRP is not subject to SEC under pending bill, said attorney Thien-Vu Hogan


Lack of regulatory clarity is a central issue in the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit as the Defendants claims there was no Fair Notice as to whether the sale of XRP would be considered an unregistered securities offering.

Two of the five SEC Commissioners – Hester Peirce and Elad Roisman – have come forward with a public statement admitting to the overall confusion within the cryptocurrency industry in regard to rules and regulations.

Ripple’s Fair Notice defense is believed to be a threat to the SEC’s future enforcement actions against the crypto ecosystem. The agency itself warned the Court that a Ripple win on Fair Notice would nullify the Howie Test.

“This case is about winning and making the whole crypto space succeed. If the SEC or anyone else gets hurt in the process, they brought it on themselves. But that’s not the goal”, said attorney James K. Filan.

As US lawmakers and the Biden Administration accelerate key decisions to build a solid regulatory framework for digital assets, it is possible that the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit may benefit from the upcoming clarity, which is expected to have retroactive effects.


Read this next

Inside View

Industry Leaders Share Insights on Framing Crypto Payments into FX Brokerage Business

While the allure of crypto payments is strong, caution is essential. The potential benefits in terms of speed, lower fees, and blockchain efficiency need to be weighed against the risks associated with cryptocurrency volatility. 

Institutional FX

FXSpotStream volumes hit 14-month high in November

FXSpotStream’s trading venue, the aggregator service of LiquidityMatch LLC, reported its operational metrics for November 2023, which moved higher on a monthly basis.

Digital Assets

Circle denies ties with Palestinian groups, TRON founder

Stablecoin issuer Circle has denied allegations that it facilitates funding for terrorist organizations.

Retail FX

CySEC hits operator of Titanedge, TradeEU with €90,000 fine

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) announced that it has imposed a fine of €90,000 on Titanedge Securities Ltd due to shortcomings in their regulatory obligations.

Institutional FX

Cboe FX volumes retreats slightly in November 2023

Cboe’s institutional spot FX platform today announced its trading volume for the month ending November 2023, which took a step back after a strong rebound in October.

Institutional FX

Alpha Group seals Cobase majority acquisition

Foreign exchange service provider Alpha Group International plc (AIM: ALPH) has finalized its acquisition of Financial Transaction Services, operating as Cobase.

Digital Assets

TMNG Tokens Successfully Listed on MEXC Crypto Exchange

TMN Global proudly announces the successful listing of its native TMNG token on the MEXC crypto exchange, effective December 1st, 2023. This strategic partnership marks a significant milestone for TMN Global in the crypto space.

Institutional FX

Marex completes acquisition of TD Cowen’s PB business

London-headquartered commodities broker Marex has completed the acquisition of TD Cowen’s prime brokerage and outsourced trading business, which will be integrated into Marex’s capital market division. This division was established following the acquisition of ED&F Man Capital Markets in 2022.

Digital Assets

Talos introduces decentralized liquidity and onchain settlement with Uniswap and Fireblocks

“At the cornerstone of the DeFi ecosystem, Uniswap has the breadth of assets and depth of liquidity that institutional traders need. And to have this partnership powered by Fireblocks, a digital assets infrastructure provider trusted by some of the most renowned institutions, is very fitting.”