SEC “attacks from the flank”: ‘XRP is a security for its marketing’ at the core of Ripple lawsuit

Rick Steves

SEC wants Ripple’s Slack messages badly, but the agency hasn’t produced any documents it has been compelled to deliver. Tension builds as deadline for the fact discovery period is 31 August.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has requested a pre-motion conference to compel Ripple to search and produce relevant communications between Ripple employees on Slack, which might help the agency building its case against the blockchain firm.

According to the letter sent by the plaintiff, Ripple “agreed to produce responsive Slack data but now, in the waning days of fact discovery, suddenly refuses to do so on the basis of Ripple’s mistakes in gathering that data.”

“Yet the relatively few Slack messages Ripple has produced have yielded critically important information—not contained in emails or other documents—that the SEC has repeatedly used in depositions to refresh Ripple’s employees’ dwindling recollections. The parties have met and conferred as to this issue and are at an impasse”, said Jorge Tenreiro, the lead counsel for the SEC.

“Ripple’s data error and refusal to produce most documents has already been highly prejudicial to the SEC. Among other things, the SEC has deposed 11 Ripple witnesses using incomplete records of their communications. For the reasons set forth below, Ripple should be compelled to search and produce responsive messages from 22 of its email custodians”.

It seems that months after the SEC’s refusal to hand over documents regarding the agency’s views on BTC, ETH, and XRP, despite the Judge’s insistence, Ripple has slowed its production of relevant information ahead of the fact discovery deadline, which is August 31.

John Deaton, attorney for the XRP Holders, commented on Twitter: “In the letter, the SEC admits it has deposed many Ripple employees and obtained Ripple documents. However, in the last hearing before Judge Netburn it was revealed the SEC had not turned over ANY internal documents it has been repeatedly ordered to produce.”

How clearer can it be for Ripple’s XRP? SEC tells Sen. Warren that Howie Test works for crypto

SEC’s core contention: Ripple sold XRP as securities

“The request for “Slack” messages goes to issue #1 – whether XRP is a security – and now we see a major part of the SEC’s strategy! It is attacking from the flank and arguing Ripple marketed and treated XRP like a security and therefore it is. See footnotes on pg.4″, attorney Jeremy Hogan commented.

Mr. Hogan refers to the letter’s footnotes that say “this information is critically relevant to the SEC’s core contention in this case that XRP offers and sales are offers and sales of securities”.

“The SEC has had some success with this argument in the past and it makes sense as a strategy since in all substantive ways XRP is NOT like a security. We will need to see Ripple’s response before taking a gander as to whether the court will order production of the documents”, Mr. Hogan added.

“The last day for FACT discovery (this type of discovery) is the end of August. Then the sides disclose their expert witnesses and have another month or two of discovery related to experts. Not a game-changer but eye-opening because we get to see a major strategy for the SEC.

The SEC’s strategy for the win – claiming that Ripple sold unregistered securities regardless of the real nature of XRP – comes as no surprise. SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce made that clear in June, when she explained the agency’s enforcement criteria.

“When we think about a cryptoasset as being a security what we’re doing is we’re saying it’s being sold as part of an investment contract. It doesn’t mean that the asset itself necessarily has to be a security. It means that it was being sold as a security.”


Read this next

Digital Assets

Celsius to repay +70% of custody account holders’ claims

A New York bankruptcy judge today approved a deal struck between troubled crypto lender Celsius Network and its “custody account holders” that will allow them to begin immediate withdrawals of 72.5% of their claims.

Retail FX

eToro revenue halves in 2022, valuation drops to $3.5 billion

Israeli social trading network eToro today reported financial results for the financial year ended December 31, 2022.


Investors transfers $424 million out of bitcoin funds in six weeks

Despite bitcoin’s decent surge last week, which took the primary cryptocurrency up 70% from the year’s low, digital asset investment products saw outflows for the 6th consecutive week.

Digital Assets

OKX has $9 billion in ‘clean assets’, shows latest proof of reserves

OKX, formerly known as OKEx, has released its fifth proof-of-reserves report amid increasing demand of crypto investors asking for transparency from exchanges they trade with.

Digital Assets

Circle seeks France license to launch Euro stablecoin

Circle, the issuer of the second-largest stablecoin by market capitalization, is seeking to get a dual registration in France as it aims to on-shore its flagship product for the European market – EUROC – a reserve-backed stablecoin.

Digital Assets Among Minority of Successful Companies to Renew Coveted Estonian License has successfully renewed its virtual currency service license from Estonia’s FIU for the third year in a row, despite regulatory changes that have made it harder for virtual asset providers to meet the required standards.

Inside View, Institutional FX

Time for brokers to add options trading as volumes explode on high volatility

“Usually, adding options to the typical CFDs and equities offering leads to fragmentation of the platform technology as many brokers will need additional back-end and front-end components, and that could be an important barrier for them. Apart from that, legal hassle and costs associated with proper licensing of market data could be a barrier at first. We are seeing this trend among market data vendors and exchanges to make it easier and more affordable.”

Metaverse Gaming NFT

GCEX’s DeFi education and prime brokerage offering available in DubaiVerse

“We are excited to be part of the developments of The Sandbox and to join other top players in the region, including our regulator, Dubai’s Virtual Asset Regulatory Authority (VARA), as part of the DubaiVerse. This is a great opportunity to bridge the gap between Web3 early adopters and GCEX clients, building a community around Web3 and digital assets.”

Digital Assets

Circle wants Fed to back USDC stablecoin after “very serious stress test” with collapse of SVB

The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank allegedly proves Circle’s point that there is a need for its USDC stablecoin to be backed by the U.S. Federal Reserve with its U.S. dollars held at the Fed.