SEC raises eyebrows for “defending” ex-Chairman from Ripple

Rick Steves

The SEC’s decision to step up to protest against a subpoena on a third-party is raising eyebrows, particularly among the XRP community. John E. Deaton, lawyer for approximately 11,000 XRP holders, tweeted his outrage.

On March 31, Ripple Labs served a subpoena to “produce documents, information, or objects” on One River Asset Management, which hired ex-SEC Chairman Jay Clayton as an advisor.

Mr. Clayton was head of the Securities and Exchange Commission when the regulator filed the complaint against Ripple Labs and its co-founders for an alleged illegal securities offering, which implicitly suggests that XRP is a security and under the scope of the SEC.

Ripple’s subpoena was issued in the context of the SEC v Ripple lawsuit and the financial watchdog has decided to formally protest against it in court.

“Defendants served a third-party subpoena for documents relating to Former Chair Clayton’s compensation after his tenure at the SEC […] Ripple explained that because the targeted firm invested exclusively in Bitcoin and ether, this request was probative to the “financial motivation” of the “decision-makers” involved in the decision to bring this action.

“But this action was approved by a vote of the full Commission and it is difficult to fathom how discovery of an individual Commissioner’s finances is in any way appropriate under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, particularly when the Court has already ruled that there is no need to produce bank records of the Defendants in this case who made hundreds of millions of dollars from an illegal offering of securities.”

The SEC’s decision to step up to protest against a subpoena on a third-party is raising eyebrows, particularly among the XRP community. John E. Deaton, lawyer for approximately 11,000 XRP holders, tweeted his outrage:

“Why would the @SEC_Enforcement object or get involved in this subpoena? Clayton and his new employer are part of the private sector. @Ripple served a subpoena on them. I’m pretty sure that One River has lawyers that can move to quash the subpoena.”

“It’s about the same issue that the judge said is relevant – it’s only asking a third party to provide what’s in their possession. Maybe Clayton sent emails from a private email account. It is absolutely appropriate to ask for this and it’s consistent with the judge’s ruling”, he stated.

“So why in the world would the SEC defend against a subpoena issued on a third party? It’s their fight not the SEC’s fight. US TAXPAYERS ARE NOW DEFENDING ONE RIVER. WTH is the SEC afraid will be discovered? It’s shameful and on its face appears conspiratorial.”

In the context of the SEC’s lack of clarity, Mr. Deaton had previously said it “doesn’t take an expert to see that plenty is very wrong, very corrupt and very outrageous about the SEC’s lawsuit against Ripple”.

He has recently published an op-ed stating his belief that the regulator is misleading the court as it secretly targets all XRP holders with its SEC v Ripple lawsuit.

John E. Deaton’s published the accusatory text against the SEC as the regulator welcomes Gary Gensler as its new Chair.

Not only the regulator is being attacked for having filed the complaint the day before Chairman Jay Clayton left his position, but for accusing Ripple’s co-founders of bad faith while also being unclear about the security status of XRP, in what Brad Garlinghouse called “ironic”.

Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen, Ripple’s co-founders, have recently filed twin motions to dismiss the case against them.

CFTC eyes SEC v Ripple for regulatory clarity

A few days ago, CFTC Commissioner Stump has expressed the CFTC’s attention to the lawsuit filed by the SEC against Ripple Labs and its co-founders for having sold more than 14.6 billion XRP tokens worth $1.38 billion in an unregistered offering, according to the complaint.

“The question of whether XRP is a security will be crucial. XRP is similar to bitcoin and other digital assets but also different in key respects, which prompted the SEC’s investigation. Bitcoin was an open software project launched by a pseudonymous creator calling himself Satoshi Nakamoto. XRP was created, sold initially, and backed by the company known as Ripple.

“I am watching the outcome of this case closely because it will help to establish the scope of the SEC’s authority in the digital assets space”, Commissioner Stump said, drawing attention to SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce’s work regarding the application of the “Howey test” to digital assets, which provides the framework for determining whether certain assets are securities.

Read this next

Interviews

OSTTRA’s Joanna Davies goes beyond 30-30-30 data standard at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Joanna Davies about OSTTRA.

Interviews

CloudMargin’s Stuart Connolly on how to manage collateral amid high rates at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Stuart Connolly about CloudMargin’s SaaS platform, said to be the only cloud-native collateral and margin management system in the industry, at a time of stress due to rising interest rates.

Interviews

Baton Systems’ Alex Knight on solving post-trade with DLT at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Alex Knight about Baton Systems’ about rising settlement fails, collateral management, and the profile of DLT beyond cryptocurrencies.

Industry News

Wise claims 92% of banks hide or inflate FX fees despite Cross-Border Payments Regulation 2

“Banks continue to exploit loopholes in EU regulation to mislead their customers and overcharge them through fees hidden in inflated exchange rates.”

Industry News

Goliath Partners opens Miami headquarters to recruit C++ developers for fintech and trading

I’m extremely excited to be pursuing this venture and having the backing of such knowledgeable entrepreneurs who have seen success time and time again. We’ve already made brilliant headway working with leading investment houses and trading exchanges. It’s just the start, but we’re already making a huge difference with our work.”

Industry News

IOSCO calls for cooperation against cross-border scams, greenwashing, misconduct, and fraud

“Regulators need effective resources, practices, tools, and techniques to promote consumer protection and market integrity, which is supported through participation in critical multilateral forums such as IOSCO.”

Institutional FX

Archax rolls out tokenization engine as LawtechUK confirms legal standing of tokens

“As the UK’s first FCA regulated digital securities exchange, we are now building on this to pave the way to make traditional assets interoperate with Web 3.0.”

Technology

Broadridge migrates bond e-trading platform LTX to AWS

“LTX is committed to offering innovative e-trading technology that facilitates transparency and liquidity discovery. By migrating to AWS, LTX can leverage the scalability of the cloud to continue to deliver enhanced data and execution capabilities to our clients.”

Executive Moves

CME Group taps Tim McCourt as Head of Financial & OTC Products as Sean Tully retires

“We appreciate the leadership Sean provided over the past decade for our financial products businesses, which included the successful migration to SOFR derivatives that now serve as the leading tool for hedging short-term interest rates. We are fortunate to have Tim McCourt, who has extensive experience across financial products, to lead these important business lines that allow our clients to manage risk in key asset classes.”

<