“Show some love” - failure to manage conflicts of interest triggers fine for Chardan Capital Markets - FinanceFeeds

“Show some love” – failure to manage conflicts of interest triggers fine for Chardan Capital Markets

Maria Nikolova

An employee from the special equities group suggested the investment banking department would use research staff “as the first introduction to new companies to bait them in” and get investment banking’s “foot in the door.”

Chardan Capital Markets, LLC has agreed to pay a fine of $100,000 as a part of a settlement with the United States Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).

From March 5, 2013 through August 31, 2016 (the “Review Period”), Chardan violated certain research report disclosure requirements, and failed to establish and maintain a supervisory system and written supervisory procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with disclosure rules.

Specifically, Chardan improperly published at least 103 research reports that contained 123 disclosure deficiencies, including failing to accurately disclose investment banking relationships, in violation of F1NRA Rules 2241(c) and 2010, and NASD Rule 2711(h).

The firm’s disclosure failures were the result of Chardan’s failure to establish and maintain a supervisory system and written supervisory procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the disclosure requirements of the Research Rules. By this conduct, the Firm violated FINRA Rules 3110(a), 3110(b)(1) and 2010, and NASD Rules 2711(i), 3010(a) and 3010(b)(1).

Chardan violated Research Rules that require firms to manage conflicts of interest between research analysts and those engaged in investment banking services. These failures involved the supervision of the Special Equities Group (SEG), which was a subgroup of the firm’s investment banking department during the Review Period. Chardan’s supervisory failure created the risk that research analysts could be inappropriately influenced by the Firm’s interest in attracting and maintaining investment banking business.

During the Review Period, the firm’s investment banking department consisted of 16 employees, seven of whom were members of SEG. However, Chardan failed to enforce its policies and procedures to block direct email communications between the SEG investment banking personnel and research personnel or ensure that compliance acted as an intermediary for communications between the SEG investment banking personnel and research personnel.

There were a number of direct email communications between SEG personnel and research personnel without compliance as an intermediary or any other institutional safeguards or supervisory review. Further, some direct email communications between SEG personnel and research personnel included improper suggestions by SEG investment bankers that research personnel should help solicit investment banking clients.’ For example:

  • In an email dated February 24, 2015, sent by a SEG employee to other SEG employees and two research analysts, the SEG employee proposed establishing weekly meetings between research and investment banking, and stated that the investment banking department would use research staff “as the first introduction to new companies to bait them in” and get investment banking’s “foot in the door.”
  • An email dated November 19, 2015, sent by the head of SEG to a research analyst, asked whether the head of SEG should have the head of research “show some love” to a prospective investment banking customer.

By failing to enforce (i) policies and procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the Research Rules cited above; and (ii) information barriers or other institutional safeguards reasonably designed to ensure that research analysts are insulated from the review or potential pressure by persons engaged in investment banking services activities, Chardan violated FINRA Rule 3110(b)(1) (for conduct on and after December 1, 2014), Rules 2241(b)(1), 2241(b)(2)(G) and 2241(b)(2)(M)(i) (for conduct on and after December 24, 2015) and 2010, and NASD Rules 3010(b)(1) (for conduct before December 1, 2014) and 2711(i) (for conduct on and before September 24, 2015).

In addition to the fine, the respondent agrees to a censure.

Read this next

Industry News

Cboe boosts its incentives

A focus on market quality meant that the Cboe BZX exchange was able to capture 36% of all new ETP launches in the US in 2020

Industry News

European ETFs enjoy a trading boom

For Europe as a whole ETF turnover rose by an average of 46% in 2020 to stand at just under €683 billion, or $828 billion

Industry News

Virtu launches big data tools for the buyside

Leveraging existing data science capabilities is a clever retention tool, particularly if that data analysis can show your customers that you are doing a good job

Inside View

Beep beep. Why are FX brokers still using legacy technology? We all need to move on

FX, CFD and listed derivatives brokers need to take heed of how to engage brokers properly. We look inside the developments that are vital to the growth and future sustainability of brokers, and why legacy opinion and sitting on the fence will not work out. Here is the solution.

Industry News

OANDA adds new cross-border payment solution for companies in North America

The partnership combines OANDA’s deep-seated expertise in foreign exchange with Currencycloud’s best-of-breed payment technology and Shift Connect’s world-class customer support to offer a simple-to-use, reliable international money transfer solution for businesses, large or small.

Inside View

Inside view on endless crippling regulation in FX. Surely MiFID was enough?

It still looks as though the whole regulatory obsession with spot FX may be driven by the exchange lobby, hence if you can’t beat them join them – the only thing is of course that if most FX brokers brought their skill and tenacity to the multi asset market, they certainly would beat the exchanges hands down.

Industry News

FXOpen announces the launch of the ForexCup Trading Championship 2021

Global FX and CFD broker FXOpen has today announced they are offering traders the opportunity to compete with the best, to win 50,000 USD, with the launch of the ForexCup Trading Championship 2021.

Industry News

Citadel Securities dominates European FX, and is one of the most profitable businesses in the world

Non bank market makers are absolutely dominating the growth of FX order flow execution. Citadel Securities is now the largest internalizer in Europe by market share, a battle it is winning against Tier 1 banks alongside global leader XTX Markets. It is good to see the OTC sector holding its own.

Industry News

Playtech confirms it has been approached over the sale of Finalto

Finalto was described by the company as Playtech’s outstanding performer in H1 2020