Software developer accused of spoofing seeks to nix “ostrich” jury instruction

Maria Nikolova

Jitesh Thakkar opposes the theory that he deliberately avoided learning that London-based trader Navinder Sarao would use Edge Financial’s program to spoof.

As the start of the trial against Jitesh Thakkar, the founder and principal of Edge Financial Technologies Inc., gets closer, the legal battle concerning evidence and jury instructions intensifies. Jitesh Thakkar is charged with spoofing and conspiracy to commit spoofing for trades made by London-based trader Navinder Sarao using Thakkar’s company software.

On Sunday, March 24, 2019, the defense counsel for Thakkar filed a motion with the Illinois Northern District Court, asking the Court to reject a proposed jury instruction by the US Government.

Jitesh Thakkar moves the Court to bar the government from offering the “ostrich” jury instruction at trial.

What’s an ostrich theory? The concept comes from behavioral finance. The ostrich effect is the attempt made by investors to avoid negative financial information. The name comes from the false legend that ostriches hide their heads in the sand to avoid danger.

Thakkar’s defense is now displeased with the US Government’s efforts to present their client as someone who avoided the information that his company’s software would be used to spoof.

In the motion filed on Sunday, the defense says the government changed its entire theory of the case and notified the defense of its intent to seek this instruction on Friday at 8:05 p.m. – just six days before jury selection was set to begin.

The defense stresses that during his interviews with the FBI in 2017, Jitesh Thakkar consistently explained to the government that he did not know how Sarao would use the computer program Edge Financial created and that traders do not reveal their trading strategies to programmers because those strategies are secret. The government disregarded these statements and presented a theory of the case that Jitesh had actual knowledge that Sarao would use the computer program to spoof.

Now, days before trial, the government seeks to present an entirely different theory in this case – that Jitesh deliberately avoided learning that Sarao would use the program to spoof.

The defense argues that allowing the government to present this new ostrich theory to the jury even though the defendant does not have time to retain and prepare witnesses on the proprietary and secret nature of trading strategies would present a misleading picture to the jury and deprive Jitesh Thakkar of his right to a fair trial.

Under these circumstances, the government’s proposed ostrich instruction must be rejected, the defense says.

Read this next


Spotware Systems unveils version 4.4 of Desktop and Web terminals

Spotware Systems, a technology provider for the electronic trading industry, has launched updated versions of its cTrader Desktop and Web terminals, which add new functionality to join a roster of advanced trading capabilities.

Institutional FX

Integral reports best monthly FX volume in 6 months

Currency trading on Integral’s platforms rose in September to its highest levels since March 2022 as increased volatility across financial markets led to greater activity on institutional FX venues.

Retail FX

OctaFX pre-launches new trading platform as MT4 and MT5 remain suspended by Apple

Like many other brokers within the FX and CFD industry, OctaFX had all its eggs in one basket, MetaQuotes, only offering access to MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5. OctaTrader will provide the much needed change.


Is the Bank of England facing another storm? Op-Ed by Stuart Cole, macro economist at Equiti Capital

An analysis and opinion editorial by Stuart Cole, macro economist at Equiti Capital, 3 October 2022 on what triggered the UK gilt market sell-off and is the Bank of England facing another storm?

Industry News

Kim Kardashian fined $1 million for touting EMAX tokens on social media

“Investors are entitled to know whether the publicity of a security is unbiased, and Ms. Kardashian failed to disclose this information.”

Retail FX

INFINOX launches IX Exchange platform with +20,000 markets in UK

“The launch of IX Exchange is a statement of intent for our growth strategy and a game-changer for our clients’ trading potential.”

Retail FX

Saxo issues gloomy report for Q4 2022 and beyond

Globalisation was the biggest driver behind low inflation over the past 30 years and instrumental for emerging markets and their equity markets. Globalisation in reverse will cause turmoil for trade surplus countries, put upward pressure on inflation and threaten the USD as the reserve currency.

Executive Moves

ICE appoints Caterina Caramaschi to oversee interest rates and equity derivatives

“As the head of a product set covering some of the biggest interest rate and equity derivative benchmarks, at a time when investor’s priorities are firmly focused on interest rate changes and the outlook for global economies, Caterina’s two decades of financial market experience, and the relationships cultivated during that, will be invaluable in developing these products to the benefit of our customers.”

Retail FX

Plus500 sponsors Chicago Bulls ahead of trading platform launch in United States

Plus500 has signed a major multi-year sponsorship deal to become an official global partner of iconic NBA team Chicago Bulls.