TFS-ICAP’s former Global Head of Emerging Markets broking argues against CFTC complaint

Maria Nikolova

Jeremy Woolfenden insist the complaint against him has to be dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction.

Shortly after Jeremy Woolfenden, former Global Head of Emerging Markets broking at TFS-ICAP, made clear his intentions to move to dismiss the case against him brought by the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the defendant has submitted a Letter with the New York Southern District Court detailing his arguments on why the case against him has to be nixed for lack of personal jurisdiction.

Let’s recall that, according to the CFTC, the New York Southern District Court has personal jurisdiction over Mr Woolfenden because his actions caused the underlying misconduct at issue in this case – flying & printing trades. TFS-ICAP brokers made misrepresentations to US-based clients because they had been trained and encouraged to do so by Mr Woolfenden. Though Mr. Woolfenden lived in London, as the Global Head of Emerging Markets FX Options he directly supervised and managed these US- and London-based brokers through at least mid-August 2015. Moreover, he registered with the CFTC in the United State as an associated person of two CFTC-registered entities.

In the latest filing with the New York Southern District Court, the defense counsel for Mr Woolfenden argues it is unfair and unreasonable to force Mr. Woolfenden, who is out of work in the United Kingdom, to go through years of expensive and burdensome overseas litigation in the United States – a forum to which he has virtually no ties.

In addition, the defense notes that the review of Mr. Woolfenden’s conduct is appropriately being done by the UK Financial Conduct Authority, whose investigation remains ongoing.

The letter also explains that during a telephone conference on April 5, 2019, counsel for the CFTC focused specifically on a set of allegations in the CFTC’s Complaint against Mr. Woolfenden. These allegations, according to the defense counsel, are insufficient.

The CFTC asserts that Mr. Woolfenden was part of U.S. management because TFS- ICAP, Ltd, Mr. Woolfenden’s employer, was part of a US company, TFS-ICAP, LLC. The CFTC, the defense counsel notes, cites no case law in support of this position.

“Mr. Woolfenden is not TFS-ICAP, and his participation in managing others in the U.K. as part of TFS-ICAP does not transmogrify his work in the United Kingdom into personal jurisdiction in the United States”, the defense argues.

The CFTC relies on the fact that Mr. Woolfenden registered as an Associated Person with the CFTC. But this argument is played down by the defense. They claim the CFTC cites no case to support the proposition that CFTC registrants are automatically subject to personal jurisdiction.

Finally, the CFTC alleges that, on at least one occasion, in 2015, Woolfenden explicitly directed a TFS-ICAP broker to ‘never admit to clients that we have ever flown rates.’ That allegation, according to the defense, is conspicuously silent as to whether the alleged flying had anything to do with the United States or whether Mr. Woolfenden’s statement was directed to the United States. Moreover, even if the statement were somehow connected to the United States, a singular act such as that would not be enough – even in combination with the other generalized allegations – to warrant personal jurisdiction over Mr. Woolfenden.

The case continues at the New York Southern District Court.

Read this next

Inside View

Private Equity Renaissance

Recent years have seen a resurgence in the concept of trading physical equities, with a slew of new arrivals joining the market for what is arguably one of the oldest forms of investing. But what has been the driving force behind this change in momentum?

Digital Assets

Dubai introduces new crypto regulations with fines of up to $135,000

Against the backdrop of a crashing market and burned investors, Dubai has sealed a landmark rulebook that governs how the Emirate will regulate cryptocurrency activities.

Institutional FX

FX volume drops 16pct at Russia’s largest exchange in January

The Moscow Exchange, Russia’s largest exchange group, released its monthly batch of trading volumes and metrics for January 2023 – the latest readings showed a pullback across the board for multiple segments, namely in the FX, given lower volatility and a reduced trading schedule.

Institutional FX

Standard Chartered sets up wholly-owned brokerage arm in China

UK-headquartered bank Standard Chartered said its Hong Kong arm has been granted an in-principle approval for a brokerage license from the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC).

Digital Assets

Revolut offers staking for Ether, Cardano, Polkadot, and Tezo

British fintech and banking firm Revolut has introduced crypto staking — a practice of earning rewards for serving as a transaction validator in the Ethereum blockchain – to its UK and European Economic Area (EEA) customers.

Inside View

Saxo releases Q1 2023 Quarterly Outlook: “The Models Are Broken”

“2023 is likely to prove a rough ride for currencies if the USD bear market fails to continue in a straight line, but EUR and JPY may outperform.”

Institutional FX

FXPA welcomes Mesirow as a member of the institutional FX industry body

“Our deep commitment to advancing best practices align well with FXPA’s goals of championing a robust FX market for all industry participants.”

Industry News

ICE delivers Russian-free barrels of ICE Gasoil and expands ESG data in APAC

ICE changed the methodology for Low Sulphur Gasoil futures from previously delivering diesel from any origin, to deliver diesel that does not include any originating from Russia. ICE Gasoil is the global benchmark for refined oil products.

Digital Assets

Gate.io taps Coinfirm for AML/CFT compliance amid licenses in the US, Europe, Hong Kong

“At Gate.io, we continuously strive to mitigate AML/CFT and counterparty risks by integrating best-in-class security measures and safeguards into every part of our operations.”

<