UBS tries to escape US jurisdiction in Sterling LIBOR manipulation case

Maria Nikolova

The bank tries to prove that the plaintiffs’ attempt to stretch the New York Court’s jurisdictional holding are meritless.

UBS AG continues its fight in a Libor manipulation lawsuit filed at the New York Southern District Court. Less than a month after the plaintiffs in the case tried to convince the Court that it should not reconsider its earlier ruling against the bank, UBS responded to the plaintiffs’ claims.

In its latest Court filings, UBS seeks to offer arguments why the Court has to reconsider its earlier ruling and that the New York Southern District Court has no jurisdiction over the bank in this case.

UBS notes that the plaintiff’s attempt to establish jurisdiction over UBS is, “at bottom, an effort to muddy the waters of UBS’s regulatory settlements”. In particular, the defendant and the plaintiff clash over a part from a CFTC Order concerning the actions of a senior Group Treasury manager in Stamford, Connecticut. Here is the text:

“On April 22, 2008, a senior Group Treasury manager (“Group Treasury Senior Manager”) in Stamford, Connecticut, determined that UBS’s LIBOR submissions were “lagging the panel and peer banks” and therefore decided to adjust UBS’s submissions upward towards its CP/CD issuance levels. The Group Treasury Senior Manager apparently believed, incorrectly, that LIBOR served as an “advertisement” of the rate that UBS would pay for funds, and not the rate at which UBS could borrow funds in the London interbank market. As a result, he was purportedly concerned that UBS’s LIBOR submissions were not competitive and should more closely reflect the bank’s issuance rates for CP/CDs to attract potential clients”.

UBS argues that CFTC Order does not definitively prove that the Stamford manager directed the manipulation of Sterling LIBOR specifically. As UBS has pointed out, the Stamford-related conduct cited in the relevant section of the CFTC Order related to U.S. Dollar LIBOR, not Sterling.

Moreover, according to UBS, even if the Stamford conduct had been referring to Sterling LIBOR, it would still fail to help the plaintiff because it has nothing to do with a conspiracy. The supposed actions in Stamford called out by the plaintiff all concerned UBS’s unilateral conduct. For example, the sections of the CFTC Order at issue refer to UBS’s purported unilateral motivation to lower LIBOR submissions to “protect UBS’s reputation and to avoid what it perceived as unfair and inaccurate negative media speculation about UBS’s fundraising ability and creditworthiness.” This internal reputational motive, UBS stresses, is unrelated to the alleged profit-based conspiracy that is the basis of the instant case.

Finally, UBS notes that, as the Court acknowledged, the fact that UBS has a United States presence is insufficient to confer jurisdiction, unless plaintiffs can make out a prima facie case that the existence, causation or intent to manipulate Sterling LIBOR on the part of UBS had its ‘nucleus’ or ‘focal point’ in the United States. None of UBS’s supposed points of “presence” in the United States are related to the alleged conspiracy and are thus irrelevant, the defendant bank says.

Let’s recall that, in February 2016, the plaintiffs – FrontPoint, Sonterra Capital Master Fund, Ltd., and Richard Dennis filed their Consolidated Amended Complaint against a number of defendant banks, including UBS AG. The plaintiffs claimed that the defendant banks manipulated Sterling LIBOR in violation of the Sherman Act, CEA, and RICO Act, and asserted state law claims for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing and for unjust enrichment.

According to the plaintiffs, the defendants sought “to generate illicit profits for themselves and their co-conspirators on their Sterling LIBOR-based derivatives positions.”

On April 11, 2016, the defendants moved to dismiss all claims against them for lack of personal jurisdiction, lack of subject matter jurisdiction, and failure to state a claim, which the plaintiffs subsequently opposed. On December 21, 2018, the Court dismissed all claims from the suit except for two: FrontPoint’s claims against UBS for violation of the Sherman Act and for unjust enrichment.

Read this next

Opinion

Is the Bank of England facing another storm? Op-Ed by Stuart Cole, macro economist at Equiti Capital

An analysis and opinion editorial by Stuart Cole, macro economist at Equiti Capital, 3 October 2022 on what triggered the UK gilt market sell-off and is the Bank of England facing another storm?

Industry News

Kim Kardashian fined $1 million for touting EMAX tokens on social media

“Investors are entitled to know whether the publicity of a security is unbiased, and Ms. Kardashian failed to disclose this information.”

Retail FX

INFINOX launches IX Exchange platform with +20,000 markets in UK

“The launch of IX Exchange is a statement of intent for our growth strategy and a game-changer for our clients’ trading potential.”

Retail FX

Saxo issues gloomy report for Q4 2022 and beyond

Globalisation was the biggest driver behind low inflation over the past 30 years and instrumental for emerging markets and their equity markets. Globalisation in reverse will cause turmoil for trade surplus countries, put upward pressure on inflation and threaten the USD as the reserve currency.

Executive Moves

ICE appoints Caterina Caramaschi to oversee interest rates and equity derivatives

“As the head of a product set covering some of the biggest interest rate and equity derivative benchmarks, at a time when investor’s priorities are firmly focused on interest rate changes and the outlook for global economies, Caterina’s two decades of financial market experience, and the relationships cultivated during that, will be invaluable in developing these products to the benefit of our customers.”

Retail FX

Plus500 sponsors Chicago Bulls ahead of trading platform launch in United States

Plus500 has signed a major multi-year sponsorship deal to become an official global partner of iconic NBA team Chicago Bulls. 

Technology

Polygon.io adds stock options APIs to market data platform that includes FX and Crypto

Polygon.io has launched a new set of stock options APIs to its entirely self-serve real-time data APIs, which includes stocks, crypto, forex, and options APIs free to use.

Market News

What’s in store for markets this week!

After The UK government unveiled their top tax rate cut, setting fire to GBP Cross pairs, prompting an intensive sell-off on the cable

Podcasts

FinanceFeeds Podcast Ep. #7: Exness’s Elena Krutova shares how to recruit the best talent in FX

FinanceFeeds is delighted to announce the release of the FinanceFeeds Podcast’s seventh episode featuring Elena Krutova, Chief People Officer of Exness, the renowned FX and CFD broker headquartered in Cyprus.

<