US Govt not willing to go on “international fishing expedition” for evidence in spoofing case

Maria Nikolova

The US Government opposes a request from a software developer accused of spoofing who wants access to documents possessed by the UK FCA and Police.

The United States Government has objected to a request by Jitesh Thakkar, a software developer accused of spoofing, over document production. Earlier this week, the US authorities filed their official response to Thakkar’s request.

Let’s recall that Thakkar has asked the Court to compel the Government to produce documents from the CFTC, U.K. Financial Conduct Authority, Metropolitan Police Service, and other British authorities. Thakkar, who is charged with spoofing and conspiracy to commit spoofing for trades made by London-based trader Navinder Sarao using the company’s software, says that, in order to investigate Jitesh Thakkar and Sarao, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and FBI partnered with the CFTC in the United States and with UK regulators. Because those entities were part of the investigative team in this case, the defense counsel insists that the US government is obligated to produce Brady, Giglio, and Jencks Act materials in the possession of those entities.

In its response, the US Government says it is not aware of any Brady or Giglio material in the possession of these independent agencies and thus is not seeking to avoid discovering or producing unfavorable facts. The government consulted with the CFTC and is not aware of any contemporaneous notes of the witness interviews identified in the Motion to Compel that the CFTC attended with the government. Should the government become aware of any such notes or other discoverable materials in the possession of the CFTC relating to these interviews, it will request them from the CFTC and review them for any discoverable material that has not already been summarized in the interview reports previously provided to the defendant.

To the extent the Motion is requesting more than the government’s good-faith undertaking with respect to the interviews attended by the CFTC, such requests, the Government says, lack basis in fact or law, and would amount to an interagency and international fishing expedition that could chill proper cooperation among independent agencies.

Any additional discovery the defendant seeks from these agencies – to the extent such materials even exist – would not be subject to the government’s discovery obligations. The Government notes that the CFTC is an independent agency that has conducted its own parallel civil investigation into Sarao and the defendant and that is not, and never has been, part of the government’s “prosecution team.” Also, the UK Financial Conduct Authority, Metropolitan Police Service, and other British authorities cited in Thakkar’s Motion are independent agencies of a foreign sovereign that, to the government’s knowledge, have not conducted any parallel investigation of these matters and have not carried out any “joint” investigation with the US government. The UK entities likewise are not, and never have been, part of the prosecution team.

Accordingly, the US Government insists defendant’s Motion should be denied.

On February 14, 2018, Jitesh Thakkar was charged in an indictment filed in the Northern District of Illinois with one count of conspiracy to commit spoofing and two counts of spoofing. Thakkar appeared for his arraignment on the indictment on February 22, 2018.

The indictment alleges that between October 2011 and April 2015, Thakkar and his co-conspirators engaged in a conspiracy to engage in spoofing—that is, bidding and offering with the intent, at the time the bid or offer was entered, to cancel the bid or offer before execution—through the placement of thousands of orders on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME). The indictment alleges that Thakkar and his co-conspirators developed and delivered a customized software program that was used by Thakkar’s co-conspirator to engage in spoofing, including in the market for E-Mini S&P 500 futures contracts (“E-Mini”) on the CME. The indictment further charges Thakkar with spoofing in the E-Mini market on or about February 25, 2013 and March 8, 2013.

According to the allegations, it was the purpose of the conspiracy for Thakkar and his co- conspirators to unlawfully enrich themselves by:

  • developing a customized, automated program designed to place certain orders into the market while mitigating the risk that these orders would be “hit,” or executed;
  • selling, delivering, and attempting to sell and deliver the customized automated program to traders, so that the traders can use the program to place orders into futures markets, including the market for E-Mini futures contracts, that they intended to cancel before execution.

Read this next

Inside View

Crypto Liquidity Providers: No Transaction, No Party!

One of the most integral parts of trading cryptocurrencies is ensuring seamless transactions; however, this is not always easy when you first start using cryptocurrency exchanges.

Digital Assets

Niftables launches white label NFT platform for content creators and brands

Niftables is the go-to platform for brands and creators looking to realize their NFT vision — whether they’re an individual or the biggest entertainment company in the world.

Retail FX

ACY Securities sponsors Table Tennis NSW as CFD broker bets in Australia’s youngest

ACY Securities has partnered with Table Tennis New South Wales (TTNSW) for a two-year sponsorship agreement intended to highlight the Chatswood-based multi-asset CFD broker’s brand in Australia, with a focus on the southeastern state.

Executive Moves

Peter Hetherington appointed CEO of Capital.com, Currency.com, and Shares.com

With his extensive experience driving strategy and growth for leading wealth and brokerage firms in highly regulated markets, Peter is the ideal CEO to lead the Group on its next chapter of growth and success.”

Digital Assets

Crypto platform Elwood raises $70m from Goldman Sachs, Dawn, Barclays, BlockFi, Flow, Galaxy, more

Elwood Technologies has closed a $70 million Series A funding round co-led by Europe’s largest B2B investor Dawn Capital and global investment bank, Goldman Sachs.

Industry News

Wilshire to launch Climate Change 1.5℃ Target Index with Nikkei and Hang Seng

Wilshire has announced a collective launch with Nikkei and Hang Seng to bring to market the first in a series of indexes empowering investors to transition their investments towards a low-carbon and climate resilient economy.

Industry News

Anne Boden’s Starling Bank bets big on UEFA Women’s EURO 2022 tournament

Starling Bank has launched a campaign ahead of the UEFA Women’s EURO 2022 tournament as part of its national sponsorship, the biggest ever for the bank.

Industry News

Older adults flock to financial apps as Revolut reports 215% more UK users aged 55-74 since pandemic

Data has also shown that older adults are back to travelling as the 55-64 UK age group has seen a tenfold increase in the amount spent in foreign countries over the past two years, and the 64-75 age group isn’t far behind with an 840% increase.

Industry News

Ripple replies to SEC’s last attempt and “shoves it down their throats pretty hard”

“The SEC really messed that up. How can Hinman receive legal advice from SEC lawyers for a personal opinion?”, attorney Hogan commented.

<