Wells Fargo objects to NY Court order for deposition of its former Head of FX Trading

Maria Nikolova

Wells Fargo insists that the subpoena for Simon Fowles implicates materials belonging to the bank that are sensitive or confidential.

Wells Fargo appears to be displeased with an Order issued by the New York Southern District Court last week regarding its former Head of FX Trading Simon Fowles being deposed in a Forex benchmark rate fixing case.

In the face of Mr Fowles’ objections, the Court ruled that the deposition must take place on November 28, 2018. The Court, however, allowed the filing of additional objections. Wells Fargo filed a Letter of objection on Friday, November 23, 3018.

The bank argues, inter alia, that the subpoena for Mr Fowles, seeks information that is irrelevant to the subject matter of the case, is not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant evidence, and will impose a burden on Wells Fargo (and Mr. Fowles) that is not substantially proportional to any potential benefit to this litigation. Let’s recall that the plaintiffs launched this putative class action under the Sherman Antitrust Act, alleging that they paid inflated foreign currency exchange rates caused by an alleged conspiracy among JP Morgan, Bank of America, HSBC, Citibank, UBS AG, Barclays PLC, and Royal Bank of Scotland PLC to fix prices in Forex market.

According to the plaintiffs, “Wells Fargo Bank per Thomas Kiefer was an active participant in the FX chat rooms in this case”. And since Simon Fowles was the Head of FX Trading at Wells Fargo Bank, he has to give testimony.

Wells Fargo notes that it is a not a defendant in this case. The bank stresses that it has not been implicated in any of the regulatory or enforcement actions related to the plaintiffs’ claims. According to Wells Fargo, Mr Fowles’s testimony has potential relevance only insofar as it might shed light on the conduct of foreign exchange traders at financial institutions other than Wells Fargo, i.e., the defendant banks in this action. Plaintiffs cannot show that Mr. Fowles even potentially has knowledge relevant to those issues, the bank insists.

Furthermore, according to Wells Fargo, the subpoena potentially implicates information or materials belonging to Wells Fargo that are sensitive or confidential.

The case is captioned Nypl v. JP Morgan Chase & Co. et al (1:15-cv-09300).

Read this next


The FX Algo Wheel, is it wheels up and ready to take flight?

by David Catterick, Sales Director, BidFX Australia

Retail FX

eToro users now can trade underlying Italian stocks

Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company eToro has expanded its service offering and trading products by incorporating new markets, namely Italian stocks listed at underlying exchanges.

Digital Assets

BlackRock bets on crypto bank Silvergate despite drastic fall

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, has increased its stake in Silvergate Bank, a crypto-friendly lender that counts major crypto exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken as clients.


A viewpoint from Anatoly Crachilov, CEO and Founding Partner at Nickel Digital, on SEC regulation of the digital asset sector

The SEC’s latest episode comes across as more of a PR performance rather than an act of investor protection.

Digital Assets

Tether denies receiving any loans from Celsius, the opposite is true

World’s largest stablecoin issuer, Tether dismissed reports suggesting that it received a $2 billion loan from the bankrupt cryptocurrency lender Celsius.

Institutional FX

Cboe FX volume makes strong rebound in January

Cboe’s institutional spot FX platform today announced its trading volume for the month ending January 2023, which marks a mild rebound after a steep fall in December.


XS.com appoints Exness alumni Mohamad Ibrahim as CEO

XS.com, the multi-regulated financial services provider, has appointed Mohamad Ibrahim as the group’s newest chief executive officer (CEO).


B2Broker Integrates Match-Trader Solution to Expands Its White Label Liquidity Offering

A global provider of technology and liquidity for the FX and cryptocurrency markets, B2Broker recently announced the extension of its white label liquidity offering by merging with Match-Trader.

Digital Assets

UK launches open consultation to regulate crypto exchanges, custody, and lending

The government’s proposed measures have been informed by recent market events – including the failure of FTX – which reinforce the case for effective regulation and sector engagement.