What is XRP: A key question in SEC v. Ripple and the answer can’t be that simple

Rick Steves

“So whether the SEC would care to admit it or not, the Howey orange grove analysis does not apply as neatly to the facts and circumstances surrounding XRP and its offering”.

Denise Fesdjian, an associate at Ulmer & Berne, has analyzed how the SEC defines digital assets as securities in a document titled “Comparing Apples to Orange [Groves]”.

Ms. Fesdjian, an attorney representing broker-dealers, investment advisors, and registered persons operating in the financial services industry, started by reminding the term “investment contract” has been liberally construed by courts to apply to a wide range of money-raising schemes that were found to be securities.

The landmark case of SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. – a hotel operator which sold interests in orange groves as an investment scheme – established the “Howey test” for an investment contract.

The Supreme Court held that the circumstances surrounding the sale of the orange grove interests constituted an investment contract and therefore a security.

Denise Fesdjian clarified the Court’s finding: “It’s important to point out the following distinction: the underlying asset (the orange grove) itself was not held to be a security, but rather it was the way in which the tracts of orange groves were sold that rendered them an investment contract.

“Naturally, you may be wondering, what exactly do orange groves have to do with digital assets? As it turns out, the SEC believes they have a lot more in common than you would think”, she continued, adding that U.S. laws and regulations have been stagnant and haven’t kept up with the crypto craze.

Meet FinanceFeeds at the IFX EXPO International in Cyprus

Without new legislation to rely on, the SEC has determined that a digital asset (such as a cryptocurrency) may be considered an investment contract and therefore a security under the Howey framework.

SEC commissioner Hester Pierce, who has recently denounced the lack of clarity within the crypto space, has also said in an interview that “when we think about a cryptoasset as being a security what we’re doing is we’re saying it’s being sold as part of an investment contract. It doesn’t mean that the asset itself necessarily has to be a security. It means that it was being sold as a security.”

The Ulmer & Berne associate also referred to SEC Chair Gary Gensler’s remark that cryptocurrencies are like the “Wild West” as he requested more Congressional rulemaking on digital asset regulation – his comment were a surprise given his former insistence that there was regulatory clarity in the space, prompting Ripple CEO Garlinghouse to compare him to an alcoholic in denial.

Mr. Gensler did, however, say there is no issue on how cryptocurrencies are currently treated under the securities laws, concluding that “certain rules related to crypto assets are well settled” and “the test to determine whether a crypto asset is a security is clear.”

In regard to the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit, aka the “cryptocurrency trial of the century,” Mr. Fesdjian clarified that in order to preserve the sanctity of the Howey test and its application to digital asset cases, the SEC did not allege that XRP (as in the digital token) was itself a security, but, rather, it was the circumstances surrounding XRP’s offering that made it one.

The SEC also added that XRP is not a currency. So what is XRP?, Ms. Fesdjian asked, as she disagreed with the agency’s answer that XRP is “software code”.

“The essence of a digital token cannot be diluted to have such a rudimentary meaning. Applying this type of logic to the Howey case would be the equivalent of reducing the orange grove’s meaning to an orange seed. The XRP digital token represents something beyond software code; it represents a virtual currency. So whether the SEC would care to admit it or not, the Howey orange grove analysis does not apply as neatly to the facts and circumstances surrounding XRP and its offering”.

“While new legislation such as the Securities Clarity Act is promising, as its name aptly suggests, more clarity in this area, in the meantime, the SEC will continue regulating the nascent cryptocurrency industry under 75-year old jurisprudence.

“It is my hope that we will soon see formal cryptocurrency regulations in place so that the SEC can start reviewing digital asset cases using an apples-to-apples analysis rather than settling on comparing them to orange groves”, she concluded.

In the meantime, Ripple has just gained a heavy weight backer as the SEC v. Ripple could determine the future of the digital asset space. Former U.S. Treasurer Rosie Rios has come forth in defense of Ripple’s XRP currency value and utility via a simple tweet.

A recent Ripple filing to the court suggests that the SEC tried to hide from Ripple a document concerning discussions with a mistery third party.

“The descriptions of three of these documents from the belatedly produced privilege log suggest they may be highly relevant to this case”, said counsel Matthew Solomon. If approved, the Judge will add these documents to her in-camera review and could find them relevant to the case, particularly for Ripple’s fair notice defense.

For more Ripple (XRP) related articles, click here.

Read this next


US and South Korea seek extradition of Luna founder Do Kwon

Both US and South Korean officials are seeking to extradite Terraform Labs CEO Do Kwon, just hours after he was arrested in Montenegro.

Retail FX

Pepperstone UK doubles profit, client assets in 2022

The London-based entity of Australian FX broker Pepperstone has reported its financials for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2022. The group had outperformed the last year’s flat performance, having doubled revenues and boosted the broker’s bottom line and shareholders’ fortunes.

Institutional FX

CLS FX volume rises to just shy of $2 trillion in February

Foreign exchange settlement provider, CLS Group saw strong volumes in February 2023 as the banking crisis continues to weigh on a world economy that’s yet to fully recover from the Russia-Ukraine war’s shocks.

Digital Assets

Binance restores trading after 2-hour outage

Binance suffered a breakdown on its trading engine that lasted for about two hours, but the premier cryptocurrency exchange finally managed to restore normal operations at around 14:00 UTC.

Digital Assets

Tether earns $700 million in Q1, taking excess reserves to $1.6 billion

Tether chief technology officer Paolo Ardoino said the world’s largest stablecoin issuer expects to earn more than $700 million in the January-Mach quarter, which will be added to the reserve backing its stablecoin (USDT).

Digital Assets

Narwhal Finance Secures $1M in Seed Funding Led by Animoca Ventures

Narwhal Finance received strong support from Animoca Ventures and angel investors in a $1 million seed funding round, reinforcing the company’s vision of providing an accessible platform to all.


SteelEye tries ChatGPT for market surveillance

This capability can be used as a starting point for initiating a surveillance investigation and to standardize workflow processes to boost the throughput and consistency of cases. It is also useful when analyzing communications in foreign languages, as the system returns the above insights in English regardless of the languages being used.

Industry News

SEC charges ex-Morgan Stanley advisor of NBA players after $13m fraud

Darryl Matthew Cohen was arrested this week and is facing three different federal counts of fraud, which could amount to 20 years in prison if convicted, besides the SEC complaint. 

Industry News

AWS FinTech Africa Accelerator launched, applications until April 27, 2023

Founders will be offered tech resources, expert guidance, and a global network of industry leaders, technologists, entrepreneurs, investors, associations, and partners, in order to build their fintech products.