XRP lawsuit: Judge seals evidence that could prove SEC lied to court

Rick Steves

Judge Netburn has granted the motion on an interim basis as the Court may reconsider its ruling when it considers the merits of the underlying motion.

Judge Sarah Netburn has ruled in favor of Ripple’s request to seal exhibits A and B contained in the defendants’ response to the SEC’s submission of three additional documents for the in-camera review.

At the time of Ripple’s motion to seal, the defendants said they “conferred with the SEC and understand that it does not object to filing these materials under seal, pending the SEC’s opportunity to review the submitted materials and evaluate whether to ultimately request sealing.

Ripple and the individual defendants Chris Larsen and Brad Garlinghouse have not taken a position on the ultimate confidentiality of these materials.

These, however, are part of the “discovery materials filed with the court in connection with discovery-related disputes,” that were designated as Confidential by the producing party. As such, they are not judicial documents and are not entitled to a presumption of public access, Ripple’s counsel argued.

Exhibits A and B are part of the discovery materials exchanged between the parties through a compulsory process to facilitate orderly preparation for trial, not to educate or titillate the public.

Judge Netburn has granted the motion on an interim basis as the Court may reconsider its ruling when it considers the merits of the underlying motion.

The three additional documents for review

The SEC was ordered to deliver the three documents after Ripple’s successful motion to compel.  The documents include:

  • the January 28, 2019 email chain: SEC forum on digital assets
  • the October 25, 2018 email chain: meeting between SEC staff and industry participants on digital assets
  • September 9, 2019 email chain on a distributed ledger technology firm’s request for possible no action relief

The SEC claims these documents are privileged under the deliberative privilege process (DPP), including the one where the SEC told a third party to analyze its digital asset under the framework of Hinman’s speech.

That document is likely to put further pressure on the SEC’s position that Hinman’s speech was not official SEC policy, but only his personal opinions.

More on that: Ripple could prove SEC lied to court about Hinman’s ‘personal opinions’

Besides the SEC’s misstep in court, Ripple can use these documents to further pursue its fair notice defense, given the agency’s seemingly contradictory positions in regard to the regulatory guidance and enforcement.


Read this next

Industry News

Exness Crowned as Best Global Multi-asset Broker at Forex Expo Dubai 2023

Cyprus-based Exness garners top honors at the Forex Expo Dubai, solidifying its esteemed position in the global financial arena.

Retail FX

Scope Markets doubles down on Middle East: AED accounts ahead of GCC Equity CFDs

“To bolster our footprint in this thriving ecosystem, it was a strategic imperative to integrate AED accounts and introduce a slew of CFD equities reflecting the GCC landscape. This not only appeases the domestic audience but also beckons international investors aspiring to delve into these dynamic markets.”

Market News

Navigating the Complex World of Central Banks: Inflation, Rates, and Economic Growth

Inflation continues to loom large over both European households and businesses, leaving central banks in the region grappling with a prolonged battle to reach their target levels.

Institutional FX

QUODD partners with Blue Ocean for real-time after-hours market data

“Investors are increasingly global, and market data providers like QUODD are facilitating access to data that enables global traders to invest in US markets. Partnering with top-tier fintech providers like QUODD allows Blue Ocean to extend its reach to a new demographic of investors.”

Retail FX

Moomoo Canada launches pro-level tools, free Level 2 data, and affordable US stock trading

“Being a real social trading platform in Canada, we cultivate a unique ecosystem helping our users grow… The world is eager to hear the voice of Canadian individual investors, and we look forward to more contributions from Canadian investors in our moo community.”

Industry News

CFTC sues Patrick Wonsey for $3.4 million FX and binary options scam

Wonsey allegedly diverted these monies for personal use and orchestrated payouts to other pool participants, mirroring a classic Ponzi scheme.

Digital Assets

MoneyGram to launch non-custodial digital wallet

“In collaboration with SDF, MoneyGram has been working towards creating equitable access to the global financial system. With the introduction of this non-custodial digital wallet, we are further emphasizing our commitment to providing consumers with a bridge to the digital economy while upholding our brand’s integrity for speed, efficiency, and trust.”

Digital Assets

Binance exits Russia as part of crypto exchange’s compliance strategy

“As we look toward the future, we recognize that operating in Russia is not compatible with Binance’s compliance strategy. We remain confident in the long-term growth of the web3 industry around the world and will focus our energy on the 100+ other countries in which we operate.”


ECNG Digital taps iDenfy for AI-driven ID verification for user onboarding

“In the realm of virtual currency exchange and payment services, the real challenge lies in balancing fraud prevention with swift identity verification. Our mission is to guide ECNG Digital on this path, ensuring precision while accelerating understanding.”