XRP lawsuit: Judge seals evidence that could prove SEC lied to court

Rick Steves

Judge Netburn has granted the motion on an interim basis as the Court may reconsider its ruling when it considers the merits of the underlying motion.

Judge Sarah Netburn has ruled in favor of Ripple’s request to seal exhibits A and B contained in the defendants’ response to the SEC’s submission of three additional documents for the in-camera review.

At the time of Ripple’s motion to seal, the defendants said they “conferred with the SEC and understand that it does not object to filing these materials under seal, pending the SEC’s opportunity to review the submitted materials and evaluate whether to ultimately request sealing.

Ripple and the individual defendants Chris Larsen and Brad Garlinghouse have not taken a position on the ultimate confidentiality of these materials.

These, however, are part of the “discovery materials filed with the court in connection with discovery-related disputes,” that were designated as Confidential by the producing party. As such, they are not judicial documents and are not entitled to a presumption of public access, Ripple’s counsel argued.

Exhibits A and B are part of the discovery materials exchanged between the parties through a compulsory process to facilitate orderly preparation for trial, not to educate or titillate the public.

Judge Netburn has granted the motion on an interim basis as the Court may reconsider its ruling when it considers the merits of the underlying motion.

The three additional documents for review

The SEC was ordered to deliver the three documents after Ripple’s successful motion to compel.  The documents include:

  • the January 28, 2019 email chain: SEC forum on digital assets
  • the October 25, 2018 email chain: meeting between SEC staff and industry participants on digital assets
  • September 9, 2019 email chain on a distributed ledger technology firm’s request for possible no action relief

The SEC claims these documents are privileged under the deliberative privilege process (DPP), including the one where the SEC told a third party to analyze its digital asset under the framework of Hinman’s speech.

That document is likely to put further pressure on the SEC’s position that Hinman’s speech was not official SEC policy, but only his personal opinions.

More on that: Ripple could prove SEC lied to court about Hinman’s ‘personal opinions’

Besides the SEC’s misstep in court, Ripple can use these documents to further pursue its fair notice defense, given the agency’s seemingly contradictory positions in regard to the regulatory guidance and enforcement.


Read this next

Digital Assets

Russia could use cryptocurrency in international payments as sanctions intensify

Faced with stiffening sanctions over its invasion of Ukraine, Russia is reportedly mulling the idea of accepting Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies as payment for its international trade. Interfax news agency first reported the news on Friday, citing a high-ranking government official.

Digital Assets

Huobi buys crypto exchange Bitex to expand in Latin America

Huobi, the world’s sixth-largest crypto exchange by trading volume, has bolstered its commitment to Latin America with the acquisition of Bitex.

Digital Assets

US Senate to ban Google, Apple app stores from hosting China’s e-CNY

The US Senate could pass new legislation to ban hosting China’s e-CNY – also known as the digital yuan – by US app stores like Apple store, Google Play, and other providers.

Institutional FX

Takeprofit Tech adds Gate.io, GCEX and others to Liquidity Hub

Fintech software developer Takeprofit Tech has onboarded Gate.io, MFP Trading, Velocity Trade and GCEX to its liquidity hub solution network.

Digital Assets

Bosonic launches clearing and settlement solution for digital assets

Bosonic launched a clearing and settlement capability which provides a turnkey digital asset infrastructure platform that can be used by market operators to run their own trading venue or digital asset post-trade service.

Metaverse Gaming NFT

Immersive technologies: How VR technologies can boost our well-being

Neuro-biologists have already proven that the human brain can’t tell the initial difference between reality and deep fantasies. It works for both dreams and daydreaming. In other words, if our brain perceives something as real, we react to it as if it was true. That is why emotions we get in the skillfully-built immersive reality can be a substitute to those we get in real life. 

Digital Assets

LevelField taps METACO’s digital asset custody platform ahead of US bank charter

LevelField is comprised of career bankers who deeply understand the importance of compliance and security.

Digital Assets

JPMorgan Chase invests in crypto forensics startup Elliptic

Multinational investment bank JPMorgan Chase & Co has joined the Series C funding round for Blockchain forensics startup Elliptic, the latest sign of how major banks are warming to cryptocurrencies.

Digital Assets

Alex Iakobachvili parts ways with B2Broker to join GCEX

GCEX, a digital asset and FX technology platform for institutional and professional clients, has appointed Alex Iakobachvili to the role of Vice President of Business Development.