XRP Lawsuit: Ripple could prove SEC lied about Hinman’s ‘personal opinions’

Rick Steves

“The SEC sent an email to a third party telling them to analyze a digital asset using the factors in the Hinman speech; which speech was just his personal opinion. I understand now – it’s the SEC that needs clarity!”, attorney Jeremy Hogan commented.

The SEC has opposed Ripple’s request to add three documents to the upcoming in-camera review to be conducted by Judge Sarah Netburn.

The agency stated those documents are not responsive to the Court’s prior orders, and the SEC placed the documents on a privilege log only in an (apparently futile) attempt to avoid disputes.

The plaintiff added that said documents “reflect deliberations by SEC staff, and have therefore been redacted or withheld pursuant to the deliberative privilege process”, according to the letter.

The SEC said there is “no need for the Court to review the three additional documents”, but if it finds appropriate to “pierce the privilege” and orders an in camera review, “the SEC respectfully requests that it be afforded the opportunity to make a submission explaining its privilege assertions for each of these documents, just as the Court did for the documents the SEC has already submitted in camera.

Documents may prove SEC’s Hinman 2018 speech was on behalf of agency, not a ‘personal opinion’

The SEC seems to have tried to keep the documents hidden from Ripple, but the team of lawyers detected the descriptions from the belatedly produced privilege log, which suggests they may be highly relevant to this case.

The documents include an email chain “concerning discussions with a third party whom Defendants understand received guidance from the SEC to analyze its digital asset under the framework set forth in Director William Hinman’s June 14, 2018 speech”.

The Defense team led by Matthew C. Solomon argued that the documents, based on the descriptions provided by the SEC, appeared to be most relevant to the claims and defenses in this case.

“The third is an email chain concerning discussions with a third party whom Defendants understand received guidance from the SEC to analyze its digital asset under the framework set forth in Director William Hinman’s June 14, 2018 speech. Had this privilege log been provided before Defendants filed its motion on August 10, 2021, Defendants would have included all three documents in Appendix A.

“Indeed, if the SEC had provided this privilege log any time in advance of the August 31 hearing, Defendants would have asked the Court to include these three documents in its in camera inspection. Instead, Defendants had to ask the SEC voluntarily to include the documents in its September 14 submission to the Court. The SEC filed its brief (ECF No. 355) without responding to this request.

“The next day, the SEC indicated that it would not submit these documents for the Court’s in camera review “absent a specific directive from the Court.”

Judge Sarah Netburn will soon be conducting the in-camera review of the SEC’s privilege log. It is not clear who the ‘third party’ mentioned in the log’s description is, but any guidance based on the framework set forth by William Hinman’s 2018 speech should be relevant.

Firstly, the document could explicitly prove Hinman’s speech was not merely a personal opinion, but the SEC’s official policy. This has been a key issue in the lawsuit.

“The SEC sent an email to a third party telling them to analyze a digital asset using the factors in the Hinman speech; which speech was just his personal opinion. I understand now – it’s the SEC that needs clarity!”, attorney Jeremy Hogan commented, pointing out the agency’s contradictions.

Secondly, the guidance provided to the ‘third party’ might also be relevant to show the SEC’s inconsistency in terms of regulatory clarity. This can be used to support Ripple’s fair notice defense, which claims the SEC failed to explain the firm and the broad digital asset space that XRP could be considered a security.

In the meantime, Ripple has just gained a heavy weight backer as the SEC v. Ripple could determine the future of the digital asset space. Former U.S. Treasurer Rosie Rios has come forth in defense of Ripple’s XRP currency value and utility via a simple tweet.

For more Ripple (XRP) related articles, click here.

Read this next

Digital Assets

UK crypto exchanges set to pay 2% tax

UK-based crypto exchanges would now need to pay a new 2% digital service tax as per some of the latest laws as the crypto regulations and classification in the UK continue to pose problems to regulators and users alike.

Digital Assets

Russian Duma’s working group to address gaps in crypto regulation

A working group formed by the Russian State Duma to tackle the issues of cryptocurrency regulations is set to hold its first meetings, said the head of the parliamentary Financial Market Committee, Anatoly Aksakov.

Digital Assets

Kevin O’Leary says XRP lawsuit is “a very bad idea”

“I have zero interest in investing in litigation against the SEC, that is a very bad idea”.

Industry News

SFC freezes 17 client accounts on suspected ‘pump-and-dump’ scam

Hong Kong’s financial watchdog, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), has issued notices to two local brokers, instructing them to freeze certain client accounts suspected of market manipulation.

Retail FX

FSCS starts to offer LCF investors compensation under government scheme

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) has gone live with the government’s redress scheme to reimburse eligible London Capital & Finance victims.

Industry News

Aquis Exchange appoints Glenn Collinson as new Chair

Aquis Exchange, a group of companies that provide services for exchanges, has announced the appointment of Glenn Collinson as its new Chair and he would succeed Niki Beattie effective from January 1, 2022.

Digital Assets

Bitpanda onboards Lydia’s 5.5 million users to white label solution

Lydia has deployed the white label solution, with transactions made by the more than 5 million Lydia customers in a wide range of assets, from crypto to fractional stocks, being executed via Bitpanda for as little as EUR 1.

Digital Assets

Archax deploys Scila AB’s AML and surveillance tech for crypto trading

Scila is very much in tune with digital assets and cryptocurrencies and has some of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges and traders in its client roster.

Institutional FX, Retail FX

ATFX goes all in on US equities: FX broker adds 113 US stock CFDs

With the addition of 113 US stock CFDs, ATFX boasts more than  300 tradable instruments, 273 of which are stock CFD products.

<