XRP lawsuit: Ripple counts on Judge to control SEC’s redactions, submission by April 8

Rick Steves

The United States District Court for the Southern District of New York has ordered the Securities and Exchange Commission to submit its proposed redactions for in camera review no later than April 8, 2022.

Magistrate Judge Netburn has ordered the plaintiff to do so in order to proceed to analyze the redactions and ascertain whether she agrees with the SEC’s understanding of what portions should be protected by deliberative process privilege (DPP).

Given the history of the DPP debate throughout the lawsuit, there are some expectations that the SEC will look to redact the internal documents as much as possible, claiming it is privileged information, thus leaving Ripple without much to use against the SEC in court.

Judge Sarah Netburn seems to be aware of the SEC’s inclination to redact and has stated, in a previous court ruling, that the regulator failed to convince the court the 11 sets of notes are protected by DPP and that none of these notes appear to contain any personal observations or commentary by the third-parties nor any attorney-client communications or work product.

The court only allowed the SEC to redact the 11 notes to accommodate the SEC’s wishes to redact any portion that expressly reflect the third-parties’ own thinking or reflect deliberations or communications among the SEC staff.

The privilege does not shield these notes from production

In Judge Netburn’s original ruling regarding these notes, the order stated “The SEC has not established that these 11 sets of notes demonstrate the kind of exercise of judgment necessary for the privilege to apply.

“Fact gathering from third parties is not an inherently privileged activity; the SEC itself notes that information about what occurred at such meetings can be requested from those third parties.

“Nothing in the notes suggests that certain facts were recorded while others were purposely omitted as an exercise of judgment or deliberation, and the SEC has not submitted any declarations by notes’ authors attesting to their method or manner of note-taking.

“Nor do the notes appear to reflect any personal observations or commentary by their authors. The privilege does not shield these notes from production. To the extent, however, that any portions of the notes expressly reflect the authors’ own thinking or reflect deliberations or communications among the SEC staff during the meeting, the SEC may seek leave to redact such portions.

“As interpreted by the Court, none of these notes appears to contain attorney-client communications or work product.”

Earlier this week, Ripple admitted that it relies on the SEC’s representations and the Court’s review to determine whether the redacted portions “expressly reflect the authors’ own thinking or reflect deliberations or communications among SEC staff during the meeting.”

Ripple argued that, because only the Court and the SEC have seen the unredacted documents, the defendants must defer to the Court to decide whether the redacted portions are in fact protected by the DPP.

On March 23, the SEC requested the court to redact portions of the handwritten notes taken by SEC staff who attended certain meetings between the SEC and third parties, arguing these portions are protected by the deliberative process privilege (“DPP”).

“The handwritten portions in question expressly reflect either (1) the authors’ thoughts regarding subject matters discussed during meetings and/or (2) deliberations among SEC staff during meetings”, the SEC stated.

Read this next

Digital Assets

BlackRock digs further into crypto with metaverse ETF

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager with almost $10 trillion in AUM, is set to launch a new metaverse ETF to help investors securely monetize on the booming immersive version of the internet.

Digital Assets

Binance wins license in New Zealand as rival Huobi shutters derivatives

Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange by traded volume, has obtained licenses to operate in New Zealand, even after rival Huobi shutdown derivatives trading last month due to concerns about regulations.

Retail FX

Hong Kong busts perpetrators of ‘ramp and dump’ scam

Hong Kong’s financial watchdog, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), has charged thirteen suspects of market manipulation in a joint operation with the local police.

Institutional FX

TradingView integrates market data from German Tradegate exchange

TradingView announced that it ‎has increased data coverage to allow its users to receive information from ‎and get free access to the intra-day and tick data from Tradegate Exchange.

Retail FX

Spotware Systems introduces Custom Push Notifications for cTrader mobile apps

Spotware Systems, a technology provider for the electronic trading industry, is introducing a new push notification feature to alert mobile users of price swings and market fluctuations through their cTrader app.

Market News

The Week Ahead: 30 September from David Madden, Market Analyst at Equiti Group

Sterling dominated the headlines last week, as there were concerns the UK government might struggle to service its debt.

Inside View

How does the quality of signal providers affect your business?

A must-have onboarding process for brokers with investment services like PAMM, MAM, or copy trading


DBS deploys Nasdaq Trade Surveillance

“The confidence that markets and our clients have in DBS as a safe and trusted banking group is anchored on our ability to detect and respond to anomalous activity, which in turn calls for a robust surveillance and prevention infrastructure.”

Industry News

SEC charges Justin Costello and David Ferraro for securities fraud and posing as billionaire veteran

The Securities and Exchange Commission charged Cannabis executive Justin Costello and David Ferraro, an associate of Costello’s, for promoting the stock of several microcap companies on social media without disclosing their own simultaneous stock sales as market prices rose.