CFTC Stump questions charges against Kraken: “How would it have been expected to operate?”

Rick Steves

The CFTC Commissioner concluded that the application of the Commission’s FCM rules to an exchange on which retail commodity transactions are traded is uncharted territory at this time.

The CFTC has yesterday settled charges with San Francisco-based cryptocurrency exchange Kraken, which has agreed to pay a $1.25 million civil penalty.

The venue has allegedly illegally hosted leveraged cryptocurrency trades and failed to register as a futures commission merchant (FCM) and served as the sole margin provider and maintained physical custody of all clients’ assets.

As such, the platform operated a facility to trade cryptocurrencies without being approved as a Designated Contract Market and acted as an Eligible Contract Participants (ECP), without registering as such with the CFTC.

The CFTC found that Kraken violated CEA Section 4 because it engaged in retail commodity transactions that are prohibited by the CEA unless traded on or subject to the rules of a DCM – a registration designation that has neither been requested by nor granted to Kraken. But it also finds that Kraken operated as an unregistered FCM with respect to those transactions.

CFTC Commissioner Dawn Stump has issued a concurring statement on the matter to further explain why Kraken violated U.S. regulations and called for regulatory clarity.

The Commission’s finding that Kraken engaged in prohibited retail commodity transactions is informed by its Final Interpretive Guidance on retail commodity transactions involving certain digital assets issued in 2020, she said.

“However, as the Guidance becomes increasingly relevant to the Commission’s enforcement program, I believe it is incumbent upon the Commission to undertake a rulemaking proceeding to supersede the Guidance by adopting binding and enforceable rules that will provide certainty to the marketplace and a shared understanding of the “rules of the road”.

“I agree with his observation that “[i]n the rapidly developing world of digital assets, two years is a lifetime” – and yet now we are an additional year-and-a-half later still. I believe, therefore, that the Commission should act to replace the Guidance with rules that are based on current input from market participants and members of the public”.

In regard to the unregistered FCM finding, the Commission has long held that certain speculative commodity transactions involving leverage are futures contracts that must be traded on a designated contract market that is subject to Commission oversight.

“However, court decisions called that view into question with respect to certain leveraged transactions involving retail participants”, the CFTC Commissioner continued.

If Kraken had sought to register with the Commission as an FCM, how would it have been expected to operate?

“Absent these transactions occurring on a DCM, they would continue to be illegal even if Kraken had an FCM registration”, Commissioner Stump pointed out. ”

“Furthermore, how Kraken would be regulated as an FCM is not entirely clear, because many of the Commission’s rules governing its regulation of traditional FCMs do not fit Kraken’s role as an exchange. It also would be unprecedented for an entity to register as both a DCM and an FCM.”

The CFTC Commissioner concluded that the application of the Commission’s FCM rules to an exchange on which retail commodity transactions are traded is uncharted territory at this time.

“I believe that if the Commission is going to hold an exchange liable for operating as an unregistered FCM with respect to retail commodity transactions, it is incumbent upon the Commission to explain in a transparent manner the relevant legal requirements for such an entity that seeks to register as an FCM and how the Commission will apply them in enabling the entity to conduct business with U.S. customers”.

Read this next

Industry News

21 Republican representatives want to “End the Fed”

“Americans are suffering under crippling inflation, and the Federal Reserve is to blame.”

Retail FX

Scope Markets launches unleveraged trading

“Whilst our traditional contract for difference (CFD) products continue to prove incredibly popular, the Invest account is unleveraged and only allows ‘long’ positions to be taken, a combination that significantly reduces the risk of capital losses.”


Unlocking Profit Potential: Earn Returns with DecodeEX Experience Bonus!

DecodeEX, the innovative brokerage subsidiary of Decode Global, announced its experience bonus campaign, offering every user the opportunity to maximize their strategic trading potential with up to $10,000 in experience bonus. 

Market News

Pretiorates’ Thoughts 28 – Precious metals and base metals out of control

Ten days ago we mentioned in Pretiorates’ Thoughts 26: Chapter 2 should start with Precious Metals.

Retail FX

Webull launches discount brokerage in Malaysia

“Making investing more inclusive and accessible to all, Webull Malaysia brings best-in-class tools and information to empower investors of all levels with knowledge and skills to help them make better investment decisions and achieve their investment goals.”

Digital Assets

Hidden Road adds OKX’s Nitro Spreads into prime brokerage

“Hidden Road continually seeks to increase market access and capital efficiency through expanded prime brokerage offerings. Integrating OKX’s Nitro Spreads product builds upon this philosophy by extending our counterparties’ ability to execute risk-managed arbitrage strategies.”


Dev Release 31: BlockDAG’s SHA-3 Upgrades Propel Crypto Mining Innovation as Miner Sales Approach 5800 Units

Learn about BlockDAG’s 31st Development Release, which includes advanced SHA-3 updates and a significant increase in miner sales, driving advancements.


BlockDAG Dominates 2024 Crypto Trends: Surpasses $28M in Presales Amid Strategic Partnerships

Explore BlockDAG, Shiba Inu, and Kaspa Killer’s rise in 2024’s crypto market, focusing on BlockDAG’s $28M presales, strategic partnerships, and innovative technology.


BlockDAG’s $30 by 2030 Valuation Prediction and Roadmap Reveal Gains Traction From Filecoin and XLM Investors

Discover why BDAG’s $30 price prediction by 2030 outshines Filecoin Investors’ hopes and XLM’s recent surge with a booming presale and clear roadmap.